Anderson for Eberle and Methot for Shultz trade talk.(Article in French)
toutsurlehockey.com/23088/manchettes/tslh/SPE...Posted Nov 28, 2014, 1:48 PM UTC
Posted Nov 28, 2014, 1:48 PM UTC
I like this trade, i just dont think its going to happen.
I really like this trade, I just really don't think it's going to happen. :(
Trading Anderson for an addition to our young core is a good idea imo. His value will never be higher, and let's face it: we aren't in it to win it all this year.
It is just a rumour. But, it seems Edmonton is dead set on making a fairly big trade happen, so I wouldn't count Ottawa out for a possible trade. Even landing Perron would be pretty sick.
From what I'm reading, the writer is saying that Shawn Simpson proposed it on the Team. Seems like a realistic trade, but I'm not sure if it's even a "rumour".
Eberle, I like though.
I like Shawn's energy, but I disagree with him on a lot of things. I'm not sure how much I'd trust him as a source. The Sens usually work though Garrioch if they want stuff in the news.
That being said I think the Anderson trade makes sense from certain points of view, but it would really be big news. I wouldn't like acquiring Schultz.
Same. I think he's an entertaining radio personality and really good at what he does but when it comes to evaluating talent he just puts way too much stock into things like "nervous energy" and "vibes." I also just flat-out disagree with his assessment of many a senator's skill set, like how he always says Zibanejad is slow. David Legwand is slow. Mika Zibanejad is definitely not slow.
When he calls players slow I'm dying for more information, like whether it's their decision making, acceleration or top speed that's slow, and how far into the shift are they, and where should they be? I want more information and all I get are narratives from broadcasters too lazy/crunched for time to do anything more in depth.
I think Mika's looked a little slow out there, but I have no idea. He's had pretty bad wingers this season and maybe he's playing it slow because he doesn't trust his wingers. Give him Hoff and Stone and I think he'll look a lot better. Also there are rumours about his conditioning level after a heart problem he had last season.
They seem to. In this case, it actually sounds like Shawn is just proposing the trade anyway, not saying it's happening or even been discussed.
Anderson trade is good, but the Methot one isn't
Considering he's a UFA after this season and the team doesn't want to pay him what he wants, getting anything for him might not be a bad thing
They could get more than Shultz by sending Methot to a contender at the deadline.
Maybe, maybe not. If a team hasn't signed an extension with a non-returning UFA and that player gets traded at the deadline, there is as much pressure on the seller as there is the buyer. I think Edmonton is a perfect trade partner because they need established defence and players willing to live there. Very hard signing UFA's there because of the weather and track record. I personally like this team with Karlsson/Methot, Ceci/Cowan, Boro/Weircioch d pairings. Philips and Gryba can be the injury reserves. That said, if Methot won't sign for a number that the team is comfortable with, get something for him ASAP.
Ah, French. The bane of my existence in Ottawa.
Mais pourquoi? :P
baguette
Not sure I like the Methot deal. I could deal with the Anderson one
I assume we'd get a goalie back for Anderson so that they didn't have to waive one? Fasth is a UFA at the end of the season but Scrivans makes less? Either would be a tremendous backup for Lehner.
Scrivens would be a great goalie to land in this deal to backup our Swedish Metal Head!
Anderson for Eberle reminds me of Bishop for Conacher on a bigger scale. I don't think Eberle is worth it for our team.
I really don't the idea of trading away Andy... A week ago, lehner was playing brutal. We're lucky we had Andy to turn back to. I honestly don't believe lehner is ready to be a full time starter yet
Edit: also, where would Eberle ideally play? We've already got such an influx of forwards
Agreed, I'm not sold on Lehner yet. My gf refers to him as "the crappy goalie" and sometimes it's hard not to agree with her.
He's not necessarily a bad goalie, he's just inconsistent as all hell. When he's on, he's great, but when he's off, good god is he off
is consistency not the difference between a good goalie and a bad goalie?
It doesn't help that our d-core is terrible most nights.
As good as he's playing lately, Andy will not win us a cup singlehandedly. Trading him for a young scoring winger right as his value is highest would actually be better long term than keeping him.
Oh I agree long term it'll help, but then we will be stuck with the a legit starting goalie...
