"Do you know who is the bankrupt?"
Abu Hurairah (RA) reported:
The Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: "Do you know who is the bankrupt?"
They said: "The bankrupt among us is one who has neither money with him nor any property".
He said: "The real bankrupt of my Ummah would be he who would come on the Day of Resurrection with Salat (prayer), Saum (fast) and Sadaqah (charity), (but he will find himself bankrupt on that day as he will have exhausted the good deeds) because he reviled others, brought calumny against others, unlawfully devoured the wealth of others, shed the blood of others and beat others; so his good deeds would be credited to the account of those (who suffered at his hand). If his good deeds fall short to clear the account, their sins would be entered in his account and he would be thrown in the (Hell) Fire".
Sahih Muslim
Posted Nov 28, 2014, 3:31 PM UTC
Doesn't the Qur'an say that no one shall bear the burden of another?
There's no contradiction here.
The Quran verses mean that you cannot be accountable for the sins of someone else if you didn't participate in those sins. You cannot be held responsible for something you didn't commit or had no part in it.
The hadith talks about something else. If someone wronged you and didn't apologize/you didn't accept his apologies, he has to reimburse you and like a brother said, the only currencies the day of Judgement are hassanat and sayyiat. So you'll be given some hassanat, let's say some hassanat he got from praying one night. Does that mean he never prayed that day, did all his prayers disappeared? No, he got the reward and now he's using that reward to pay his debts. That's the exact same thing for good and bad deeds that have no effects on others.
Let's say I stole a banana from you, never apologized and you do not forgive me. I have 0 hassanat and you have 200. So I have to take 20 sayyiat from you, does that mean Allah consider me to be responsible for the bad deeds that come from these 20 sayyiat? Not at all. In fact, we come to the same result if I just lose 20 hassanat (putting me in the negative) for stealing and you receive 20 hassanat as indemnification. What would contradict the Quran in this example is if I would steal a banana from you and on the day of Judgement, Allah says my boss is responsible for that because he didn't pay me enough. But that is never going to happen, it is my sin, it is my debt, whether my hassanat are used to grant me the highest level of Jannah, to pay for my addiction to alcohol or the damage I did around me in no way contradicts the fact that I'll be the only one held responsible for these sins if no one else took part in them.
This is a different circumstance than what you're discussing. Just to make sure I'm not totally missing your question, can you provide some citation for what you're talking about?
From what I've been taught, on judgment day we will have a pile of hasanat standing next to us. Others will say "brother/sister Maslawi wronged me in such and such ways!" and to account for this transgression, you will give the appropriate amount of hasanat from your pile and add it to theirs. This hadith discusses people who've transgressed so much that their pile of good deeds has been completely depleted due to others wanting compensation for said transgressions; and yet there are still others who have a right to some of that person's hasanat due to further transgressions. In this circumstance, since this person no longer has any good deeds to give as compensation, they now have to take on the burden of the other's sins.
Essentially, he's going into a debt of good deeds. Does that make sense? Please, do your own research on this as I could very well be misinformed/misunderstood the lesson taught by my teacher
You seem to be much more knowledgable on this topic than me. This verse has always stuck out to me:
To me this suggests that good deads will only benefit the person who performed them and will not be transfered to anyone else. The hadith seems to suggest that good deads are transfered, this is where my confusion lies. Similarly the hadith seems to be saying that the sins of those who have been wronged will be entered into the account of the transgressor. Will the one whose sins has been transfered be unburdened of these sins? Also what if this persons sins outweigh the debt of the transgressor, will all of their sins be transfered or just enough to relieve the debt?
The verse and the Hadith go hand in hand. Think of hasanat as a currency whose amount indicates your level of reward. Sayyi'aat count as negative currency. In order to do accounting for huquq ul ibad and balance everything out (literally that's what Hisaab means) the hasanat and sayyi'aat are shifted from person to person until the person has exactly what they deserve. In this setup, when you wrong another person (or creature!) it does not get added to either the hasanat or sayyi'aat piles of either parties. Instead the accounting for it happens on the day of judgment by the process mentioned in the Hadith. If the wronged person chooses to forgive then no transfer takes place (and I'm sure that Allah gives the person hasanat for their forgiveness).
So nobody is bearing the burdens of another. They all get what they deserve.
But surely the transfer from one person to the other would indicate a transfer of burden (sayyi'aat/sins) or reward (hasanat). Does this not contradict the Qur'an which insists that whoever does good deads, these will only be of benefit to him (rather than be transfered to someone else) and that whoever sins - it will only effect his soul and no one elses.
I see what you're saying about the currency but it seems to contradict the Qur'an. Surely there is a way to balance out reward/sins that doesn't involve the transfer thereof between people?
It's a central concept in the deen Allah taught his messengers. I would personally hold this in authority over whatever hadith that was. Allah mentioned it in (at least) 3 different scriptures.
Or has he not been informed of what was in the scriptures of Moses, And [of] Abraham, who fulfilled [his obligations] - That no bearer of burdens will bear the burden of another, And that there is not for man except that [good] for which he strives, And that his effort is going to be seen, Then he will be recompensed for it with the fullest recompense, And that to your Lord is the finality (53:36-42)
Say: What! shall I seek a Lord other than Allah? And He is the Lord of all things; and no soul earns (evil) but against itself, and no bearer of burden shall bear the burden of another; then to your Lord is your return, so He will inform you of that in which you differed (6:164)