A tour of the British Isles in accents (in only 90 seconds!)

Posted Aug 16, 2014, 7:00 PM UTC

11243
r_m_8_8Taco | Burger | Sushi•

Non-native speaker here, I understand less and less the more it moves to the north, lol.

19
FratmanBootcakeEnglish N | German B1 | Русский A2 •

Don't worry, that applies to natives too.

17
thepeff•

That's probably why he didn't attempt a Geordie accent in this video!

2
clinchgtES, EN, DE, NO, JP•

Dat flair, tho

10
GehalgodL1: EN | L2: DE, SV, RU, GA•

Thinking of changing my flair to

"L1: Freedom | L2: Beer, Blondes, Vodka, Catholics, Clogs"

2
Angelov95•

Non native too, and I started hating North Yorkshire accent watching Britain's got talent.

1
Atarian091•

Is that really enough to throw you off? It doesn't seem that much worse (if even a little easier) than my Aussie accent (which I thought was mild).

-2
blanky1Eng N | Deutsch B2 | Español A2•

I think this may be a more accurate and comprehensive demonstration of British accents.

6
Phlebas99•

Nobody yet has tried Manc.

A very dirty accent seen in the Gallagher's: Oasis and Shameless.

7
englad•

Manc here, it's because nobody wants to hear our accent

2
Mezzra•

Really? I think she's far worse than the original video

2
iandiochEqually poor in English, Gaeilge & Français•

Her Dublin is so much better than the other fella. Not perfect, but so so much closer.

1
xela88•

I disagree

2
[deleted]•

Her East Anglian was too West Country, they don't pronounce their Rs. She also pronounced dance in her Brummie accent like a south-easterner would, "dahnce" instead of DANce.

1
gufcfanEnglish, Irish, French (Beginner)•

Nar narn accent was half-right.

Dublin accent was completely off. Most of the others were good enough.

Welsh accent sounded like a good impression of Rhod Gilbert.

4
galaxyrocker🇺🇸English N | Gaeilge TEG B2•

I didn't watch it - which Dublin accent was used? Please tell me they didn't try to imitate D4...

2
gufcfanEnglish, Irish, French (Beginner)•

No Dublin accent.

3
iandiochEqually poor in English, Gaeilge & Français•

He should have skipped it altogether. It would have also saved the argument about Ireland being in the British Isles in the comments...

3
gufcfanEnglish, Irish, French (Beginner)•

Idiots will always argue in youtube comments.

2
DreadfortReek•

Dublin accent sounded like Dara O'Brien to me.

2
yuumeiEnglish N | 日本語 B1•

No brummie accent? :(

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
iandiochEqually poor in English, Gaeilge & Français•

Ach bhí sé i bhfad níos fearr ná a bhlas ó mBaile Átha Cliath.

(I'm guessing you won't be against a little Irish in such a place as this! So few opportunities to use it)

1
diana_mt•

And I love all these accents! God damn I love the English language!

2
hyperforceEnglish N | Portuguese A1 | Filipino | Latin•

I wonder if someone could do this for the States.

Mur'ka!

1
didgeriduff•

With the exception of some southern dialects there is little variation. The Midwest certainly sounds different from the coasts. But it's hardly the difference between say Essex from a Geordie accent. It wouldn't be that entertaining with the exception of a few cities on the east coast like Boston or New York. Even then, the New York a accent is actually dying out whereas these are still very much alive.

Additionally these are so spatially packed that it's truly interesting. I have a friend who can tell from what part of his relatively small town you are from by the way they speak. And he can certainly tell the difference between his town and the next big town 12 miles away. And they dislike each other. This doesn't really work in American terms. You might be able to tell that someone is from south Boston. But this is a massive city and to be honest you would be basing this on their accent only existing there because of the relative gentrification in Boston proper. But if you talked with Townies in Somerville or Charlestown they would really sound the same. He'll go up to Lynn or something and it still sounds the same. America lacks the accent diversity that makes this a truly exemplary and interesting video.

4
iwanttoseethestars•

Source re: the New York accent dying out?

6
whimseaEnglish N, Español A1•

There's way more variation than you think there is. There's standard American, Philadelphia/South Jersey, New York (maybe it's starting to go away, but my dad and his whole family speak with this accent. It'll still be here for a while...), Boston, Maine, North Midwest, Chicago, Texas, Virginia, Deep Southeast, and California. Each of these accents sounds extremely distinct to me, and yeah, these areas aren't packed together, but that's a fair amount of variation.

While American accents aren't spatially packed, saying there's only one midwestern accent or one southern accent is simply wrong. Someone from Chicago sounds very different than someone from Minnesota, and someone from Savannah sounds incredibly different than someone from Dallas. It's true that you have to travel farther to hear different accents, but the diversity is still there.

4
lgf92English N | Français C1 | Русский B2 | Deutsch B1•

But the variation in the UK is even more remarkable, considering that the UK is about the same size as Oregon.

2
whimseaEnglish N, Español A1•

Yes, I don't dispute that. It's amazing that you get multiple accents in the city of London itself, which the video didn't even show. OP just said there was "little variation" in American accents, so my only point was that that was wrong. I never implied that the variation was more impressive than the accents in the UK (I don't think it is), just that it exists. I also said many times that the US is larger so the variation is much more spread out. My only point is that it exists. This is not a country made up of 3 accents: standard, midwest, and southern.

1
want_to_live_in_NL•

My NY family all talks with distinct NY accent. we joke with them about it because were from CA. There are definitely a lot of regional accent differences, they're just not usually as pronounced.

1
iwanttoseethestars•

Seconding this. Also, most of my (huge) family has a Lawn Guyland accent, and it's hard to imagine it going away any time soon.

1
rmc•

Yes the USA has about as much variation as the UK in terms of accents. However the UK is tiny compared to the USA.

USA is the same size as Europe (ish). And that has loads of variation!

1
lgf92English N | Français C1 | Русский B2 | Deutsch B1•

You're deluding yourself if you think that the USA is as diverse as Europe just cos it's a similar size.

3
didgeriduff•

Yeah. I'll give you that. I am American. And from the Midwest. I was just saying that the differences are not nearly as marked. Sure. You could make a video and it could be interesting. I'm simply amazed by HOW different things are in the UK.

1
j4p4nCurrently learning: Chinese, German, Korean, Indonesian, etc•

The other commenter said you couldn't do that with American accents, but this guy does that with American accents (with good ideas like Navajo and Mexican, which are part of the American accent sphere I guess) but he also has British and Irish, Indian etc and so he is really just showing all his accent abilities I guess. But I imagine America as a 'global melting pot' so I guess that works too?

2
Zaridana•

That was very impressive, but since when was Perth and Kinross the Highlands?

1
[deleted]•

My God his Liverpool was terrible.

1
GehalgodL1: EN | L2: DE, SV, RU, GA•

ITT: People don't think their own accent was well represented. Who would have thought?

1
MiG_Pilot_87•

This video has informed me of one thing. My Scottish accent is closest to Glasgow. (I'm American but I have heard my scottish accent is pretty good, even from a Scottish friend)

-11