Wasn't Schultz just recently scratched in Edmonton? From what I could see from Oilers fans reactions, he was absolutely brutal on a bad D-core. Can't see how he would help us, especially if we lose Methot. It's been pretty bad trying to replace him so far.
He would need a ton of coaching. I don't know what's causing him to be so bad defensively, but he is so bad defensively. It would take a lot of work for the coaching staff to salvage that, and if you're going to put in the time and trade a good player in Methot, why not just keep working with Wier and Cowen?
I'd prefer a Gryba + Smith deal for Petry or Marencin.
Petry? Are you kidding me? He's easily one of the worst defensemen in the entire NHL. The fans absolutely despise him there. Gryba is a better player and much more cost-effective than Petry so it doesn't make any sense to make that move.
My impression was that he is massively undervalued in Edmonton and has very good results considering the situation. Why do you think he's so bad?
There are a lot of ways to evaluate a defenceman, but a fairly comprehensive one in dCorsi says he's playing above expectations(Expectations based on competition and zone starts etc. in orange and results in shot attempts in blue).
I like Gryba, and I put him there because I think Edmonton would like him too. Of Gryba/Phillips/Boro for the team's 7th defenceman (assuming Petry to Ottawa and Methot stays), Gryba is the best and also easiest to trade.
Well, you actually have statistics to back up your claims, so I guess there's nothing I can really say to refute that lol.
My statement was based on what many people with their finger on the pulse of the team consistently say about him. Guys like Ryan Rishaug rip him to shreds almost every night and after watching him play I tend to agree. He's just not a very good player and playing in Dallas Eakins' mess of a defensive system probably doesn't help him much either.
Anderson's the best goalie we've ever had (which isn't saying much, but still). Lehner's inconsistent. But this team isn't winning the Cup any time soon. Maybe we might as well just go with him and let the young core grow together, playoffs or not.
I remember Montreal trading Huet a while back just before the playoffs and going with a super-young Price. In the long run it worked out all right.
I guess you could say...the price was right. I'm leaving now..
I don't carey what you say, there's halak of humour in that post.
I disgust myself.
I was going to report this post as inappropriate, budaj gotta go.
I can't Anderson'd why you didn't reply Fasth'er.
Shultz is not a good player. Do. Not. Want.
I have no idea how reliable this website is, but there's talk between the Oilers and Sens for an Anderson for Eberle trade and possibly Methot for Shultz if the Oilers can sign Methot to an extension.
I feel like for now we shouldn't be rushing to give up our defensive strengths, we only have so many.
I really hope we aren't actually getting rid of Anderson. Not yet, anyway - Lehner just isn't quite ready to start, I don't think. He will be, and maybe soon, like next season, but not yet.
Why would it matter when we ship out Andy? This is a bubble team at best, and trading him for a young scoring winger when his value is high seems like a great scenario. We won't contend for the cup with or without Andy, so planning for the future seems smarter to me.
If Methot won't re-sign here for an acceptable price (esp. given the potential for reaggravating whatever is ailing him now), then I'd be ok with the latter trade. I think we really desperately need a top-2/4 guy like Methot if we want to win consistently right now, but getting a decent (maybe) asset like Shultz back wouldn't be the worst thing ever.
Andy for Eberle? Ouch, that's a tough one to swallow. I agree that it's fair(ish) and that we have 2 capable goaltenders, but 2 worries come to mind. First, many Edmonton fans were saying that Eberle is really good beside Hall, but not so much by himself (esp. for $6mil a year) - not sure how true that is, but it's a worry. Secondly, with Andy gone Lehner takes over. That alone, while scary, might not be a bad thing, but finding a backup (Bryz, Brodeur, and then it all goes further downhill) that we can be confident in winning our games does sound like a recipe for many sad games. I'm now accustomed to the luxury of two great goalies, both signed for a while, who are splitting time and stealing games for us.
The trading value of a goalie isn't like it use to be. When was the last time that a goalie got as good as a return as Eberle? Look what Sens got for Ben Bishop. I really think it will take much more to get some one like Eberle (especially since he isn't a rental).
Oh no doubt, but good point. I suspect there would be some picks or prospects, and/or even someone like Greening/Condra/Smith heading back the other way too. However, everything I've heard seems to point to Eberle being over-valued by fans outside of the Oiler fanbase. Additionally, Andy is currently a top tier goalie (statistically, at least) on a defensively challenged team that's not hosting a fire sale, and he's also signed at ~$3+mil for several more years. Edmonton also seems to desperately need to fix a leaky goal line, due more to goal-tending or defense is debatable.
