What post-hardcore band never really clicked for you?

Discussion

For me it's Chiodos. I've tried but I just can't get into them. I'm more of a fan of bands like Thrice and Brand New so I've never loved Dance Gavin Dance as much as everyone else either.

How about you?

Posted Oct 26, 2014, 12:35 AM UTC

32107
ManWithoutModem•

La Dispute

45
n00bsause•

Yeahh, they never got very far with me. It's the vocals that irk me a bit.

12
ktm57ktm57Handwrites VTN signatures so the actual members don't have to •

mwm pls

9
WorldIsStaticOP•

When I'm in the mood I love them but sometimes they're just so dramatic and I can't handle it. I totally understand why some people don't like them.

6
keepitcutthroat•

I hated La Dispute the first time i heard them, i couldn't conceive of how anyone could like them, and then one day something clicked

6
TheMurderCapitalist•

I understand but I'm still disappointed

5
trollens•

This is what changed my mind about them. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1TNXL6iL3wU

3
scifimusic•

This is awesome, thank you! :)

2
Thebiglurker•

Huge fan of somewhere at the bottom of the river. Couldn't get into anything else by them.

2
rgb003•

Omg I came to say this. Fuck that band

-23
fateislosthope•

You could of just said they are not your thing.

4
420boner420•

Letlive.

I definitely have nothing bad to say about them, but yeah like you said, it just never "clicked" for me.

30
WorldIsStaticOP•

They're like Glassjaw for me in that half the time I love them and the other half I can't handle listening to them. I think it's the wall of sound they create with their instrumentation; I much prefer when you can hear each instrument as they work together to create a song.

8
vcguitar•

See them live, they'll turn you around immediately.

Their set at Warped Tour last year was the best I've ever seen in the past 14 warped tours I've been to.

4
[deleted]•

Man I love their albums so much but Jason Butlers live performance just reeks of disingenuous bullshit attention seeking antics; it turns me off to them so hard. Does that make me a hater?

7
vcguitar•

Hey, to each his own. At the Scranton show, they played to probably 100 people (the rest of the crowd was at BMTH). Jason tore the shit out of the stage like they were playing to 100,000. It was awesome

It took me a bit to get into The Blackest Beautiful, but it's easily grown to be my favorite release from last year.

7
SulMatul•

I agree about Jason. It's like, are you a musician or a clown?

I really tried to get into letlive. but Jason got in the way. He seems more concerned about his image than his content. He dresses extremely flamboyantly. If you watch his interviews, he'll just randomly throw in ten dollar words like he's looking for any excuse to say them. On top of that, his lyrics are typical angst driven teenage crap.

End rant.

3
JeffroTheMan•

Rock and roll has always been theatrical. It's always been about the band taking on a larger than life identity. Too many bands, imho, and in this genre especially, don't put out any stage presence for fear of what you just described. If the music ain't moving the players, how is it supposed to move the listeners? Just my two cents :)

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

Haha definitely. I meant it in a decidedley cringey, 'I think I acted like that when I was 13 but fuck I hope not' sort of way.

2
tjm713•

Definitely agree, Ive never listened to them but I saw them live once and it was amazing, he leaves everything on stage and even if you don't know the music it's enjoyable to watch

1
thesewordsarefake•

You're older than me.

1
olypenrain•

I felt that way when I first discovered them and watched their videos, but I found that I really like their musical style when I just listen to their music.

2
ktm57ktm57Handwrites VTN signatures so the actual members don't have to •

Enter Shikari

22
Captain_Blood•

DUNUNUNANADUNUNUNANA wubwubwub WAMP WAMP WAMP

oooyyy yes mate ya can't change their agenda

fightin like cats and mice to fill their wallets

OOOOOYY RORY C WHAT'S YOUR TAKE

(THE POLITICIANS ARE FUCKING FAKE)

11
ktm57ktm57Handwrites VTN signatures so the actual members don't have to •
7
Captain_Blood•

Still my favorite r/corejerk thread of all time.

