r/baseball•
TempAlt

Picture of Japan and USA benches after game 4 of the MLB Japan series recently posted on /r/pics... thoughts?

The picture itself: http://i.imgur.com/XRxuNj4.jpg

Original post: http://www.reddit.com/r/pics/comments/2mstyg/us_baseball_all_stars_are_in_japan_for_an/

This is from a Japanese news article about how the Japanese grounds crews were shocked at the state of the USA dugout after game 4. There is a huge cultural emphasis on cleanliness in Japan, with children being formally taught how to clean up after themselves and perform janitorial duties in primary school.

In the r/pics thread it seems most people are on the "they're just slobs that should be ashamed of themselves" side of the fence. However, people who have played baseball at a highschool or higher level in America will realize that this is absolutely tolerated and even expected in an American dugout. Hose it off after the game and you're good to go.

So... Should these players have made an effort to clean up after themselves? Is this a case of entitled millionaires disregarding common decency while representing America in a foreign country? Or is it simply a cultural touchstone of the sport that never came about in Japan?

What do you guys think?

Posted Nov 20, 2014, 7:45 AM UTC

918
kasutori_JackSan Francisco Giants•

People in that thread never played baseball.

31
scarface910San Francisco Giants•

Irrelevant comment, but I was looking up beef bowls in r/Japan and saw a comment you made 3 years ago. Just funny seeing fellow Giants bro somewhere not related to baseball.

3 cheese gyudon was my Crack when I was in Japan and I'm jonesing for it right now.

3
kasutori_JackSan Francisco Giants•

Goddamnit now I'm thinking about spicy cheese gyudon.

It's basically a Philly cheesesteak in a bowl over rice with sririacha and fuck vegetables.

Why would you remind me of what I can't have...

3
scarface910San Francisco Giants•

I was hoping you'd provide an alternative :(

Closest I can find is yoshinoya in Santa Clara/Cupertino. Shame they don't carry the 3 cheese version.

2
kasutori_JackSan Francisco Giants•

I didnt know there was a yoshinoya there. If I had a car, I'd go.

1
bedell37•

I think it's just lack of cultural tact. If it was customary for Japanese people to shit on the floor, you would expect them not to do it if they came to your country. In the same way, I think US players ought to respect Japanese culture and be a bit more tidy when they're there. It's part of baseball culture in America, but that doesn't make it okay in Japan.

10
ChelsorKansas City Royals•

When they're wanting MLB to be showcased in Japan, it's perfectly acceptable.

You're playing in the NPB? Then no, you need to assimilate.

This is nonsense.

-1
twistedmind1586San Francisco Giants•

No one forced MLB to play. They doing it to market MLB in Japan. Don't act this is all for the good of NPB.

When a friend invites you over do you spit on their floor just because you do it at your home? No.

You go to someone else's home, you follow their rules, even if invited.

1
ScottBoras•

Would think sunflower seeds certainly play into it. Players treat the field and dugout floor with them, like you would peanut shells in a bar years ago. Japanese kids had to be taught what sunflower seeds are, as this article notes.

Add the use of chew, which requires spitting, and then at that point, bottles won't be a big deal. You'll see this in the minor leagues as well, so not a money thing I would think but there's certainly more people that take of you and the places as you go up levels. Cultural difference.

4
lukothebossLos Angeles Angels•

The general reaction on that post is seriously ridiculous. American and Japanese culture is very different, spitting dip and sunflower seeds on the ground is part of American baseball. It takes about 2 minutes with a hose to clean up after a game, if that.

I hate how so many people on reddit judge things without even bothering to understand them. The vast majority of redditors don't know anything about baseball, and reading through those comments really proved that for me.

I'm passionate about baseball, I want as many people to like baseball as I can. But trying to educate baseball to those who are self-righteous neckbeards requires more effort than I am willing to give.

3
TempAltOP•

Well put

1
ChelsorKansas City Royals•

Thank you for giving me a bit of hope. This is nonsense, there isn't a better word for it.

If it wasn't the offseason I'd accuse OP, and anyone else trying to make it a discussion, of trying to force a story like the media does.

This is my face when people are trying to make this in to something

0
isiramgreenSeattle Mariners•

Definitely a part of the baseball sub culture.

Little leaguers from an early age emulate their favorite players; spitting, chewing, eating sunflowers, pouring a full cup of gatorade/taking a sip/ then throwing the rest of it on the ground..

I'm positive players in Japan are taught to respect the venue the play at. Getting a big head over there is frowned upon. (I could be wrong)

2
ChelsorKansas City Royals•

Ah, but the assumption is that spitting tobacco on the floor means you don't respect your home stadium? This is nonsense talk.

It's no wonder the world is in such a weird way, people don't even get the concept of different cultures. Different cultures means the Japanese don't spit on the floor of the dugout. It does not mean that US players don't respect their stadiums simply because they do spit on the dugout floor.

0
jy_amToronto Blue Jays•

This not the first year that this series has taken place. So is this the first year that the MLB players left the dugout in this state, or that it was reported in the Japanese media?

2
twistedmind1586San Francisco Giants•

Damn people in this this are just as ignorant as the r/pics thread. MLBs team certainly didn't know what they were doing, but they still should have had a little more respect. Honest mistake.

But MLB doesn't have a right to do whatever they want. They didn't play this series to benefit Japanese baseball. They're marketing. Can't justify these pics by saying "they wanted us, we can do whatever we want!"

1
ChelsorKansas City Royals•

Who gives a shit?

They want MLB to come over, well, they did. It's not a big deal at all. It's a cultural difference - am I missing something?

Or is it I'm supposed to feel shame and feel bad for the poor bastard who has to clean it up? So that guy is somehow worse off than the guys in the US who clean this up 162 games a year? Nah.

0
THEriot2Chicago Cubs•

Welcome to the big leagues.

-1