r/goodyearwelt•
fdoom

New to GYW and thinking about purchasing these Cordovan boot Seconds. Can that mark on bottom left toe be fixed/hidden/polished away?

Question
New to GYW and thinking about purchasing these Cordovan boot Seconds. Can that mark on bottom left toe be fixed/hidden/polished away?

Posted Sep 13, 2014, 10:48 PM UTC

110
makemewafflesno-show socks•

I've had luck deer-boning some small rough patches, but that usually works best on poor finishing as opposed to a blemish on the shell itself. Hard to tell what the blemish on that shell is from based only on that one pic, but looks like something that would be hard to get rid of. Personally I wouldn't bother with them myself, since the blemish is in such a prominent spot and would really bother me if I couldn't get rid of it.

3
fdoomOP•

I got a reply from the store:

It is in the shell—a crinkle if you will not a hole or rip.

1
6t5gWTB: Carmina Frankenstich•

Hard to tell considering we don't know if the defect is in the finish or the shell itself but I would say that it is unlikely you'll be able to remove it. You do not want to layer polish upon cordovan and there is nothing you can do it fix it if it the cordovan itself and not the finish.

2
fdoomOP•

I got a reply from the store:

It is in the shell—a crinkle if you will not a hole or rip.

1
tdwtomcat•

AE Dundees? I just got some from the seconds sale and they showed up today.

1
fdoomOP•

Yup. The store sent me that photo. What imperfection did yours end up having? Is the fit wide? Also how do they look for casual wear? How do you like them so far? Maybe I should just pull the trigger and eat the $10 return if they don't work out.

1
instagigatedVINTAGE-SHELL-ADDICT•

Doesnt look too bad. Is that actual damage to the leather or just the finishing? When you rub your finger over it, do you feel the texture? If so, i dont think you can permanently fix it.

1
fdoomOP•

I got a reply from the store:

It is in the shell—a crinkle if you will not a hole or rip.

1
instagigatedVINTAGE-SHELL-ADDICT•

Yeah, there wont be any structural damage but it will never be hidden.

1
EternalOptimist829•

That would drive me insane.

1