Point is, I think Eberle's value is lower than we think, and to Edmonton Andy's value is actually pretty high. So extra assets heading to Edmonton wouldn't be substantial (from our perspective), and could actually be more focused around evening the deal if someone like Fasth we being shipped back as part of the deal too (saves them waiving a goalie, and brings us a backup).
But EDM is in no rush to move Eberle. Why make a move to still be out of the playoff and not have a good draft pick. The only way they move Eberle at this moment is for a great hockey trade.. (Anderson + Lazar). If not, they will wait at the deadline or the draft to get the value.
EDM may suck right now, but the worst thing they can do is to rush to move one of your key piece for a quick fix. I am sure that if Ottawa is only offering Anderson and some prospect (sens got almost as good for Spezza who requested a trade, plus only has 1 year to his contract and is getting "old"), EDM will find a much better deal somewhere else.
Edit: We are also talking about a goalie that has had difficulties just last year.
Yeah, that's (all) true - although on the Spezza note, despite factors against him, he's still an elite scoring center while Ebs is just a "good" winger.
Most notably, I hadn't considered that the deadline might be a better time to make a deal (short of something exceptional), especially since Eberle is not a rental. I wonder how much this trade talk is just fan speculation thanks to a tire fire of a season start in Edmonton, and how much is genuinely management either bowing to public pressure or being proactive in solving their issues early rather than wait for boat to sail?
It wouldn't be a quick fix, though. Anderson is signed long-term so they'd be suring up the goaltending position for years to come.
Dont you touch my Lazar
Meh, most teams just understand the value of a #1 goalie and don 't put them on the market ever unless they're playing poorly. If Nashville decided to put Rinne on the market today, they'd reap a huge return. They'd never do it though because even if they got back a 40 goal-scorer, a top 4 dman and a 1st round pick, it still might not be enough.
Andy's playing great but he is getting older, I'd be all for swapping him for Eberle.
I don't think the Sens are a great fit for any trade with the Oilers. If you want to trade for Eberle (or Yakupov), the sens will need to trade at least 2 of : Anderson, Lehner, Cecci, Lazar, Zbad or a signed Methot (I don't think Methot will want a signed and trade). In addition to those 2 players, they would need to give a 1st or a 2nd.
Both team are not in a rush to make a move so I don't see the Sens giving that much for a player and I don't see EDM being undersold on a young star forward signed until 2019.
Just my opinion.
Ya know, I'd make both of these trades. I'd sweeten the pot with greening and a salary split for 2 years, for eberle
There have been serious concerns regarding Eberle's work ethic and attitude. I agree on selling Anderson while he's hot, but I'd like to see something else coming back our way. I'd honestly rather see Yakupov coming our way than Eberle.
Why would we trade away something we don't have much of (Defense) for something we have in spades (young, inexperienced, skilled forwards)?
Andy for Eberle. Methot for Schultz. We aren't losing a Dman in this.
We gain Eberle, the aforementioned young, inexperienced, and skilled forward. We lose Methot, who in my opinion is greater than or at least equal to Schultz, and Anderson who, while not a defenseman, is a defensive asset on this team.
I wanna keep Methot. I really like him. Im not sure trading Andy is a good ideal, cause hes the only reason we are winning a lot of our games.
He and Robin, definitely are why we are winning.
But its time for Lehner to be the starter, #1 goalie. Andy's on a roll, good time to trade him for something else.
Exactly. Sell him when his value is high.
Yep. We might make the playoffs this year, but certainly aren't cup contenders. If we can get good value for Anderson I say take it, even if it means killing our playoff hopes this year (which I don't think it necessarily would). Anderson is and has been great for us, but will likely be on the downslide by the time we're near contention.
Andy is leading right now, but the fact is we are not a team that is going to push. We "MAY" make the playoffs maybe, but as it stands he is worth something, and we can get a really good return. And by the time our team is grown up enough to challenge Lehner will be our leader.
Shultz didn't want to sign with us when he was an FA...
Methot
arguablyis our best defensive defensemen, and even if he's injured, I still feel safer keeping him as Karlsson's partner than anyone else.Also he's a hometown boy. Gotta keep that link.