r/legaladvice•
reth42

Can I get rent lowered after signing contract? What can hold the landlord legally responsible to fix or replace? Alexandria, Louisiana

I wanted to keep the title short, because there are several issues I have questions about. I moved into an apartment recently, and I keep finding more and more issues that need attention. The apartment came furnished, but it also still had all the decorations from the previous tenant. I was told that I could not remove any of the larger pieces (couch, loveseat, etc), but if I wanted the decorations removed I could put them in the shed beside the apartments. I was kinda put off that it was left to me to get rid of some prior tenant's junk. It was like they bought the left side of Hobby Lobby.

In addition there were two broken Tvs and various small kitchen appliances that didn't work. The microwave works. The stove has a burner that's out, and another that's not doing great. The refrigerator looks like it's from the 70's or older. The freezer part needs repair, because the ice builds up so much that I can't properly close the little plastic door. The sink faucet's handle is broken, but functional.

Also, the apartment was not thoroughly cleaned when I moved in. It was spot cleaned, so it looked tidy at first glance when shopping. I found broken glass from a beer bottle under the couch. Along with a ton of dust and dirt. The loveseat had dirty window blinds, dust and dirt, and a roach carcase underneath it.

My biggest issues are at the front and in the bedroom. The front door has a big gap where the latch in the doorknob catches in the frame. It closed and catches, and I can lock it. I can see through it though. It just doesn't look like it would take much to break in, seeing as how the mechanism is almost completely exposed. One time, during a somewhat heavy rainstorm, water began coming in from outside. In the bedroom there is a wall that the paneling is pealing away and cracking. This was hidden by a painting and some of those bamboo roll-down shades. It seems like every decoration was placed to hide some kind of damage.

I have told the landlord about all of this, and her only response is "It's an older house, so ya know." To the apartment not being cleaned upon moving in, she responded "Oh, now why did they go and leave it like that?" No apology, no offer of refunding part of my deposit, nothing but putting the blame on someone else. Is there anything I can do to either get lower rent, or preferably get the problems fixed. Or, do I just have to suck it, and fix the issues out of pocket? I hope that I have given a good picture of the situation. Please, ask if anything is unclear, or more details on an issue are needed.

Posted Sep 7, 2014, 9:21 AM UTC

416
Lehk•

Nothing you described comes close to being something that any state allows repair and deduct and not all states allow it at all.

the only thing that your landlord is even responsible to fix is the burner, if you insist on annoying your landlord over a $10 burner element instead of replacing it yourself.

4
reth42OP•

So, the front door being properly sealed against weather or forced entry is not a requirement landlords have to meet. Or, walls that are peeling away from the sheetrock...or whatever is behind the paneling.

1
malachi23•

Lehk is right. The reason your rental has all these deficiencies is because it's already a cheap, furnished rental. To get a rental that doesn't have all these issues, you need to pay more than you're paying now. The landlord isn't "getting away" with these things; the market allows for it -- as long as people keep paying that much rent for that crappy of a rental, she'll keep doing it. If it sits vacant for a long time, she'll either drop the rent until she finds the "sweet spot" that someone is willing to pay to live in such accommodations or she'll fix it up.

7
reth42OP•

I guess I need to look into being a landlord. Thanks for letting me know where I stand, or confirmation of another telling me.

0
kizzan•

You shouldn't be a landlord. There are a lot of tenants out there that complain about a $10 burner. Lol

7
Lehk•

Any door can be forced in unless it is a special high security door.

I suggest you invest in weather stripping tape, it costs 5 bucks and will keep the cold and rain out better.

6
reth42OP•

Ok, thanks for the information. Looks like I have my Sunday plans, now.

0
Lehk•

Weather stripping should take 10 minutes and the burner 2 minutes.

2
Brad_Wesley•

It was like they bought the left side of Hobby Lobby.

I'm curious about that remark. I have been in hobby lobby once or twice and the whole time always thought to myself "wow, an entire store of useless shit".

That being said, it's not all useless as I once went in to by a glue gun for my daughters school project.

Is the left side the "useless shit" side and the right side the art/hobby supplies?

1
reth42OP•

You are correct, sir!

0
Brad_Wesley•

thanks..

1
reth42OP•

Hey-Oh!

0