what if you could unlock more deck slots by leveling each hero to 30?

for every hero you level to 30, it should give you an extra deck slot

that way new players won't be overwhelmed with slots until they get at least 1 hero to 30...and by then they will have a good grasp of the game

Posted Nov 15, 2014, 1:47 PM UTC

1.5K241
Bandicooted•

I don't care, whatever system. Upvoted because I want every freaking post about having more deck slots to reach the frontpage. /rant

733
[deleted]•

The longer they keep people waiting the more people will be willing to spend when they're finally released.

81
Hyperoperation•

Am I the only person here who thinks that charging for deck slots is about the sleaziest thing Blizzard could do to Hearthstone? Maybe I'm old-fashioned, but I don't think a necessary, overdue UI update qualifies as a chargeable "expansion."

27
Mecdemort•

I think it is exactly the kind of thing that should require payment. It is a minor change to reduce an inconvenience that has no impact on gameplay. I would rather they charge for stuff like that than anything that could make the game pay-to-win.

30
Ricketycrick•

I would rather they charge for card packs than charge for something as basic as more deck slots. If they want to be sleazy that's fine, but they're going to lose any respect I had for them and subsequently any desire I had to spend money on them. Just because they can play some technically correct bullshit card about how they "only want to charge for convenience" it doesn't make it not shady as all hell.

-2
HINDBRAIN•

sleaziest thing Blizzard could do

Not even close.

"Woops, your minion just died. You can resurrect it with only 5$!"

"Warning: your ragnaros will be destroyed in 3 hours unless you rent a collection decay prevention ward!"

10
DuckDuckLlama•

At this point, sleezy or not, I don't even care. Just let me have more deck slots.

2
Draki1903•

Or the people will go find a new game that listens to the player input. Your call Blizzardino.

0
robotdonny•

A lot of really cool card games out on the market, are there?

3
Draki1903•

There is always a niche to be filled.

1
Terrors_•

At this point, I'd be willing to pay $2-$3 per deck slot

-59
Ivoos001•

Don't say that too loud, you might give them ideas... Oh who am I kidding, they've probably already thought of a system to get the most cash out of new deck slots.

51
krispwnsu•

Wow prices for a decent amount of deck slots. 30 dollars a month just to keep your deck slots. Fuck you Blizzard if you are thinking of anything like this.

-18
Paran0idAndr0id•

Especially if each came with a pack of cards with it.

4
jrr6415sun•

why would they do that

1
jrr6415sun•

as long as you can for it using gold i'm fine.. I would pay 200-300 gold easy for a slot.

3
RemusofReem•

I think it's crazy that this got so downvoted this. As u/mcdemort said above this is a perfect way to pay for server time without making the game more pay to win

1
losisnojokeOP•

maybe then Blizz will get the hint

25
garbonzo607•

Ben Brode just made a tweet on Twitter essentially saying they are worried about creating new packs because it might confuse new players and that "it is a huge issue".

https://twitter.com/bdbrode/status/533533097308872704

I honestly don't understand what they are going to do if they don't release new packs. You have to. So you just have to accept that new players will have to research it themselves or go to the collection menu to see what's in each pack....

2
dgforce•

MTG doesn't have these kinds of issues so why should Hearthstone?

2
DPSisBad•

They will release cards, they're more scared of the game playing out like might and magic where it was extremely daunting at least for me to decide between all the packs.

They will probably alternate adventures and packs, trying to give packs a strong sense of identity, while letting adventures release more of the odds and ends of the game

2
RemusofReem•

It already says "recommended for new payers next to vanilla packs"

1
garbonzo607•

He's saying people won't know what the cards you can get are in each pack maybe 3 years down the line.

1
KSmoria•

Any post with more than 3 upvotes reaches the front page :P

10
HugoBCN•

I don't even think I need more deckslots and still agree... Once they introduce more slots, at least we'll be able to talk about the features that'd be really cool to have. :P

6
[deleted]•

Here here!

I never feel the need for more than 9 slots, but I appreciate that other people do.

1
Huggernaught•

Upvoted because I want every freaking post about to be about having more deck slots***.***

FTFY

5
deviouskat89•

Good lord, I don't. Quit breaking our sub!

5

If it's not a suggestion for Deck slots, it's a suggestion for something else. r/hearthstone has turned into a suggestion page to be honest.

3
CapnCrunch10•

It's what most game related subreddits end up being. It would be more, but thankfully we're approaching a new content cycle so there is plenty of other things to talk about.

4
Ditocoaf•

"We're taking this community hostage. It may not be effective, but we're desperate and it's the only chance we've got."

I guess that's that, now, with the threads deleted. The problem is hidden away forevermore. Good job, mods!

