Informal survey of sub members: Over the past few years, have you actually started to notice it?

I read the Age of Spiritual Machines back in 99 and was aware of the concept of the Singularity back then but only recently have I really started to viscerally feel the pace of technological acceleration speed up. It feels like we're pivoting every few weeks which only used to feel like every few months. I'm curious to know if anyone else feels the same way and why?

Posted Oct 10, 2014, 8:17 PM UTC

1120
kebwi•

Could just be the fact that we have more immediate access to a wider swath of news (including remarkably low quality news of course). Our dailys lives are now defined by an constant deluge of articles, columns, blog posts, reddit posts, facebook posts, tweets, headlines, youtube videos, tv segments, podcasts, etc. etc. etc.

When you have tons more "news" (of a sort) firehosing at you around the clock you feel like more is going on, but really, you're just more aware of what's going on. There isn't necessarily more actually going on.

This theory has also be proposed to explain why people think we live in such violent times. We read and learn and watch and hear about wars of all sizes between groups of all sizes in every far-flung corner of the world, so we think the degree of conflict is dramatically worse than ever before...but from my understanding, this sense of increasing war and violence is actually inaccurate. Apparently, we live in a very peaceful time compared to most of history. It's just that throughout most of history people had no idea what else was going on because there was so little media to absorb.

9
kidpostOP•

On your last point, of course I think we all agree. Stephen Pinker has written and spoken about this decrease in violence extensively.

More than anything, the question was a way of probing other members of the sub to see if they're feeling something similar that I've felt myself. Even discounting for the effect of encountering tons of pop-sci (frankly) bullshit articles, if I look back it still feels like the acceleration has increased.

Personally and professionally, my interest is in machine learning and even just there the advances have felt very different. From the early 00's to about 2008 it felt like there weren't that many changes and then it started to feel like it ramped up and now it just feels like BOOM, BOOM, BOOM - insight after insight, advance after advance.

For example, in 2012 Andrew Ng et al used 16,000 cores, 3 full days of computing time and $1 M to train the Google Brain recognize faces and cats. The system could learn 1 billion parameters then just one year later, Ng developed a cheaper, faster GPU solution that could analyze 11 billion parameters for only $20,000 on just 3 machines instead of requiring a large collection of servers in a warehouse. Then just a few weeks ago Baidu announced that they had built a system with a 100 billion neuron system (the number of neurons in the human brain) and that it was 100 times more powerful than the 2012 system built by the Ng team, and 10 times better than the 2013 system.

This is kind of what I mean by really "feeling the pace of acceleration." That's not a doubling of performance every 18-24 months - that's a 10x improvement every YEAR.

2
Metric0•

I do feel this way, when looking at the array of tech products that have become available to me on a very short timescale. For a long time I was a smartphone holdout (waiting for x86 architecture and general computing capabilities), until the last month or two when I finally discovered what a $50 contract-free smartphone could do. At the same time, I bought my first drone-mounted camera for almost nothing. Nothing terribly important, but random things that seemed pretty remote to me just a couple years ago are suddenly showing up in a pretty unexpected way. I did find it a little startling, when reflecting on the fact that these trends should continue to accelerate.

3
kidpostOP•

Thanks for adding to the discussion. It feels like that for me with 3D printing and genomics.

2
Metric0•

I guess I don't feel it quite as much in technical areas I actively study. It hits me the hardest in areas where I never really expected to care what was happening, and am suddenly taken by surprise.

2
kidpostOP•

That's an interesting point. For me, it's the opposite. But it's probable that different fields have different paces so it feels differently. I don't deal with supercomputers but I do know that the price/performance per watt actually is faster than Moore's Law because you've got the tippy-top of the line components, specialized software and the like.

1
Duduli•

You may want to check out the very similar thread running in r/futurology right now:

http://www.reddit.com/r/Futurology/comments/2ivh5b/has_technological_change_been_greater_between/

3
kidpostOP•

Thanks for the lead. Cheers

2
genesimmonsisdead•

I feel it too. Why? Because it's my job to keep up with emerging and disruptive technological breakthroughs and analyze them for their environmental, economic and social significance. The pace has definitely picked up, seemingly going beyond exponential. From the huge implications of a now possible clean, green abundant Hydrogen economy based solely on intermittent renewable energy, to hybrid-material solar cells breaking the solar cell efficiency ceiling - the progress in alternative energy has been at an all time high for about seven weeks. And that's ignoring all the 3D printing, robotics, nanotech, and next gen computing breakthroughs that I also track. It's just phenomenal and it's only going to get faster as we augment ourselves with AI.

