In Defence of Olivia Chow
Hey r/toronto.
I've couched this post as "In Defence of Olivia Chow", which may essentially be saying "Please don't downvote me". And I understand that this subreddit can be very moderate, and very intelligent, and that "don't downvote me" is a key for "downvote me", unless you're posting it ironically on askreddit, or un ironically as a test, but...I'm going to go for it.
Before I start this in earnest, I want to qualify this by saying that I’m currently voting strategically first (on an anything-but-Ford basis) and Soknacki second. I’m a policy wonk, and also a westerner; and while I respect Saskatchewan’s history of social policy, I was also raised in an era of western fiscal conservatism, so Soknacki is a beautiful melding of those three worlds for me. I've been a supporter for him since day 1, and have probably tired a number of people on this sub with my support (I've luckily never been called out as a shill account, probably because I have a series of remarkably stupid posts in my history).
I saw a facebook status from an someone, a self proclaimed progressive who I respect earlier today disparaging the Olivia Chow campaign, and I’ve been hesitant to react to it, due to the two of us not knowing each other terribly well, my reticence to engage politically on social media, and this being my virginal (can I use that word? I’m going to) Toronto Municipal Election. But I’ve been following the campaign pretty closely, and I feel like I want to voice something concerning the Olivia Chow, and the continuing cynicism of the left in terms of her campaign.
Also, I’m going to take most of these sources from TorStar, which is absolutely a biased source, but I also believe the only one of the major three newspapers with any degree of national political conscience, and I might not cite some of them due to facebook’s character limits, so I hope you’ll forgive me. In tearing down the other two major sources (this is speaking only of their Toronto Municipal Election based reporting, and is no reflection on their national, international, business, or art related reporting) The National Post vouched strongly for Rob Ford, and recently ironized a Toronto Star article from 2010 saying Pantalone/Rossi/Thompson should drop out of the race, and swapped names with Chow/Soknacki/Thompson should drop out of the race. So they’re holding fast with an idea that only two conservative candidates should be allowed to run in the municipal election. And the Globe and Mail supported Tim Hudak (I think I have to include this http://www.theglobeandmail.com/globe-debate/editorials/ontario-election-part-4-for-a-conservative-minority/article19047636/#dashboard/follows/) even though he was routinely mocked within his own party (Soknacki has identified as PC at least once to my knowledge, and Tory has cited the Hudak campaign to sweep his own PC run under the rug as to how difficult it is to be a conservative in central Canada) [I guess that is a reflection of their provincial reporting...so I’ve already established a falsehood, but considering Tory was the leader of the PC party and both Doug and Rob have vouched for said party, and Soknacki, my preferred candidate has supported that party at times, I’m not going to delete it, and I’m going to let it stand as a part of my bias]. The Toronto Star backed their reporters to break the multiple Ford scandals, which is a godsend for honest reporters in Canada, and has continually been the only voice of both the centre and the left in municipal politics since I’ve called this city my home. So I’m using it as my source, as biased as it is.
Now, moving on from my bias, the Toronto municipal campaign has been structured around three things as far as I can see: 1) Taxes, 2) Transit, and 3) Character. And while this is absolutely not enough to structure a campaign around, since it has been the majority of the dialogue, I’d like to break those down between the three frontrunners.
- Taxes.
Olivia chow says: “...her property tax increases will be “in line” with inflation.” “John is committed to keeping taxes at or below the rate of inflation.” (Toronto SUN) “Ford said he’s committed to keeping taxes “a lot lower” than the rate of inflation.” (Toronto SUN)
However, Joe Pennachetti, the city manager, who is the be-all-and-the-end-all (that’s totally not how you type that) when it comes to municipal taxes, has been cited multiple times as saying the city needs ““We need new tax revenues. We can’t survive any more just on property taxes,” (http://www.thestar.com/news/city_hall/2014/05/13/toronto_needs_new_taxes_city_manager_says.html).
