Post-hardcore with symphony instruments or classical influence

Discussion

I'm looking for recommendations on other songs or albums with classical song structure or instruments, even if it's just a piano or a synthesized cello during the intro-- though real instruments and progressive song structure are better of course. Really I'm just looking for that "epic" sound. Earlier Dear Hunter and Chiodos' Bone Palace Ballet are some of my personal favorite examples.

The Used and Panic! at the Disco have a handful of songs that qualify. Avenged Sevenfold too; metalcore would be fine. The intro song on Isles and Glaciers' EP is a good borderline example. RX Bandits kinda counts. That's all I can think of. Please give me more!

Edit: Wow, that's a lot of recommendations! I had planned to respond to each comment individually, but it will take me at least a week to give all of these bands a fair shot. Thanks to everyone who commented or has yet to comment!

Posted Sep 7, 2014, 12:50 AM UTC · edited

1128
NotMyRealNameAgain•

In Fear and Faith

7
Carlyd95•

Haha yeah they have a lot of good ones

1
tylerseher•

My first thought. I loved Symphonies

1
SheldonFreemanOP•

I've always avoided them for being a Christian band, but I'm listening to Symphonies and it's fantastic, I'll have to look past the lyrics...at least they're somewhat cryptic...

1
[deleted]•

Not exactly post hardcore but Set It Off has wind and brass instruments and I think a xylophone.

You might like Get Scared's newest album.

I'll add anymore if I can think of them.

6
SheldonFreemanOP•

Great recommendations! Set it Off has the synthesized symphonic sound and Get Scared definitely has the epic sound, and energy, and fairly original melodies. I could really get into both of these bands.

Another example: We Came as Romans' first album would fit the bill if the melodies weren't ridiculously generic.

3
turtwig316•

set it off? i love you

2
dos0mething•

The human abstract, if you want actual professional musicianship. The classical influence behind their riffs is obvious.

People get hardons for nocturne, but their true talent comes in with digital veil.

6
Dxrrel•

You might like The Venetia Fair

4
SheldonFreemanOP•

Perfect!

3
BuddhaWithABraOn•

I listen mainly to screamo-ish post-hardcore, so might not be up your street, but hey ho.

The Elijah played their final gigs with a string quartet, features quite heavily on their album. I Would Set Myself On Fire For You had a viola/cello - this is more scream so not sure if it fits here, but might be worth checking out. Some of Envy's catalogue (Insomniac Doze especially) use a synthy-postrockish thing that is awesome and epic. In the same post-rock vein, Devil Sold His Soul.

Other angles: Coheed and Cambria straddle the line between post-hardcore and prog rock. I think you might like Biffy Clyro's earlier stuff, Toys Toys Toys Choke Toys Toys Toys is probably the best posthardcore song by a not posthardcore band.

And now I'm going to scribble down everyone else's recommendations.

3
HeyThereMrBrooks•

OP, this band called The Elijah put out an album like two years ago, its called "I Loved. I Hated. I Destroyed. I Created." It is EXACTLY what you're looking for, it's got classical influences all over the place, progressive song structure, and each song is grand and epic as fuck.

3
OneMoreDuncanIdaho•

Blue and the Grey by Parkway Drive has a trumpet intro and Drop Dead Gorgeous has some pretty good piano segments.

2
Jestoner•

some of these might be metalcore but have nice string accompaniment

dream on dreamer https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DcwRHDlmKJI

camisado https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R0MdSLgzZPs&list=PL5PfmQnSNjP3KMf6AcSqdLI-hsAksxiGF

people seem to hate attack attack but they do have some fun songs https://www.youtube.com /watch?v=Fip2KbGXrtw

woe is me https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UhQUyeQf01Q

outline in color https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IYMfofV65f4

the ongoing concept https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gv6IZArcoDw

Mirimar https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4RT6MAav8dw

jamie's elsewhere https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yfh9jov2HLQ

incura... not really this genre again but i think it might be what you're looking for, they're considered opera rock https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HRtGQnSSvqQ

in faith and fear https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c1HdH7ldAX0

ice nine kills https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EDpMhlLouZc

i see stars this is more electronic/dubsteppy https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7cP27i83jYI

house vs hurricane https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8_2Yr2eQ_g

everyone dies in utah https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xs4fKhkm2l0

Not exactly this genre but this song is a winding road of creepy, captivating music. It's a nearly 13 minute song that captures your attention the entire time. Has really big symphonic backing throughout... give it time to sink in, don't skip through the song https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_2iWDbDH4Q8

2
WorldIsStatic•

Cold Cash and Colder Hearts by Thrice has some nice strings involved.

