r/auslaw•
AzMoo

Dishonesty laws and politics

So the thing that I hate most about politics is the spreading of misinformation and outright lies to justify a policy position or gain political advantage.

In Australia we have a bunch of laws that relate to dishonest actions, and I'm specifically looking at Division 5 of this document: http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/sa/bill/clcodab2002564/

Is there any reason this wouldn't apply to politicians? If not, why aren't they ever held to account legally for their dishonest actions? I understand parliamentary privilege would shield them from this when they're making statements in parliament, but what about on the campaign trail?

Posted Aug 15, 2014, 2:45 AM UTC

019
anappropriatename•

If not, why aren't they ever held to account legally for their dishonest actions?

Politicians are held accountable every 3, 4 or 6 years when they face an election.

They are also held accountable to the Speaker of the House which they belong and to various other bodies.

I understand parliamentary privilege would shield them from this when they're making statements in parliament, but what about on the campaign trail?

Because when Politicians do things that you call lying they're more often than not talking about future intentions and it is incredibly difficult to prove that at the time of making the statement, the person didn't hold that intention.

When Politicians make statements of fact that they represent to be correct which are incorrect, it is relatively easy to prove them wrong and they are usually punished. For example, Peter Slipper.

EDIT: I dun writed bad.

9
AzMooOP•

Politicians are held accountable every 3, 4 or 6 years when they face an election.

That is not the accountability I'm talking about. I mean legally.

So in this particular case you've linked, which I will admit prompted the question, if there were some kind of evidence to show that they did have an intention to cut funds to the ABC (like an email or recording stating such an intention) and claimed otherwise before the election, would this fit the criteria?

If we look at u/wogmafia's dot points, we could say that we meet the specificity requirement because we have clear video statements of the claims, the politician clearly knew their conduct was dishonest (intended to do one thing while saying another), and the dishonesty benefitted themselves and the Coalition as a whole.

The only one that seems like it would be difficult to meet is whether the politician mistakenly believed that they had a legal right to lie to the Australian public, but surely that would stretch the bounds of credibility? They are familiar with these laws as evidenced by their involvement in other cases such as Slipper's. What exactly would you need to prove this?

-5
iamplasma•

the politician clearly knew their conduct was dishonest (intended to do one thing while saying another

How do you know that beyond reasonable doubt? I defy you to prove to a legal standard (ie not just declaring "it's obvious" in r/australia) that it was a lie at the time it was said.

9
AzMooOP•

if there were some kind of evidence to show that they did have an intention to cut funds to the ABC (like an email or recording stating such an intention) and claimed otherwise before the election

My statements are based on this hypothetical.

-2
wogmafia•

Even hypothetical situations need to have grounding in reality. Proving someones intention to be dishonest is extremely difficult. Sure, like you said if you have an email or video recording of them specifically saying I am being dishonest but realistically that is not going to happen.

Simply saying one thing in public and another in private, does not automatically prove you were being dishonest.

4
anappropriatename•

Other commentators have explained the evidentiary difficulties in obtaining a finding of guilt.

Let me tell you what the defence would likely say:

It's not a lie because the ABC and SBS portfolios were not "cut" in the budget.

By definition, to "cut" something, it must be abridged or shortened, reduced by an omission or reduction.

In 2013-14, ABC and SBS received $1.539 billion.

In 2014-15, ABC and SBS received $1.549 billion.

Can you show me how that is a cut please? The numbers have increased.

Source Table 11.1

It is true that ABC reported that their budget had been "cut" by thirty million. What they left out is that that was a reduction in the planned increase, not a reduction in the actual allocated amount.

So it is arguable that even taken at its most literal, the statement wasn't a lie.

3
AzMooOP•

Right, fair enough. So what about the ICAC proceedings in which politicians are admitting to practices which the general Australian public would consider dishonest? Take Barry O'Farrell for example, who intentionally misled ICAC in an effort to save his political career. That's fully documented, lead to his resignation, and appears to fit all the required criteria. Why is it that Slipper is hit with these charges while O'Farrell wasn't? The circumstances seem very similar to me.

EDIT: This is ridiculous. Is it because I'm asking about Liberal politicians? What about Eddie Obeid, who the Commission actually recommended the DPP to consider prosecution? Why aren't these laws being universally applied?

-6
iamplasma•

Take Barry O'Farrell for example, who intentionally misled ICAC in an effort to save his political career.

What the hell are you talking about?

This is exactly why everybody is viewing you as a hyper-partisan poster. You are making an unqualified accusation that Barry O'Farrell intentionally misled ICAC. That is not "documented" at all!

Did Barry give an incorrect answer to a question? Yes. Can you prove, aside from slimy innuendo or assumption, that he intentionally gave incorrect evidence? Absolutely not!

Your posts really, really, smack of a desire to just get people to join you in an anti-Liberals circlejerk.

3
wogmafia•

Firstly, you want the Act not the Bill

http://www.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/sa/consol_act/clca1935262/

You need to go through the elements:

  • Was a specific conduct of the politician dishonest by the standards of ordinary people?

  • Did the politician know their conduct was dishonest?

  • Did the politician honestly but mistakenly believes that they have a legal or equitable right to act in that way?

  • Did that dishonest conduct cause benefit to themselves or another, or detriment to deceived person or another?

You are going to fall down on knowledge that the conduct was dishonest, because they will bullshit on about changing circumstances, or I was not aware, etc. You would need contemporaneous evidence showing the politician knew they were being dishonest.

Also there is an issue of the protection of the implied right to political communication, which is quite complex. Interestingly, even if the implied right does not protect this type of conduct, the politicians mistaken belief that it does would be enough to get them off.

Then you get to the mechanics of charging someone for a crime like this. The DPP is controlled by the Executive Government, and no politician is going to create a precedent where other parliament members are charged for lying. It just opens up a can of worms for them once they get kicked out of office.

TL:DR... Not going to happen

4
burito•

Did the politician honestly but mistakenly believes that they have a legal or equitable right to act in that way?

What happened to "ignorance of the law is no defence"?

2
_sapi_•

What happened to "ignorance of the law is no defence"?

Nothing happened to it.

wogmafia is citing directly from the Act. That exception / defence is the law.

4
jaytee190•

There's a difference between ignorance of the law and holding a mistaken belief as to facts. Most serious crimes require a mental culpability (often, knowledge of the facts that make the act or omission wrongful).

3
iamplasma•

Sometimes the law, or at least your perception of your rights under the law, is a relevant fact.

For example, if I mistakenly believe the legal effect of a contract is to give me the right to take your car, and I then take your car, I'm not guilty of stealing that car even if it later turns out that my legal interpretation of the contract was wrong, because a genuine belief that one has a right to possession defeats such a charge.

3
AzMooOP•

You would need contemporaneous evidence showing the politician knew they were being dishonest.

Would something like a private email or voice recording from before the election stating their intention suffice?

the politicians mistaken belief that it does would be enough to get them off.

This seems like the deal breaker to me.

2†