I love the Talisker 10 and want to try some more of what Talisker has to offer. At the moment I'm leaning towards the 18 year because it only costs 20% more and I really want something that tastes a step up from the 10.
Posted Nov 10, 2014, 4:48 AM UTC
I like 57 north the best
Go with the 18. The 57 is good but i actually prefer the 10 to it.
I personally found the 18 to be amazing. I would go with that, if I could afford it.
Distiller's Edition for me. I used to prefer the 18 but changed my mind.
I haven't tried the 57 North, around me a bottle of DE goes for $65 and a bottle of 18 goes for $110. I think there both great, and while I don't think the 18 is necessarily twice as good as the DE it offers a mellow maturity that your not going to find in the other two.
Distiller's edition is above and beyond for me. Bought a set of three which included the 57 North when I went to the distillery, but I haven't tried the 18.
So what did you get?
Got a pretty good deal on the 18yr but I'm yet to open it as glenfarclas 105 seemed more christmasy.
I like the 57 North, personally.