1
deviouskat89•

If you've got concerns, you can direct them to modmail. You can stop your unfunny pasta now.

0
Ditocoaf•

Eh, it's just a line I came up with that I feel explains pretty well the sentiment behind all the deck-slot spam. I wanted to put it at least one place that wasn't deleted. Sorry if it bothered you.

I should take a break from reddit now probably.

1
althius1•

You know, this gets thrown around a lot to the point of being overdone, but I'm gonna say it.

MORE DECK SLOTS OR RIOT.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Levitlame•

Reddit Admins here... It seems voting has gotten too complicated for you. From now on you can only up vote 10 threads. Ever.

2
Rpgguyi•

Woah more than 9?! Can someone explain how that works?

6
DBones90•

Another day, another sensible way to introduce deck slots without overwhelming new players.

1
KaossKing•

just give us pages of 9. if you only need 9, you only use 9. if you need more, you can flick through pages

135
NonSilentStalker•

And they already have the system in the game!

You can trade between your own decks and the pre made casual ones (not sure what they're called)

62
crazetex•

Basic decks.

30
althius1•

Let us replace the Basic Decks. Then you could have one page of Control and one page of Aggro. I'd be happy.

16
DreNoob•

two pages of Aggro

FTFY

52
crazetex•

sounds fine with me. ties in with hitting 30, too -- hit 30 and you could replace that deck

2
KaossKing•

holy shit I just remembered this. it already exists. wtf Blizz

6
LimeWeavile•

I honestly think that everyone should have as many decks as they want from the start. Nothing confusing with that.

90
Carthradge•

Yes, but it's more about discrediting the only reason Blizzard has used. They still haven't addressed any method that would get rid of it for new players.

38
wasniahC•

Yeah, I disagree with this. I don't think we should be accepting the reason of "it'll overwhelm new players" and work around it. This post says "Blizzard is right that it will overwhelm new players, so we should get a solution that stops it from being a possibility for new players!". No, that's not what we should be doing - we should be arguing that it isn't overwhelming for new players to have access. There should be ways for it to exist without new players being overwhelmed by it (i.e. a setting in options that you tick to enable it), not ways that stop it from "overwhelming" new players and simultaneously disadvantage them.

10

You're acting like both aren't happening. What people are really saying is more like this:

"Blizzard are wrong about the change being too complicated for new players because <insert reason>. And even if they were right, they could implement <insert possible solution> to solve that problem."

4
wasniahC•

If I came across as if both aren't happening, I'm sorry, that isn't how I feel about it at all. I know both ARE happening, and I have no issue with the first (people making good solutions that work for everyone, and the way they are implemented causes no problems). I have a problem with the latter, the ones where the solution itself panders to the shitty excuses we're given, and therefore end up being shitty solutions. This post is one of the latter. I don't want to see this being the solution, because if this gets traction and becomes "the solution", we aren't going to get a good solution.

1
rasmustrew•

I cant see how this would disadvantage a new player in any way.

3
wasniahC•

Sorry, maybe wasn't clear there - this disadvantages them because they are going to have less gold "spare" to spend, so it leaves them with less deck slots than the people who have been playing a while and have gold lying around to throw at things.

So yeah, this solution means that new players get less deck slots than people who have been around a while (or "waste" gold on deck slots when we ought to have something like a setting we can just tick for it)

1
HapaxHog•

If a new player clicks New Deck 300 times, it's their own fucking fault.

"Ughhaaaa so many decks, I'm so confused!! I'm not giving Blizzard my money!"

Is that what Blizzard think will happen?

7
garbonzo607•

What if your kid makes over 9000 pages of deck slots? That could be a real issue.

1
joyx•

It's not really confusing, that's just Blizzards cop-out.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
Frexter•

Yeah, if only we had an option to name our decks so we could remember what they are...

11
oreostix•

Naming our decks? Heck that's way too complicated for us

5
banmenow•

Please, slow down. I need to lie down.

4
rasmustrew•

How about we dont go around calling people retarded eh?

2
6Jarv9•

The only hero i dont have at 30 is hunter... I hate playing as and against him.

67
AtomOfUniverse•

Same here. When I try to create a hunter deck I already feel the trauma.

27
carnige•

Everytime I get a Hunter quest , I feel like shit doing it.

7
AtomOfUniverse•

I feel like repeating sorry emote, but it works in the opposite way.

9
AlterBridgeFan•

Just played against a hunter and can confirm. "Sorry" doesn't mean anything... stupid mother fuckers.

18
Carloes•

I actually do this and often add the player after I win and tell them I didn't want to play Hunter but had to for the quest (which I only do if they give 60 or more gold).

-1
Terrors_•

I re-roll it or let it rot for a day so I can reroll it the next day.

