Update-Related Theory Time!

(Spoilers for the 10/25 update. Just in case you couldn't tell from the title.)

So a big deal was made about how the B2 session was going to have 8 players. Due to recent events, it may look like things are irreversibly screwed up. But then I noticed that there are exactly 8 Sburb players still alive. Sure, some of these look like they might die soon, but they're not confirmed dead yet. In fact, there are 2 from each known Sburb session:

  • Aranea and the Condesce (the Condesce, as post-scratch Meenah, kind of counts as a Sburb player)
  • Aradia and Terezi (sure, Aradia's still in the dream bubbles - but she's alive and could leave if necessary)
  • John and Rose
  • Roxy and Dirk

What if a successful 8-player session is still possible - but using a different 8 players than we'd previously assumed? That would mean that this is the alpha timeline and the recently deceased characters would not be brought back, but on the other hand they could still be relevant and help out on the dream bubble front.

Side note: There is one other possibility involving "replacement players" - the merging of four planets into two planets could mean that B2 is now a 6-player session, in which case 2 of these players (I'd guess the Condesce and either Aradia or Aranea) are excluded.

Edit: It should probably be Sollux and not the Condesce.

Posted Oct 25, 2014, 6:33 AM UTC · edited

1828
Rafevisit the IRC•

Sollux is chopped liver

9
hyperhedgehog7bleh•

what the fuck is a sollux

10
Drilling4manaGNU Terry Pratchett•
5
ThatzeraguytechnoWanderer•

John Retcon powers, calling it.

7
PersonUsingAComputerOP•

I'm doubtful that this will happen. Compared with the other times there's been some kind of timeline-related retcon, the situation isn't nearly as drastic, despite how it may feel. There are 2 other major timeline retcons:

  • The timeline where John was killed by Typheus and Jade couldn't enter the session. At the time John was the main character, more so than now when we've had entire sub-acts go by without seeing him, and the story really couldn't go on without him. Plus we hadn't had any character deaths at that point, so it was even more clearly a "bad end".
  • The timeline where Vriska fought Jack Noir. If Vriska was shown to win the duel, it would A) be an enormously anticlimactic ending for Jack Noir and B) leave Vriska stranded in the B2 session with no way to leave. If Jack won the duel, Aradia (not really a central character on par with Karkat or Terezi) would be the only troll still alive. In either of these situations, all of Act 5 Act 1 would be a complete waste.

But if we look at the current situation, neither of these really applies. Due to dream bubbles, even dead characters can remain somewhat relevant. We did know dream bubbles existed by the time of the Vriska-Jack doomed timeline, but hadn't seen evidence they would allow dead characters to keep doing useful things. Besides, there are easily enough remaining main characters (John, Rose, Terezi, Roxy, Dirk, WV) still alive to advance the story in the B2 session.

That said, John retconning things is quite likely, but far from a given.

1
Rafevisit the IRC•

Also, Sburb players have dreamselves. The Condesce doesn't have a dreamself.

5
LumoBlaze•

Theres no more frogs.

No more forge....

No more winning....

4
PersonUsingAComputerOP•

Theres no more frogs.

Rather suspiciously, we never saw what happened to the completed Genesis Tadpole that Jade made. It was headed for the Forge, but for all we know it got rescued by one of John's stray arms at the last moment. Or missed the lava. Or something else happened.

No more forge....

It may well have survived the planetary collision. Most of the characters were right next to it, and none of them were killed by the collision.

No more winning....

Kids and fun! That's what Homestuck is all about.

3
partner_pyralspite•

It was explained that it went to the center of LOFAF where Echidna lives and now takes care of the genesis frog.

5
Kippyanthe lil swagmcmuffin deluxx•

Requesting source. I heard nothing of this and if it's the case, it would ease my consciousness very slightly after what's just happened. Hey, you gotta take what you get.

1
partner_pyralspite•

Its in the middle of this page Jade says it http://www.mspaintadventures.com/?s=6&p=008227

2
LumoBlaze•

About the frogs, my only issue regarding the genisis tadpole is this. Wasn't there essential end game alchemy that required use of the forge even past just raising a frog?

When a planet smashes into another planet right on the volcano that we could see from space, it's safe to assume it's either severely busted up, or totally flattened.

and yes. yes it is.

1
micheel6•

they arent coming back, didnt you see the wedged door to the after life?

4
taschneide•

The Condesce never played Sburb. Sollux, however, is still alive and with Aradia, last time I checked.

3
qezlerVoid of Mind•

Let's not get ahead of ourselves. This is unlikely. If I'm not mistaken, nothing was prototyped pre-entry in the current session. Hence, the battlefield cannot bear fruit.

3
TotalXenon•

But didn't Jade bring the battlefield from her session to this one? I'm pretty sure she put it in the session they're in now after they got there.

3
psychobatshitskankRogue of Time•

It fell into the lava when Gamzee was beating Terezi.

2
Raderph•

Actually, that was Jane's Skaia Fork, IIRC.

4
TotalXenon•

It was indeed, you can see it begin to fall in on this page, and it falls all the way in a couple pages after that.

2
arrantSagacity•

That was Jane's fork.

3
MikeWasowzkiHeir of Life•

terezi and rose haven't been DECLARED dead yet but... I'm pretty sure what happened to them equals death, same as jake and jane

3
Kippyanthe lil swagmcmuffin deluxx•

No

No

No

No

Rose and Roxy's new friendship is the only thing keeping me going. There's no way she could die. Roxy's going to void out and then materialize medical supplies to save Rose or something. It's going to work out. I NEED it to work out.

3
PersonUsingAComputerOP•

If Terezi were going to die immediately, there would be no reason to show her getting up and pulling the cane out of her wound. With Rose, the chance of death is higher, since there's always the chance she was only saved for a few dramatic last words to Roxy. However, I'm not sure what happened to her would count as heroic (like when Jack killed John on the Battlefield, she dies before she can actually do anything) and it definitely wouldn't count as just.

1
everlastingSnowGet your mouse off of my Flair! Do:•

I don't think Aranea would be a willing participant in that session...

2
partner_pyralspite•

Oh a session full of kid cadavers, shed love it.

1
wendelscarduadoze riding a slowpoke•

What makes this session/timeline screwed is not so much the lack of 8 players... but the lack of a Space/Knight pair for frog duties. (then someone invokes bkew inversion theory to say that other players can do this)

1
PersonUsingAComputerOP•

They already have a frog! Echidna is keeping it.

1
wendelscarduadoze riding a slowpoke•

Well, getting that frog back kinda counts as frog duties... And the only ones Echidna would talk to are dead.

1