1
1Sopel6•

Elenora and some of Enter Shikari's songs (System Meltdown or Quelle Surprise)

1
DFile•

Last Days of Summer by Silverstein has some really nice violin parts (also a kick ass breakdown). They have several other songs that feature violin too, but I can't remember which ones at the moment.

1
Carlyd95•

Omg I love when bands do this!!!!!!!!! In fear and faith I think has some in the album imperial. 1:40 on intentions by WCAR.

1
butterbunz•

Sorry I don't have a ton of input like others here do, but I recommend you check out Chiodos' new album Devil. It's amazing imo and has a lot of background symphonies.

1
SheldonFreemanOP•

Actually, being reminded of my disappointment regarding Devil when Matt and Derrick left the band is what motivated me to ask for albums like Bone Palace. Chiodos and Fall of Troy used to be my favorite bands. I didn't know anyone considered Devil "amazing." Nobody had anything nice to say about Devil when the post about Matt and Derrick leaving the band hit the top of this subreddit. Devil isn't terrible; it would be mediocre if it weren't a Chiodos album. Thanks much, but I kind of want to fight you. :)

1
butterbunz•

Haha I wasn't aware of the backlash that Devil received when Matt and Derrick left. I was just stating my opinion. So I guess I accept your invitation to tussle? I'm kind of scrawny so you'll win.

1
SheldonFreemanOP•

Haha I'm pretty scrawny too but I'm six feet tall so I might have an advantage when it comes to reach. Yeah Devil was received poorly by fans when it came out; when Matt and Derrick left, r/posthardcore figured it was just another in a series of problems for the band, Devil being one of them. But if they survive and return to their progressive sound, I bet their next album will be well-received, no matter how inspired they are or how well they get along.

1
butterbunz•

Also six feet even here haha. Regardless, here's hoping that their next album will be at least as good, if not far better, than Devil.

1
Emandiputs•

If you want my opinion on Devil, I'd say it was definitely above average if you rate it by its best parts rather than the average. What I mean is that the album had 2 pretty bad songs, 4 or so mediocre ones, and 4 or 5 that really lived up to what I would expect from a Chiodos album. That said, I though the overall tone of the album was sort of boring and "safe", but who am I to say if thats bad if thats the direction they want to go in.

I didnt realize this thread was old until after i posted this oops

1
SheldonFreemanOP•

Haha oh well. They took a risk by making a generic album. They took a risk by including pop punk songs...which, unlike To Trixie and Reptile, were very generic. I V vi IV, really dudes?? Calling half of the songs up to their standards is a bit of a stretch IMO. I'd say most of the songs were mediocre and none were truly memorable. The only "safe" choice would have been to make another progressive album with zero bad or mediocre songs, that all sounded very different yet somehow fit the same vibe and never deviated from heavy symphonic post-hardcore, aside from one or two ballads. And they didn't even try to do that.

Craig being a pretentious douche used to make for great lyrics, but he's a different kind of pretentious douche now, and it's not the same. Blame sobriety and Jesus I guess. Thomas Erak's humbleness stifled his creativity. The guitar work is simply not good on this album, to a point where it's hardly even a matter of opinion. It's like the whole band wasn't inspired and treated it like a job. Except Craig; I think he believes everything he writes is amazing. His girl needs to cheat on him and "accidentally" leave some pills lying around for the fans' sake. (Not seriously.) BMTH is becoming better than Chiodos, which is insane.

1
turtwig316•

in fear and faith are really good at this and even have an ep (symphonies ep) utilizing this sound. we came as romans and crown the empire are good at this as well. edit: [yellowcard](http://youtube.com/watch?v=VVUrYCZCwY4] (pop punk) use violin in a lot of their songs

1
DoctorStrange37•

Fightstar - Being Human

1