4
Vigilante_Circus•

I always do it in casual. Figure its better than using cancer in ranked.

1
itsbananas•

That is the ebola setting in

-1
TrannyTooth•

God, I know. Better go back to your Control Warrior, remember to throw every legendary you paid for on it. Fuck Hunters, amirite guys? upvotes to the left.

GO HEALTHY DECKS WITH FIVE OR MORE LEGENDARIES!

-21
Sakatsu_Dkon•

I can smell the salt from here.

11
ArbitraryPotato•

If you can smell salt...

1
HugoBCN•

Your salt levels are almost tragic.

5
Terrors_•

I play a Druid Legendary deck (golden portrait) filled with alarm-o-bots, faceless manipulators and legendaries. I can taste your salty tears, and they are delicious.

5
LuichoX•
-6
ArbitraryPotato•

Any hunter you beat is trash. Any hunter who beats you is trash.

7
jmoneygreen•

I mean, if you want to win 55% of your games with zero decision making or thought then it can be fun to play hunter...

3
Quilt82•

For me it's priest and mage. It would take me ages to level them up, because I don't like playing as them.

1
Riggzon7•

Well that hurt. Not all hunters are bad you know. Racist.

1
Dogeboja•

Yes they are. Here, have a downvote.

3
funnydudde•

True, mine is at a whopping level 6.

1
Zidgia•

Same! I just think i make ranked more friendly for my opponent even if they use them

-1
Suakeli•

Anything would be better than the current system, so yeah.

15
Fen_•

What if you were still missing the point after 5 discussions a day for several days?

15
BMRGould•

Why have some unlock system? Just give us as many decks as we want to make.

12
monkyyy•

"complicates the ui"

22
BMRGould•

Adding page tabs complicates it how?

0
monkyyy•

"the technology isn't there yet"

29
QuintonFlynn•

Was the technology there ten years ago?

1
Selthor•

It doesn't. That's just the BS excuse they are giving us.

7
green_meklar•

Exactly.

6
clouden•

Adding tabs is really complicated !!

  1. You need to code it. And we all know that blizzard with his very little team of a few peoples, hasn't the man power for implementing it. But even if they could :

  2. People will be lost. With at least one more button in the UI, you complicate the UI for at least 5% more buttons ! And when you begin to add more than 0% more button in an UI, peoples are lost, see what they did in Star Craft 1 and 2, lots of buttons and every peoples are okay to say that Star Craft is a skill intensive game... And you don't want that for new players in Hearthstone.

You could use the ALREADY EXISTENT PAGE WITH THE UNUSED PRE-CONSTRUCTED DECKS but it would force the player to remember which decks are in each pages... Clearly impossible ! Want a proof ? Did you knew that you had the pre-constructed deck's page before I remind you of it ?... yeah, that's what I think.

...

So yeah, clearly it's just bullshit from Blizzard but they doesn't care because we still pay and play Hearthstone.

-1
alienware•

You just said it

-2
green_meklar•

Blizzard, what if we already had a way of making a simple, intuitive UI that allowed people to access billions of different things?

Just hypothetically, of course.

-5
rasmustrew•

this for deck browsing? you are kidding right?

2
Nairobie755•

I want one of two things, reduced slots because the meltdown people would have would be too good to pass up or extra slots so they would shut up already.

11
[deleted]•

You can't stop gamers from complaining. Some gaming communities complain less and some complain more, but from my experience the level of complaints for a given game will be constant regardless of what the complaints are about. And because this is Reddit, when people are complaining they will tend to all complain about the same thing.

This subreddit is complaining almost exactly as much about deck slots as it was about bots, despite the fact that bots were a big problem and deck slots are a very small problem.

Of all the things people could be complaining about, this is probably one of the best. It won't scare off any new players because they won't care, and talking about the problem can't contribute to the problem (as it might have with bots).

I wouldn't mind if people kept complaining about this forever, but they will stop when they get bored anyway. This level of discussion about such a narrow topic isn't sustainable.

6
clouden•

While I kind of agree with you (with a community large enough, complain will always come)

  1. Deck slots was always a problem.

  2. for you maybe bots was a big problem and deck slots a small one, for me and for others friends of mine, it's the inverse.

Bots only play online, you can beat them rather easily and even if you loose, you still played (I prefert playing against bot than a bad player or a BM one)

Yes, it's unfair for people who doesn't bots, but I don't really care, people will get their shiny hero maybe some more cards and that's all. They doesn't get a more unfair advantage than people who paid for cards with real money.

So yes, it's kind of bothersome to play against a bots, but not so much.