2
kidpostOP•

I'm glad to hear you say that you're also feeling the acceleration and that it's based on looking at advances that have happened over the years. I gave u/kebwi an example of advances in machine learning that were 1000x in 3 years. Do you have any examples that come to mind?

Also, I'd like to ask your opinion on what you meant by a "hydrogen economy". Do you mean fuel-cells, fusion, what?

1
genesimmonsisdead•

Hello, Thanks for your response. I am very new to Reddit and have been distracted by work and travel, otherwise would have gotten back to you sooner.

By hydrogen economy, I mean using fuel cells powered by hydrogen that is generated ONLY by renewable energy. The new method hydrogen generation, "decoupled catalytic hydrogen evolution," leapfrogs safety and storage problems with the old proton exchange membrane electrolysis (PEME) method. The new method allows larger-than-ever quantities of hydrogen to be produced at atmospheric pressure using lower power loads, typical of those generated by renewable power sources. It was announced last September. Read more at http://phys.org/news/2014-09-hydrogen-production-breakthrough-herald-cheap.html.

Regarding machine learning breakthroughs, those from Cornell -alone - in the past 12 months have been a future shock experience, no?

1
Alatain•

I am a relatively late-comer to this idea, but I have noticed a very real uptick in advancement within the past five years. Without having read or seen anything on the topic, I had come to the conclusion that we were accelerating our advancement. Before reading anything about this, I began discussing the idea with my friends that our immediate future will be so radically different from what we know, that we would not understand it.

Now, I see things that I wanted but could not hope to see in my lifetime happening in the next four years. We live in truly interesting times.

1
kidpostOP•

What kind of thing did you not hope to see in your lifetime but have seen?

2
Alatain•

I really did not think that we had the chance to have real, true augmented reality that could map real-time data to our immediate surroundings. I knew it was possible but the increases in processing power that we have seen in the last few years has really made it possible in the near future to fully remap the world to be what we want it to be. I mean, we are on the verge of holodeck capability with some of the technologies that we are developing now.

On the simpler side, just the ability to access any information at a whim has completely changed our society. Aside from truly hidden knowledge, everyone has access to all the knowledge that anyone has, at all times.

On the outside, just crazy side, we have connected the brains of rats and allowed the direct transfer of information in a brain-to-brain interface. We are more connected than ever and are slowly developing into a different organism through this connectedness. I am not sure what will happen, the development of super-human intellect through AI or through the emergent capabilities of millions of minds connected through the internet. Either way, it will be interesting.

2
Gnashtaru•

That's one thing I think about sometimes. We focus so much on the concept of the Singularity being a moment when A.I. surpasses us and we can then merge with it or are wiped out by it or whatever. But maybe it won't even be an A.I. in the conventional sense. Maybe it will just be a boom in the human capabilities through our increasingly useful interface with data. The artificial part of it might not be some separate intelligence at all. Maybe we will be the means in and of ourselves. Maybe not as a hive-mind, or maybe as one. Dunno. But our access to augmented data pre-filtered for our needs seems very likely to advance faster than a stand-alone A.I. to me. Maybe there's no difference, since I said "augmented data pre-filtered for our needs" and maybe that in and of itself IS the A.I. I'm dismissing. Who knows.

3
kidpostOP•

Yeah, I think you're right. In fact, I think you might be ore right than people give your idea credit for. If advances in human-machine interfaces continue, then the singularity is unlikely to come about because of AGI but because we will surpass human level intelligence. Thanks for contributing.

2
Digitlnoize•

In a very real way, I see this sort of information sharing happening on Reddit more than anywhere else. If there's a TIL or post about subject x, it's very common that there will be fairly high posts explaining why it's right or wrong. Reddit is quickly becoming the best place to digest information in a social way, IMO. That's certainly why I'm here. I learn so much here every day.

Once we're able to have true brain to brain interfaces, something like Reddit could easily morph into the collective super intelligence you're talking about.

New Nightmare: Reddit AI vs 4chan AI for the fate of the world. It could happen...

3
kidpostOP•

Well said

1
gomboloid•

yeah

-1
oboes•

It's not.

-2