ELI5:Internet Slowdown Day

What is Internet Slowdown Day and why is it happening?

Posted Sep 9, 2014, 6:59 PM UTC

212
[deleted]•

Several internet companies will make their service slow to protest the companies that own the cables that connect us to the internet being allowed to give preferential treatment.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mgdmw•

They won't actually slow it down, just display infinitely looping "loading" images to get people to think about what it would be like if all these sites were slowed down: http://www.itwire.com/it-industry-news/telecoms-and-nbn/65372-internet--slowdown--day--is--here

1
TOMATO_ON_URANUS•

The internet is like a highway - just like only so many cars can physically fit on the road at a time, only so much data can be transferred per second through the infrastructure.

Net Neutrality is a concept in which internet service providers are legally prohibited from treating any data it transfers differently than any other.

Specifically, Time-Warner/Comcast wants to limit the amount of data per second that it will deliver from Netflix. This specific complaint is someone reasonable, since millions of people are streaming 10+Mbps 24/7.

The issue many internet users have is that this creates a precedent for ISPs to have free reign. If Comcast can slow down Netflix, why can't they slow down 4Chan to 1Kbps because the CEO thinks 4Chan is evil?

Internet Slowdown Day is websites intentionally slowing down the data they send out of their servers to demonstrate what the internet would be like without Net Neutrality, before anything actually happens.

2
stylzs05•

The internet is like a highway

So essentially websites are pulling an internet Chris Christie.

2
keertus•

I was under the impression that the sites weren't actually going to slow down, instead they would be posting a loading wheel to demonstrate what it would be like having to wait at the slower speed. Is that not actually the case?

2
UltraChip•

You are correct. The term "Internet Slowdown Day" is a misnomer. The participating websites are just going to have a fake loading icon that links to a website that explains net neutrality.

1
nemewsys•

And what is going to cause the slow down.

1
mgdmw•

Nothing will be slowing down on Internet slowdown day (the sites will show fake 'loading' images to look as if they are taking a painfully long time to load, but speed is not affected).

However, the whole protest is about proposals by the FCC to allow ISPs to create a two-tiered Internet where if you and your neighbour have the exact same broadband connection but he pays more he can have a faster Internet ... or, realistically, you have an artificially slowed Internet: http://www.itwire.com/it-industry-news/telecoms-and-nbn/65372-internet--slowdown--day--is--here

Companies like Netflix are opposed because it hurts their business which needs high-speed broadband. Realistically, it disadvantages poorer people and diminishes their access to education, employment and a raft of other things people use the Internet for.

1
Inconsensical•

There is the concept of "net-neutrality" that basically says that internet service providers should treat all internet traffic equally, nothing gets priority over anything else. People have been trying to get this concept formalized into law for a while, but this past April the FCC has hinted that they may allow a rule to allow ISPs to give content providers a fast track for their content. This opens the door to ISPs filtering and throttling traffic based on who pays them what.

A hypothetical for instance, Netflix could pay Comcast a bunch of money to prioritize their traffic. This could mean that people trying to use Hulu or YouTube experience slower speeds because a chunk of the traffic is being reserved for Netflix.

On Internet Slowdown Day a bunch of companies will voluntarily throttle their traffic, resulting in slower responses and speeds to those sites. This is an attempt to give actual users a feel for what could potentially happen should ISPs be allowed to dictate what traffic gets priority. The hope is that users become more aware of what is at stake and more people get involved with supporting net neutrality.

1
mgdmw•

They won't actually throttle traffic - that would hurt their own profitability if they did. They will show fake infinitely-looping loading screens however to give the impression of a slowed page: http://www.itwire.com/it-industry-news/telecoms-and-nbn/65372-internet--slowdown--day--is--here

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Mason11987MOD•

Direct replies to the original post (aka "top-level comments") are for serious responses only. Jokes, anecdotes, and low effort explanations, are not permitted and subject to removal.

This post has been removed as it is not an attempt at an explanation.

2