Tory and Ford have also been citing Tax Increment Financing as a method of paying for all their proposed initiatives, a method of borrowing which has yet to prove successful in the developed world despite multiple attempts at using it to please an electorate (http://www.thestar.com/opinion/commentary/2014/08/30/john_torys_smarttrack_doesnt_live_up_to_its_name.html).
Meanwhile, Olivia Chow has proposed, while admittedly quite weak, a progressive tax on the highest valued homes in Toronto (http://www.thestar.com/news/city_hall/toronto2014election/2014/09/02/olivia_chow_promises_progressive_land_transfer_tax_hike_on_2m_homes.html). This progressivity is in line with NDP values, and indeed in line with most leftist thought on how to effectively raise capital for public programs (Thomas Pikkety is hugely in favor of progressive rates, moreso on capital gains and inheritance, but he’s very much a French leftist from my understanding, with a skeptical but ultimately a fundamental belief in the powers of Capitalism).
- Transit.
Do we even need to talk about Rob Ford’s transit plan? Matt Elliot will take it down in Metro (Again, a TorStar source http://metronews.ca/voices/ford-for-toronto/1143482/rob-fords-bad-transit-plan-is-based-on-illusory-math/). The man is making horribly empty promises about selling air space and public-private-partnerships, which he’s never been able to deliver on. He’s a joke.
However, Tory is walking on the same imaginary tightrope. He’s managed to convince the public that his takeover of a provincial liberal plan is a solution, and his promises about budget (http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news/toronto/john-torys-smarttrack-why-his-big-bet-on-transit-is-a-real-risk/article20177429/#dashboard/follows/) and timeline (http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2014/08/26/is_john_torys_smarttrack_on_track_for_sevenyear_delivery.html) are both pie in the sky promises.
Meanwhile, Olivia Chow has been mostly running on a platform of cancelling the scarborough subway, reinstating Transit City, and increasing bus service. And admittedly, again, even her bus service idea has problems. In this article: http://www.thestar.com/news/gta/2014/03/27/olivia_chows_plan_a_reminder_of_the_importance_of_buses_to_the_ttc.html there is a mention of accessibility problems “But there is also the question of accessibility. The TTC thinks adding new low-floor streetcars and articulated buses will allow Wheel-Trans passengers to use the conventional system for more trips. This would not be possible with the older buses.” without Olivia answering how she plans on having a bus fleet with mixed accessibility. There’s also the fact that those buses are OLD. And maybe they shouldn’t be kept on the road anymore. (Here Karen Stintz says old busses will cause more gridlock - (take Karen’s view for what you will. I put her only a small step about RF http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/olivia-chow-wants-more-buses-karen-stintz-wants-a-transit-fund-1.2625971).
So there’s no solid plan for Transit. Were a very young city that only started investing in our public transit ~50 years ago, and we’ve had continual freezes since then. That being said, we’re being compared to cities like NYC, London, Tokyo, Paris, etc. in the rhetoric of all the mayoral hopefuls, and we’re just not the same city. Many of those cities had invested substantially in underground infrastructure around the beginning of the 20th century. We didn’t enter into the game until the era of the skyscraper.
- Character.
This is a personal thing. I’m not going to try and negatively shape anyone’s opinions about Ford or Tory. I will say for Olivia that:
1)Chow is the reason that non-English speakers can dial 911 in a crisis and get someone on the phone who understands them. She pushed for multilingual 911 service, which now includes 140 languages.
