[deleted]•

[deleted]

7
nilstycho•

I think it's actually only one component of the cocktail that is supply-constrained: sodium thiopental. In addition to euthanasia, it is used as an anesthetic, especially as a veterinary anesthetic.

Some experts recommend asphyxiation by inert gas as the most humane method of euthanasia. It is a common option for assisted suicide, although it would be less humane when the subject is unwilling.

12
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
gpunotpsu•

Why is inert gas asphyxiation less humane for an unwilling subject?

2
nilstycho•

An unwilling subject may resist inhaling for as long as possible, gasping and thrashing in panic and desperation. Effectively, they may begin to suffocate themselves with CO2 buildup in their lungs (which is painful) rather than the ambient inert gas (which is painless). The executioner could administer a sedative, but that only raises the question of how the sedative would be administered.

3
DigitalMindShadow•

dart gun

3
gpunotpsu•

Interesting. I never though about that. It would still be a good option for people who can willingly submit. You could choose between inert gas and whatever the state's other option is.

2
DrDuPont•

Can you or someone else expand on why it is that the CO2 buildup causes pain, but that of the inert gas does not?

1
The_Time_Master•

Why not carbon monoxide poisoning? Since people fall asleep in running cars and die all the time.

1
NotSafeForEarthOP•

I'm curious as to what the non-execution use of the cocktail is.

Probably as an anaesthetic – which is a matter of dosage.

Also, it seems to me the guillotine is the quickest and most humane option for execution.

The guillotine however makes it hard for the audience to justify the brutality of the act to themselves. The "great" thing about lethal injection: Unlike certain kinds of hypoxic e.g. argon gas executions, it causes additional suffering and is cruel but you can't really see the cruelty and the suffering, so like waterboarding, it's easier to justify to critics. Which makes it perfect for America. The guillotine would be the opposite of that: It wouldn't cause as much additional cruelty and suffering, but you can really see it and it looks really cruel. That, I think, is why America doesn't use this method.

  • Hypoxic/inert gas executions: You don't see much cruelty and there isn't much.

  • Guillotine: You see much cruelty, but there isn't really as much.

  • Lethal injection: You don't see much cruelty, but there often is quite a lot.

I think a non-botched firing squad execution is similar to the guillotine in these regards: Done properly, there isn't that much additional suffering induced, but you really see the act for what it is, stripped of any going-to-sleep delusions and justifications.

So it would not just be but also look really, really drastic if Utah were to actually go through with this.

If you haven't already, watch this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dDlDN2nsopE
It makes it really clear towards the end that America's capital punishment advocates want the cruelty. It's a bit of a shame that the presenter just accepts their argument, but that's probably to do Michael Portillo's politics.

8
chaosmosis•

Don't guillotines sometimes fail to chop all the way through? Or is that something that happened historically but that we could easily prevent with today's technology?

I've also heard what essentially amount to rumors that sometimes the head lives for a few seconds after being disconnected from the body.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
NotSafeForEarthOP•

Don't guillotines sometimes fail to chop all the way through?

That would be a very badly designed/built guillotine. The ones the French used were not.

I've also heard what essentially amount to rumors that sometimes the head lives for a few seconds after being disconnected from the body.

That's almost certainly true, but you probably wouldn't feel any pain, because you'd be in shock – and then you'd just lose consciousness due to lack of oxygen and blood pressure. It's a pretty brutal and drastic act, but there are worse ways to go as far as pain and human suffering are concerned.

2
plonce•

Wood chipper anybody? Really, is this so hard to figure out?

-6
NotSafeForEarthOP•
-7