The German Premium KV-1
The German KV-1 is currently underteired in my opinion. To begin with, it is 5.0 BR where the Russian is 4.7 BR. This hardly seems fair to me considering how much better the German version is.
First, it has 105/105/105 mm of armor all around the turret while the Russian KV-1 has 75/75/75 mm.
Secondly, it has a gun upgrade to the KwK 40 L48 (Same gun used by the Pz. IV H and J) with 114/102/84 mm of penetration whereas the Russian KV-1 has at best the ZiS-5 with 83/74/67 mm of penetration.
I also believe it has a slightly better engine but that does not make that much of a difference.
Now for my experience in battle against it. In almost every single battle of RB or SB GF that I've played since 1.43 I have seen at least one of these tanks. Now, I don't mean to say that I'm an amazing tanker, because I'm not, but I don't consider myself to be terrible either. Most recently on Poland in RB I found myself trying to kill a German KV-1 over a slight hill, blocking me from seeing his chassis but allowing me to see his turret fully. In my T-34 1942 (3.7 BR uptiered by my KV-1 ZiS-5 and T-34-57, I realize this wouldn't always face German KV-1s normally) I fired at least 7-10 76.2 mm rounds in a mix of APCR and APHEBC and bounced every time. I estimate I was about .2-4 km away from him. His turret was facing 90° to my line of fire and I still had no hits whatsoever.
The reason this is a problem is that at or below 5.0 BR, the Russians have a total of three tanks that can penetrate the turret of a German KV-1 at that distance: The SU-85, the T-34-85(D-5T), and the T-34-57 (Maybe the ZiS-30 and SU-122 but I have not tested). All others are equipped with F-34 cannons (T-34 1942 and T-34 1941), ZiS-5 cannons (KV-1 ZiS-5) or ZiS-3 (SU-76M) and are completely useless against 105 mm of armor at ~.3 km.
I think the German KV-1 should be at least placed at 5.3 BR as to prevent it from seeing the aforementioned useless tanks.
TL:DR - The German KV-1's turret armor cannot be penetrated by anything other than a very few tanks in the BR range it faces and is invincible against those tanks as well as being more heavily armed than the Russian KV-1 and is only .3 BR higher than the Russian version.
Posted Oct 16, 2014, 9:28 PM UTC