-
Olivia helped create the program when she was a city councillor. It’s one of the city’s most inexpensive, delivering activities such as music and sports to kids aged 6-12. Fees are low, just $2.34 per child per day, with about a third of participants getting it for free because they live in priority neighbourhoods
-
(and these are my own words) Olivia Chow is a lifelong public servant (in my view, this is a good thing, as I see the government as a check and balance to corporate powers, rather than an entity in their service), having served Canadian citizens on the Toronto District School Board, Toronto City Council, and as a Member of Parliament. She’s the only major candidate who has stated that they will improve transit service to underprivileged and underserved areas of Toronto (despite the fact that he’s a total wanker, Kinsella’s allegation that Tory is segregationist is, while slanderous in reality, effectively not incorrect), and has a substantial amount of federal connections, as well as a willingness to work with the three tiered system that a financial capital like Toronto must operate in. (Tory has this as well, I’m going to vouch for him here: he has massive business and political connections.)
I feel like, and I’ve been getting more personal as this post has run its course, that Olivia is caught up in a spiral of Canadian politics, particularly Ontarian politics, where we’ve taken a general leap away from the left, due to a) The unfortunate passing of Jack Layton b) The failure of the orange crush c) the horrendous failure of Andrea Horwath, and d) the emergence of Justin Trudeau. But Olivia is the real deal. She’s been a moderate, intelligent, progressive voice in Canadian politics for longer than I’ve been alive. She’s the only major candidate running on a campaign whose numbers aren’t imaginary (and I don’t mean complex numbers, I mean fake ones).
There seems to me to be a hesitance towards her campaign from the left, from her base, from the “intelligentsia”, because she isn’t promising us a pot of gold at the end of the rainbow like Horwath did with her austerity minister, like Hudak did with his jobs platform, like Obama did with hope and change, like Ford is with subways, subways, subways. She’s asking for a mild offering from the wealthy to pay for after school programs, bus routes in underserved areas, and an honest reflection on the year-to-year abilities of the public purse.
I’m sorry if any of this seems inflammatory, but I feel she’s an incredible public servant, and the only one of the major candidates who has had any degree of honesty with the public. And more and more among my peers, she’s being attacked for not promising enough. But I still believe in moderate progressivity, and I can’t stand to watch the spin of the media delude the electorate into thinking the only candidate who is acting in an accountable fashion is some kind of leech on the public system.
Yeah, my post is biased. Her gun control idea is stupid. Her transit plan has been attacked for its financial viability, but we're talking a financial viability of $15m vs $8b or (not even close to realistically) $9b. That's what, x200 the cost for increasing public transit? The idea is far from perfect, and far from fully formed, but there's at least a little reason in it. And that's why I post this, to appeal to a bit of reason in an electorate. Ford talks about minding the pennies, and letting the dollars watch themselves, but the dollars are running away from him, and Tory is trying to fight him with his own numbers. I want to make a case for Olivia Chow, and say that she's running a real campaign, and shouldn't be continually shut down as a weak candidate for not promising nirvana.
Posted Sep 4, 2014, 1:27 AM UTC
Her performance as a candidate is just terrible. She let Warren Kinsella be part of her campaign and he's a fuckup. As it stands now, she's where she deserves to be in the race.
I'll agree, her performance as a candidate hasn't been stellar. There's been a lot of uncertainty. And Kinsella is the worst. I can't stand him.
My main point with this post, and I feel like I didn't get it across properly, is that the reason that her performance as a candidate has been seen as disastrous is because she's been so much more moderate than Tory or Ford. Ford obviously lies to the public continually, and has the 20% crazy base, as well as a number of people who vote for him for whatever reason.
But the main point of Tory's campaign is this SmartTrack promise, and it doesn't make any sense to me. At 15 minute intervals, it doesn't serve the populace, it's not payable with TIF, and it's not even in his jurisdiction to promise.
So while Olivia is a bad public speaker, has Kinsella on her team, and has made major blunders like the gun ban (it is an astoundingly stupid policy, one which I hope any reasonable council would shoot down immediately), I feel she is the only major candidate who is telling the truth financially, and who is representing the entirety of the city.
Olivia is not a bad public speaker. Olivia is a bad candidate. She goes on Metro Morning without simple talking points and even Matt Galloway's softball questions make her look like an ass. She forgets that she is running for mayor, not MP and releases stupid policies.
