Alfie's playing career may be over - come on home!
freep.com/story/sports/nhl/red-wings/2014/10/...Posted Oct 15, 2014, 7:34 PM UTC
Posted Oct 15, 2014, 7:34 PM UTC
I'm going to say something really controversial, so brace yourself. Does this mean Melnyk was right for holding out on that 2-year 12M$ for Alfie? I mean, I hate that Alfie left but 6M$ is alot of money for an injured player.
Ha ha, you are brave.
It is, but part of that salary expectation was based on him giving them a discount on his previous contract.
I don't know the numbers, but part of that 6M was money we should've already paid him but that he deferred to help the team out.
See I have a big time problem with this. At the time, the contract was signed with an extra year running on the assumption that Alfie was going to retire a year before the contract ran out (unless I'm misremembering things). Sure, circumstances change, but you can't hold the team hostage because it turns out you wanted to play a couple extra years
that doesn't really make sense, if you except him to retire after say 2 years, why would you make a 3 year contract?
I'm pretty sure the contract was made with a future extension in mind, and that it would effectively allow them to use it to back load his salary on to it.
whenever it was discussed last summer, that's the impression I got of how he had viewed it.
Cap hit
Cap hit, wink wink. If he expected and intended to retire after 2012, the $1M in 2013 is a bonus that reduces cap hit and thanks him for his service. That it didn't work out that way throws a really weird wrench into things.
That 6 million was supposed to be "back pay" for the 5 million dollar hometown discount he took.
It seems to have all worked out for the best
[deleted]
No thanks. Have fun in Detroit, remember to lock your doors.
You know what, I don't want him back. Not now.
EDIT; CAREFUL sens fans you are treading in to leaf territory. The future is bright and Turrisy.
You don't deny The Alfy HERE and expect to get away with it!
And... "Leaf Territory"? What does that even mean?
Sad fans holding on to the past! He's like gone man.
1 day, 1$ contract with Ottawa, and retire, so we can put your number in the rafters.
C'mon Alfie. You can turn your back on the team, not on the fans.
$11 dollar contract, obviously.
Easy there, Melnyks isn't made of money.
oh sweet jesus you may have hit the nail on the head.
Alfie please. Man that would be so awesome.
Fuck, I think they should give him the million they owe him.
What money do they owe him? He played until the end of the contract that he agreed to and walked away. I love the guy, and acknowledge that he made less than market value to help the team, but he was by no means forced into signing any of his contracts.
Bryan and the Team allegedly promised a market value final 1-2 year deal after Alfie played the $1 million season that the team asked him to include into his contract to lower the cap hit of the deal, which was never supposed to be actually played out. When time came for the market value deal, after a year well below market value, Eugene and the team lowballed him.
He agreed to the original contract. If he didn't like the terms he could have said no to the third year at a lower value, but he didn't.
You really think its fair that he was paid $1,000,000 for the '12-'13 season?
Its acknowledged by all parties that there was a sketchy/sweetheart deal, and that the senators didn't live up to that.
Details
Fair or not, he agreed to the terms, and was by no means forced to do so. Turns out both he and the organization were wrong about how long he would end up playing, but you can't go back and retroactively alter the contract to make it fair to the player, nor do they owe him anything - both parties fulfilled their obligations.