4
ktm57ktm57Handwrites VTN signatures so the actual members don't have to •

Found it about a week ago, haven't gone a day without thinking of it at least once

2
maxwellbevan•

They never clicked for me until I saw em live,they put on a hell of a show

3
ManWithoutModem•

Enter Shikari >>>>> La Dispute

3
ktm57ktm57Handwrites VTN signatures so the actual members don't have to •

downdarlinged

2
pabsensi•

I do like them but the just sound so cheesy most of the time.

2
moshlyfe•

Pierce The Veil. I've tried on three separate occasions to get into them, and it just has never clicked for me. Dance Gavin Dance took a while for me to get into, but I'm head over heels in love with them now.

18
Zeppetella•

I never got into PTV either, and DGD always seemed like the composition of the music was way to crowded like everyone was trying to play really complex things all at once and it never meshed

14
tjm713•

Same here, that's the exact reason I could never listen to DGD, I love Jonny Craig but that band sounds like a hot mess

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2

Hands Like Houses.
I kept seeing all the recommendations on here and decided to try them out. I skip their songs every time.

10
Lag-Switch•

I really enjoy them but I too tend to skip their songs quite frequently.

Their style is one that calls for a certain mood and it doesn't really fit into my regular playlist. I find that I listen to 'Hands Like Houses' on nights when I'm up late coding.

6
[deleted]•

I will say I liked Chiodos but never really got into them. However, I saw them live with ADTR and holy shit did they blow me away. They were amazing.

9
itsmountainman•

I wanted go to that concert so bad but I had class the night it was near me. What was it like?

1
[deleted]•

Loved it. I missed Motionless In White. Chiodos was pretty amazing. Craig sounded amazing and had such great stage presence. Bring Me the Horizon was great, Oli had great stage presence even if his voice wasn't 100%. And ADTR was just fucking awesome. They played so many songs, like an amazing amount and did like a 5 song encore. Really had a great night.

5
DanceShomoDance•

Chiodos, they are talented and I don't dislike them, but I don't know just can't get into them for some reason.

9
jmb_412•

Dance Gavin Dance

7
NotSoMystical•

letlive. and Issues. I don't even know why.

6
rgb003•

Which Issues songs have you tried to listen to? The first few songs didn't do it for me right away but their full length album rocks!

1
NotSoMystical•

Mad At Myself, Stingray Affliction and Never Lose Your Flames. I just didn't feel it. Their unclean vocalist lacks emotion in his voice, imo.

5
seventhousandmiles•

try their EP. i loved the EP but i didn't really dig the full length at all, except for the song life of a nine.

2
NotSoMystical•

I couldn't really find their EP, unless it's called Black Diamonds. I actually dig that, but certainly not their albums.

3
Homiesunite•

Dance Gavin Dance. Only song I even remotely enjoy is Pounce Bounce and even then it's rarely. Just not a fan.

6
battlefield645•

Check out their acceptance speech album. A very different sound from dbm and dbm2

3
fateislosthope•

Every album after death star sounds different.

1
Homiesunite•

I have. Still not a fan. Just not for me.

1
pabsensi•

Most of the bands that get upvoted here.

6
oscar9909•

Same here.

1
Tokyoto_•

PTV

4
RufinTheFury•

Pianos Become the Teeth and Hands Like Houses. Meh.

4
colesun•

Cannot stand Pierce The Veil or Dance Gavin Dance.

4
Captain_Blood•

ITT: People knocking bands that I like

4
Mr-Vengeance13•

Probably Fear Before. I keep seeing people post about them on here, so I thought I'd give them a listen. Didn't really do anything for me. Same goes for Trophy Scars, but I dig "Alphabet. Alphabets." a little.

3
titan_of_braavos•

Trophy Scars best album IMO is Alphabet. Alphabets. It's the only one that I REALLY like. Holy vacants is good too, but it doesn't stick.

With fear before (one of my favorite bands) every album is so different that you may only really like one...check out all their albums because each is sooo unique. My favorite is The Always Open Mouth.