Olivia has been a shitty candidate and she is getting exactly the level of support she deserves right now. There is time for her to change that... I wish her well, but currently, her campaign is shit.
Oh Christ. I heard that too. Galloway's an amazing interviewer because he presses while never going on the attack and alway leaves his guest the room to explain and defend. He did just that yesterday and Chow had nothing.
Yeah. I didn't catch the end of the interview but every time she avoided giving a straight-up, honest answer to one of his questions, I winced. Dammit, Olivia.
Yeah, I'll give you that. Her performances on Metro Morning have been atrocious. Tory is always better at radio, not only in his comfort level, but in his talking points.
That being said, I don't think that excludes her from being a bad public speaker, and that negatively affecting her polling numbers, and her appeal to her base. Having watched 4 debates, she can't keep up with Tory in her ability to quickly maneuver around contentious issues and turn them into barbs against the other candidates or points for herself. Which is not at all what municipal politics is about in the end (or at least, a reasonably run city council), but which does, maybe, steer the minds of the voting public.
And also, in her defence (which maybe I shouldn't scramble to as often as I do), Tory and Ford also often speak publicly about provincial and federal issues. The entire rhetoric of Tory's SmartTrack is a provincial issue, and Ford has talked about...well, drug legalization, and banning criminals from the country, and getting support from all levels of government, and - well, I don't think I need to appeal to anyone on this forum about Ford (except Rah and Slabs). I just think for some reason the populace views Tory through rose coloured glasses, and he needs to be held a little more accountable to his statements.
Tory is also a historically shitty candidate. He's a loser, but he's in a field where he is the least loser. Olivia doesn't need to be a great speaker to be a great candidate. She's been a terrible candidate. Her campaign isn't losing because it's bringing up gun control. It's bringing up gun control because it's losing. Her campaign has no coherent message, no focus... that's what allows her to meander in public appearance, to bring up stupid issues, and to poll far out of the lead.
Olivia has exactly the support she deserves for the campaign she is conducting.
She has won 10 elections....
What's your point? She's run good campaigns in the past, which is one thing that makes this current mess so painful to watch. Presumably, she knows better than this, but has let this mess happen anyway.
A shit campaign and poor performance as a candidate happens from time to time. This time, it Olivia.
I've read this and all your follow up responses and I essentially agree with you on how completely terrible Chow is as a candidate and a public speaker. As others have said, it was her race to lose, and lose it she has.
But your criticism basically omits any substantive discussion of platform and policy, and that's an issue. As OP has pointed out, despite some idiotic talking points on gun control etc., Chow's platform is what Toronto needs. Compared to the other two front runners, she's miles more realistic. Her transit policies are affordable and feasible (unlike Tory, she renders unto Metrolinx the projects which are Metrolinx's). She knows how things are going to be funded. Her revenue-generating tools, while possibly unpopular, are at the very least not a total pipe dream.
I'm sorry, but no matter how shitty her PR is, Chow is still the only politician who looks like she could do something useful once in office. I don't care how much she puts her foot in her mouth, she's the mayor we'd be lucky to have.
I don't have a problem with Chow's platform. I support her and will vote for her. Her job as a candidate is to get out there and promote her platform and sell herself as a candidate. This is something she's done for a few decades successfully, but this time around she sucks. She sucks enough that she doesn't deserve to be doing any better than she is doing.
Got it. In that case, we completely agree.
I also agree with what someone else said lower down: Chow seems tired. She seems like she doesn't really want to be running (and she delayed her campaign announcement a fair bit). I can't help but feel that's she's up there just because no other viable big name candidate emerged from the left, and she felt like she had to.
Poor Olivia...no spark.
I've seen her much better in the past. She just fucked this one up. It's on her.
I'm sorry, but I have to take this sort of narrative with a grain of salt.
