[Critique] 25/f/WI Look at this!

I just added two more photos . One has my child in it and I'm not sure if it should be up. People in Irl say I should have it up but I've heard here not to. thoughts? Also my hair is dyed brown, should i mention or have a picture of before?

I'm unsure about this line in profile "I'm not the best at writing about myself...but I'm pretty great." I have had some people like it and message me because of it. But in the don'ts it says not to say negativity in self-summary. I don't want it to come off as full of myself.

Also your general thoughts would be appreciated. Thanks

http://www.okcupid.com/profile/malarkeytrees

Posted Oct 23, 2014, 5:26 PM UTC

117
MetricLemurUsername, age, gender, profile name•

I have kids myself and like dating women who have kids (we understand each other better in my opinion; we know dating people like "us" has more challenges) but I tend to avoid the profiles of women who show pics of their kids. To me, I'm interested in dating you and only want to focus on you. At least at first. If things work out for us then eventually it will be necessary to "meet the kids" but I don't think it adds anything that simply marking "has kids" doesn't. Also, couldn't it attract the wrong kind of guy?

3
randomelskaOPMost•

I certainly don't want them meeting my child until we are serious and they want to. I don't want to give off the impression that they will.

3
VinoNobile[30/M/Seattle]•

A couple of thoughts, from someone who doesn't have kids but is open to dating those who do.

-I don't think you should have a picture of you with your child posted. It's good to make it clear you have a kid, and yes, there are some people who will just look at pictures, but honestly, you don't want to hear from them anyhow. I'd rather you kept your child's privacy intact.

-I also think you need to talk more about yourself in your profile. I understand that being a mother is the single biggest part of your identity, and it's important to be clear about that, but other than lists of your favorites (which aren't all that helpful), I don't get much of a sense for who you are. In fact, the entire profile comes up as kind of standoffish. In particular, I think it's better to not fill out a section than to put something like "nope" or "life in general." Those tell me nothing, and make your profile read poorly.

-Also, in the top section, where you list what you like to do, USE SPECIFIC EXAMPLES. Name some favorite local hikes, or the board games you most love. Move from generic examples to specifics, and you'll have a much stronger profile.

2
randomelskaOPMost•

I took off the kid pic since you and another said to.

I'll have to think about how to do the others. I don't like over sharing and am a private person unless I'm actually talking with someone. I'd like to know if other people agree with you on more detail and better to leave things blank. Thanks for the input.

1
BloodlustHamsterDon't you hate pants!?•

Your profile says "I am an INFP" get rid of that shit.

2
randomelskaOPMost•

I like having it on my profile. I know it's not everyone's thing, but there are others who also like it.

-1
dmull38727/M/NJ married to u/GalinToronto for the green card•

If you're not going to admit anything private, that's cool, but don't bother keeping the section around if that's the case.

2
randomelskaOPMost•

thanks

1
mke-ultraauto-erotic ass fixation•

I live in Milwaukee and am desperate and would not message you even though you're definitely cute. The thing is, there's no real 'character' or personality to your profile. You say you have a sense of humor but there's nothing funny on your profile. You've got nothing to lose, spice it up, have some fun. Show us you!

Also, I would lose the whole "lower than 70% match filtered out". It's makes you seem like a b-word and why don't you just filter them out and don't say anything about it?

1
randomelskaOPMost•

Thanks for the response. I actually view it as being nice to say that I have it filtered. That way they know I'm not interested and don't waste their time messaging me.

1
Brighter_Tomorrow•

I'd be sending you a message if you lived nearby.

The only thing I think you need to do is add to the "what you're doing with your life". Even if all you feel like you do is take care of your child, add something else in!

"Learning about X"

"trying out X"

If you can't think of anything, even "Browsing Reddit until I sleep"

Also, add something to you "most private thing". Be unique and creative. It's such a cop out when people just say "nope" or the classic "but then it wouldn't be private... LOL!"

1
randomelskaOPMost•

Thanks for the response. I'll have to think about what else I could ad.

1
deez_manBoobs•

I was going to say add a dash of makeup for one magical grand standing picture, but then you said you're bi, so I'm guessing you look all sexes to appreciate the natural beauty? If that's the case, more power to you. You're not too shabby and although a minor makeover could help, you're reaching for lesbians whom all have varied preferences I'm guessing.

1
randomelskaOPMost•

I mean I think it's good to appreciate natural beauty and women should be comfortable without makeup. I just happen to not be wearing any the day those were taken. I'll wear makeup on dates and random days.

0
Captain-Dennis•

I really liked it, pics: wow you are crazy beautiful and profile: short but informative. I know others are saying add stuff to your profile but I like it straight to the point. Its better if that stuff comes out when you are talking to another person anyway.

Have you include the a pic of your real hair color? Sorry if this is a dumb question but it looks darker in the last pic. If you haven't you might want to include a pic with your real color unless you keep it brown all the time. Also that line about being great read fine, I'd keep it.

Why the 70% filter though? I am coming back to OkC after a big break but at least in the past the match % would be way off.

1
randomelskaOPMost•

The last pic is darker because of lighting and that was right after I dyed it. Natural hair color is darker blonde.

I'm not interested in people below the filter. There's too many differences in terms of values. I've never gotten a message from someone i'm interested in who has a low match score.

1
Captain-Dennis•

Ok dark blonde doesn't sound like a huge difference. And thanks for the Info about match % it's probably gotten a lot better. That actually sounds helpful I live in the South and about 75% of the women believe in something that I find morally repugnant.

1