Is Tim Dormer the 'Russell Hantz' of BBAU?
Only people who also watch American Survivor will know who Russell Hantz is, but I'm hoping that some of the people here are fans of both shows, as I am.
First of all, I feel bad for even mentioning the vile creature that is Russell Hantz in the same sentence with Tim Dormer, whom I actually enjoy and find intelligent, clever and charming - unlike Russell. But when it comes to playing the game, I feel that they both have the ego the size of a moon. They both seem to think that their way of playing the game is the best way, and possibly the only 'right' way to play their respective games (Survivor and Big Brother), even if prior to Hantz eighteen people had managed to win the game perfectly fine (not to mention that Hantz himself lost) and prior to Tim, nine. Now that Tim visited the BBAU house, his advice to David was basically "here's how to be more like ME". He wanted there to be big moves, more strategical thinking, no groups... Which is all fine if that comes naturally to you, but I think trying to force it basically results in a Gemma. It's simply not fun to watch to anyone.
I personally still think that the best way to win Big Brother is to be your genuine amazing self, but only one person can be Tim Dormer. I think the idea to do something on BB "because Tim did it" is just as ludicrous as going on Survivor and doing something "because Russell did it". You have to play your own game. Yet Tim himself seems to believe that his way is the best way, as Russell - despite having lost every season he was on - still appears to believe he's the best player of Survivor.
I think if people keep worshipping Tim the way they currently are, this show has no future because not only would it be uninteresting to have a Tim clone competing and conquering the game each year, but it's also very unlikely and, thus, creates false expectations to viewers that set the show up for failure. Survivor has been able to provide more enjoyable seasons without relying on a Russell-like strategy, so why can't Big Brother Australia thrive without a Tim-like strategy? People say that Russell changed Survivor and that Tim changed the way BBAU is played, but doesn't viewing them as some type of an ideal become a limitation in itself concerning what is perceived as the 'correct' way of playing the game, when it is their way of breaking limits that made them stand out in the first place?
Anyway, this is merely what I've pondered this morning and I'd love to hear your thoughts, oh fellow BBAU fans.
Posted Sep 23, 2014, 8:24 AM UTC