For the deck slots however, I love to play different deck. I have 3 competitive deck, 5 decks I love playing and 2 decks for experimenting and or dailies. I hate to play twice the same deck (when I have 5 victories for a class, I play like 3 to 4 decks for the quest) and I love experiencing new and silly decks. I play rather regularly with my friends too. Some have all the cards, some have near none, some know how to play, some doesn't. Some want to play fun decks, some serious... so how can I have :

  • Serious decks
  • Loved decks
  • Fun decks
  • Decks for newbies
  • Serious Deck without legendary (or with a few)
  • Experimenting decks
  • Daily quest Deck

with only 1 slot ? I have more than 1 deck I love, I want to experiment with more than one deck at once, I want to play with my different friends with more than one deck before asking them to wait that I create a new one, I want to keep my powerful decks without having to think again and again all the cards I put in it....

I want more slot decks, and for me it's a BIG problem.

/rant

But yeah, your right for the rest of your post :/

4
It_Just_Got_Real•

Or you know.. just implement it as a simple yet necessary QoL improvement to the game instead of framing it as something we have to earn or worse yet, pay for.

10
JulpaFTW•

At this rate, I just want them to add more decks not because I need them, but because I want people to stop bitching about this

8
clouden•

We all hope they'll at least think like you ! <3

1
scene_missingMOD•

Quick Mod note - we were getting absolutely flooded with "9 deck slot" posts, so we went ahead and deleted all but this one (the oldest on the front page). Feel free to continue the discussion here.

This is not a permanent rule change, just something we do from time to time when a topic gets into meme/spam territory.

8
tatergunner•

You deleted a lot of content in established posts into something which doesn't represent the true flavor of the stuff you deleted. Why didn't you consolidate to a megathread or something?

5
Dantini•

I feel like the sheer number of topics and complaints were important (to keep) to get blizzard to realise that this is a change many people want...

4
theclarinetsoloistMOD•

It was getting to the point where people were just making troll posts that vaguely related to the deck slot controversy. There is a difference between people who genuinely want more slots and people who are just using this as a way to post stuff that would otherwise break the rules.

2
tatergunner•

People may have been having fun with the topic but that doesn't mean there wasn't a real issue underlying it. I think you were right to take action but this is not a great post to be the catchall for this issue. It's one specific semi-halfbaked idea. I saw posts that had UI mockups, posts discussing the validity of Blizzard's concerns and questioning their claims, multiple ideas for how extra deck slots could function, etc etc. Do you see all that being mirrored here under the "unlock us deck slots at 30" catchall?

5
yyderf•

again, quick, easy and wrong decision. if people were making troll posts, you should delete those. IMHO, you mods took easy way and about issue that is rather important to the majority people on this subreddit

2
l-lahutzy•

They won't even do it to sell you the slots for money.

I don't think they'll do it for free.

7
garbonzo607•

They won't even do it to sell you the slots for money.

How do you know? They say they are actively discussing adding deck slots, whether that means charging or not, they haven't said they won't do it.

1
MrRivet•

If the charge for basic game functionality, they deserve to have their game die, and i genuinely hope it will if it comes to that.

I doubt even they would be so retarded though.

1
Zephyrot•

No, this can't be implemented. That would be too reasonable and still too mind-taxing. Just think about it, you'll have to keep in mind all levels of all heroes and make decisions. That's a no-no.

P.S. The problem isn't in finding the good solution, blizzard can think up and implement a thousand of them. They just don't want to, for some reason, that's not yet been revealed. Not counting that bs they post about it ofc.

4
green_meklar•

They just don't want to, for some reason, that's not yet been revealed.

Because a history of fanboyism has convinced them that they're the infallible gods of the gaming world and know what we want better than we do.

2
GQlle89•

They have revealed the reason..

They want you to keep Tweaking your decks. As they have said plenty of times, a big part of what they call The Hearthstone Experience is making decks, and also making changes to your decks.

1
Terminus14•

In what world does having more deck slots prevent that?

0
GQlle89•

If you have more deck slots, you are more inclined to keep your old deck, and just create a new one with the changes, thus the constant tweaking kind of disappears..

Note that I too would like more deck slots, I just told OP the answer to his question :)

2
Fuzati•

No, everyone should have more deck slots to start with.

There's no good reason to make people grind for it (how does one get "overwhelmed" with extra deck slots anyway)

4
Zcrash•

What if they stopped lying to and insulting us and just gave us more deck slots?

4
eihen•

I'm pretty sure they would rather you just pay money for the slot. At this point they are just prioritizing other features other than this.

3
zomjay•

Full basic card unlock at ten, one slot at 20, another at 30. Allows the decks per class.

3
Ariamanna•

Brilliant idea. It will take Blizzard a good 2 or 3 years to implement.

3
jegerdk25•

Honestly, being overwhelmed by deckslots isnt even possible.

3
SirKnightofDerp•

Or... What if you could just have more fucking deck slots.

2