Need help vs Mech
I'm a high master player and I always feel lost vs mech. Never know what composition to aim for, when to expand, whether to be passive or aggressive. Any help or theorycrafting would be greatly appreciated. http://drop.sc/385178 http://drop.sc/385179
Posted Aug 22, 2014, 9:42 PM UTC
I am a mid Diamond player so take what I say with a pinch of salt but I think both of these games are bad examples of you losing vs mech since you were never on even footing or ahead, both games you were behind on workers early on and never had the advantage now sure the harrass was mech but E.g on the second game were he attacks with hellions a wall off was necessary to deal with that and in the first game I felt you dealth very well with the widow mine harass but it did put you on the back foot.
Now even though both of these games aren't that good of an example in my opinion. Here we go, The 2 styles were different in the first game on nimbus it was a hellbat maruader tank style which had been featured in a day9 daily (without the tanks) in my opinion gateway units melt to that comp and the only way I found to deal with it was immortal collosus void ray. second game vs heavy hellbat army with few tanks ( never played against it so not sure) your best bet is voids to focus fire tank/thor and stalker/immortal to clean up rest stalker does well vs hellbat and immortal are generally good vs more tanks.
GL HF and good luck vs terran mech. (if you have any other replays vs mech I think we could help you a lot more from them because simply having a max 200/200 mech army vs any composition protoss at 130 is gg)
Colossus.... are you serious? It's the absolute worst unit aside from sentry that you can build vs mech.
Thing is it is not pure mech it is maruader/hellbat style which colossus is decent against. if it was pure tank/thor/hellion I would agree with you.
What about when they get ghosts out? Immortals become pretty useless. I think then some collosus are needed.
I'll just answer you both with Yeah I get the thought behind what you're thinking. What people like to do is get High templar to Storm not only the hellbats and ground but also the vikings if they get too close. Colossus fall too fast against tanks, especially if they focus fire, it's just not a good investment. High templars will accomplish the same thing and also be good against the vikings, so get that instead!
I think you're right I was behind in the beginning from both games, but I don't know what I should do to stop that from happening. There is so many different things terran can in the early game. Like in the second game by the time I scouted he was going hellions it was too late to walloff. Also the 200/200 vs 130/supply is because he has hellbats which are really cheap so he will always have the supply advantage.