Pre-fucktual agreements?

Question

I have been thinking a lot about the unfair system of how different genders are impacted by an unwanted pregnancy. After talking with a friend, i believe a fair solution would be a legal document both parties sign that agrees any offspring will be aborted (probably limited to a year at a time). If not abortion, then the male party, by default, is not responsible for the pregnancy. This is similar to a prenuptial agreement. birth control is reliable these days, along with the option of abortion. this is fair to both parties. if a woman is willing to sign this document for the period of a year, it is her agreement that she and her partner will take proper steps to prevent pregnancy. a woman is not required to abort the pregnancy, but if she chooses to keep it, she is not entitled to financial support of the child from the man involved.

of course this will never pass in our overly-feminized society, but nobody can say this is not completely fair.

im not very good at expressing this idea- perhaps someone can re-word it for me to be more palatable.

Posted Sep 9, 2014, 10:49 PM UTC

013
new-man2•

Even if a woman agreed, this would not be legal for the following reason:

The choice of a woman is not taken in anyone wanting to "opt out" of child support. Even if a single mother doesn't want the man to pay child support, if a man is named on a birth certificate, he may be required to pay child support.

The decision concerning child support is no longer civil case between two people; the United States government feels it has a vested interest in finding and demanding payment from absent fathers in order to reduce the amount spent on the welfare of its citizen.

If you would like to give men the option to "opt-out", you must first eliminate the Social Security Amendments of 1974. States are currently required by the federal government to attempt to collect child support from absent fathers. States that don't seek child support risk losing federal funding.

It might sound like a "fair solution", but the government is already involved; we (men and women) are no longer given the right to make that choice.

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/12/01/us/01child.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0

http://www.csecouncil.org/industry/reports/role-of-bar/

7
SharpTitsOP•

thanks for the well-informed post.

2
xNOM•

Ok but, you realize that no woman on the planet would sign it, right? They want 99% of reproductive rights and only 40% of the responsibility.

3
SharpTitsOP•

40% is generous. they think 9 months of incubating is equivalent to 18 years of financial responsibility.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
new-man2•

They want

Anytime you are talking about a sub-set of society, it's a good idea to realize that not all of the sub-set is the same. It is prejudicial.

I follow the Men's Rights movement because both men and women should be allowed to make choices without prejudice. I am aware of women that take responsibility. I believe that acting as if all women (or any stereo-typical group) are the same makes us look bad.

The laws that marginalize men as they currently stand are not the fault of all women. We need women's help in the fight. Belittling women won't help to make them feel welcome assisting us.

2
Dexontronox•

This would work perfectly, just not in the manner you're suggesting.

Any man who brings a piece of paper like that out to sign before sex wouldn't just get turned down, they'd get laughed at, insulted and scorned. Then she'd leave, and tell all her friends about the weirdo who tried to make her sign a sex contract.

2
SharpTitsOP•

i was envisioning more of a LTR scenario, but that's not wrong either.

2
Dexontronox•

In an LTR you'd just offend the woman for being such a dick. And rightly so, you're telling the woman you mistrust her so much that you want her legally bound to a course of action. Secondly, it's saying that you don't think you could have an open discussion about the matter. You'd never accept some woman pulling a legal contract out for you to sign.

MRAs are (or should) be about treating each gender equally, not backing people in to a corner.

1
SharpTitsOP•

i wouldn't try to force someone into it. I mean to suggest it is the end result of you both agreeing to the course of action. It is entirely possible for a woman to agree she doesn't want to get pregnant for a year, and the completely change her mind. she holds all the cards. im just trying to eliminate what i see is the root of the unfairness of the present situation. the most concise way i have read it is:

for women, consenting to sex doesn't mean consenting to parenthood.

2
Dexontronox•

I think the most valid point you've raised here is that men should be able to trust women when it comes to sex. We should be able to trust that if we have agreed with our partner to not have children, that shall be upheld until we have agreed on something different.

It does seem cruel for a man to be forced in to paying for a child he was tricked in to creating.

But on the other side of that argument, women should be able to trust that men will stay and support a child they knowingly created. There are many cases of both sexes being screwed over, both sides need to be addressed for equality to happen.

1
MRSPArchiver•

Post text automatically copied here. (Why?) (Report a problem.)

1
Nomenimion•

A pre-fucktual agreement isn't worth the semen-stained paper it's printed on.

1