3
Mr-Vengeance13•

I did listen to all their albums, but I think they just might be one of those bands that have to grow on you for a while. I had the same problem with Glassjaw at first, but I ended up really enjoying them, even though I only listen to them on certain occasions.

1
utb040713•

Alexisonfire.

3
TreyWearsPrada•

ಠ_ಠ

2
xxthanatos•

wat

1
ChestHairs•

Are you sure you like this genre? There seems to be lots of pop punk and emo being passed off as post hardcore in this sub (I'm talking about brand new, taking back Sunday, melodic, 16 year old angsty lyrics type bullshit).

-1
utb040713•

Just because I haven't clicked with one band doesn't mean that I dislike the genre. I mostly listen to FFAF, Senses Fail, Story of the Year, Chiodos, The Blackout, Fightstar, etc. It's been years since I've tried to listen to alexisonfire, but I just could never get into them, with the exception of a few songs.

1
utb040713•

I think I found the problem. I listened to a few songs of theirs on youtube, and I liked about half (Born and Raised, Rough Hands, This Could be Anywhere in the World) and couldn't stand the other half (Water Wings, Plumonary Archery). I figured out that the ones I didn't like are their older stuff, and I actually like their newer stuff. I'm listening to Old Crows/Young Cardinals now, and haven't found anything I dislike so far.

1
P_Manslapper•

A Day to Remember.

3
jdmurrayz•

Definitely these guys. I have nothing bad to say about the band, just nothing ever really caught my attention.

2
P_Manslapper•

Exactly how I feel.

1
HeartShapedNutshell•

There's probably a equal number of post-hardcore bands that I like as there is ones I've never really liked/gotten into, so here's a big list of all the ones that come to mind.

Chiodos, Dance Gavin Dance, La Dispute, Enter Shikari, Hands Like Houses, Crown the Empire, Falling in Reverse, Chunk, No Captain Chunk!, Escape the Fate, Touche Amore, Emarosa, and the big hitter on my list is Famous Last Words (can't stand them).

I also have a dislike for corporate-puppet bands like PTV, SWS, and naturally most bands signed to the Fearless/Rise/Sumerian record labels, being someone who doesn't slam hate bands and has a decently wide music-tastes, it's not that I have anything against the musicians personally, I like some of their earlier more-underground tunes, but that's just the strong "grunger" side of me coming out that just all-in-all hates the radio-friendly soulless commercialization of music (which I mean, is inevitable, if you want to be a band with a decent-sized fan base in today's shitty pop-filled monetized world.

For equal measure, a list of bands I do like include Alesana, Atreyu, Before Today (the Fuentes band before PTV), early-Blessthefall, The Color Morale's "Devil In Your Eyes" album, Eighteen Visions, Fugazi, Hawthorne Heights, Funeral for a Friend, Pianos Become the Teeth, Saosin, Silverstein, Thursday, Thrice, Underoath and The Used.

Also, Heroin, Jesus Lizard, and Scratch Acid are good post-hardcore bands, but I doubt you guys listen to/have any knowledge of them.

For further reference, I'm not a big fan of deathcore bands, there's a few but not many, that genre's just not my cup-of-tea.

2
7MOV7•

Out of curiosity have you heard both of Hands Like Houses albums? Ground Dweller is more phc with iffy production but i'd consider Unimagine to be more alternative with great production. Two very different sounds, you might dig one of them. To each their own though :)

3
HeartShapedNutshell•

Unimagine is the only album by them I've heard, I found a few of their songs like "Introduced Species" catchy, but it was nothing spectacular enough to catch my interest, and the use of electronic/computerized elements didn't really help, I'm one who prefers a more organic-melodic sound with hard-hitting thrashing intervals.

2
NotSoMystical•

Their cover of Torn is pretty neat!

2
Lag-Switch•

Also, 'Reimagine' is out now. It is some remixes/reworks of the songs from 'Unimagine'.

1
pistonman94•

Interesting that you like Pianos, but not La Dispute or Touché Amoré.

2