Nevermind the fact that it ignores the entirety of the information that's been presented here - this trope has been parroted over and over again, and usually by people who're trying to push their own candidate. Chow hasn't been a terrible candidate - the truth is, she's been an able candidate, to an antipathetic audience.
I'm starting to get really, really turned-off with these buzzword politics. I'm not okay with it when people like the CPC use buzzwords to attack the Liberals, the NDP, or the Greens - this is no different. I want some substance - and the truth is Chow has substance.
I'm going to vote for whichever candidate can beat Ford. Right now, that's Tory, and I'm fine with that - I'm okay with fiscal governance winning out. But Chow is a proven leader, with the ability to make this city work under her vision. She's been a fair and moderate voice, instead of needlessly inflamitory, and after four years of Rob Ford, that's a big, important step. She deserves better than she's getting - and I'm starting to wonder if the thing that's keeping from getting it isn't her own campaigning, but rather, other people's attempts to hamstring her, in hopes that their own preferred candidate might look better because of it.
Yes, when a campaign is circling the drain, it's clearly the voters fault. The voters aren't doing the things they should be doing. Olivia has been stellar, but the voters are wrong to not pay attention to her brainless meanderings and off topic nonsense, realize she is clearly just better than they are and support her fully.
I have no idea what you mean by "buzz word" politics. Candidates win now the way hey have always won elections. They get out in front of the media and portray themselves as the most competent candidate with the best plan. The performance they put on in public either drives that message or it doesn't.
In Olivia's case, it simply doesn't. Her campaign is a fucking mess. Transit is a really important issue for voters, yet she's talking gun control and dedicated taxes for poverty reduction on the radio. She probably has great ideas, but she's a brutally bad candidate. The fact that you try to blame the voters for not paying attention to a flailing candidate illustrates the kind of stupidity that drives unsuccessful campaigns. What a load of shit.
Politely, Pretender, that's an awful lot of angry, dishonest rhetoric. I'd suggest you do some research into buzzwords - and into Olivia Chow.
Transit shouldn't be an issue that's politicized - but as it has been, then it's worth pointing out that Olivia Chow is the only candidate with actual experience in working with the TTC, having served as Vice-Chair. And her plans and visions for TTC development are moderate, and reasonable. She's even said as much - only to have a vocal minority shout (as loudly as they can) that she hasn't, that she didn't do it well enough, and that everyone's choice of candidate is terrible, except for their guy.
I'm not saying 'voters aren't behaving how they should' - I'm saying that there are dishonest people portraying her (and Tory, and even Soknacki) dishonestly. And I'm really, really getting turned off by it.
I can only hear 'She's running a terrible campaign' so many times, before I have to investigate the claim, and I'm sorry, but nothing I'm turning up shows that. If anything, I'm finding that a lot of her troubles started when the vocal minority just started repeating (over and over again) 'She's running a terrible campaign', until it stuck.
No, she's running a terrible campaign is based on every single incoherent meandering public appearance I've seen her make of the last few months. I told everyone I knew that choosing Kinsella to be part of her team would only lead to disaster. Guess what? It did. The guy has a long record of being a useless self promoting asshole, and Olivia invited him along. That's Olivia's choice to bear, and a big part of why her campaign turned to shit. Utter and complete shit.
Olivia is only being characterized by others because she hasn't given the voters anything else to judge her by. I've been campaigning on the left since the early 80's, I've seen this done well and done poorly. Olivia's campaign is one of the worst I've ever seen.
Warren Kinsella vs. Nick Kouvalis? Pretty big toss up if you ask me, but if I have to pick a pitbull I'd still pick Kinsella.
Kouvalis is competent and effective, which is not an endorsement of him as a person, just as a campaign team member. Kinsella is a fuckup.
I'd agree with that. I wouldn't want much to do with either of them, but it seems like Kouvalis runs a consistently more streamlined campaign.