Why can the History Channel(s) legally broadcast shows that are falsifying history and science?

Personally, I think it should be mandatory to have a full disclaimer at the bottom of the screen permanently attached to every second of falsified or unscientific programming that they air.

Posted Nov 30, 2014, 5:07 AM UTC

043
[deleted]•

[deleted]

28
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
sweeptheleg55•

They don't air the walking dead or Lucy on those channels.

A channel called "we tell the truth" should probably be held accountable for atleast attempting to tell the truth. History and Discovery for the longest time were attempting to follow through on their conceit.

It just turned out Americans would rather be lied to and feel entertained because they also feel like they are watching something true.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
lamarskibag•

Comedy Central does not always air comedies. I think Comedy Central does exclusively air comedy.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
pewpewlasors•

The real problem here, is dumb American laws. The History channel isn't the problem, but Fox "news" would be illegal in Canada, because its illegal to lie on the news there. A law News Corp (Fox's Parent company) spent millions lobbying to try and repeal.

This is really all the proof you need that Republicans are pure evil. Fox is the propaganda arm of the Republican party. Fact.

News corp owns Fox, and they specifically want to lie to the public. They spent millions to try and do so. Fact.

Republicans have a propaganda news station that lies to, and misleads the public.

They're fucking evil.

Oh, my point was, this is all legal in the US, because our Freedom of Speech laws go way too far.

-8
petrov2500•

Fox news tells the truth. Canada is run by a bunch of fascist pigs with a terrible healthcare system. America is the land of the free!

1
Fripples•

What law do you suppose they would be breaking?

20
pewpewlasors•

They should be required to be a History channel. Catering to ratings, on a niche channel that is already subsidized by the Cable package model, should be illegal.

So should lying on the news though, and that is legal in the US.

-5
con77•

you are whats wrong with this country

-9
Spiderkite•

Not the rampant gun crime, not the disgusting education practices, or fear of free healthcare, not the third world education rate or rampant racism, the unwillingness to help immigrants and refugees regardless of what the country's charter states. Its that guy, who is confused bout broadcast law.

/rant

1
con77•

gun crime by criminals, not law abiding gun owners. Teachers are indoctrinating your kids. Healthcare is not free and we don't owe illegal invaders A THING!!!

0
Spiderkite•

That sure explains all those school shootings by legal gun owners. Health, education, an the right to be safe without the requirement to bear arms are basic human rights everywhere in the world, bar warring states, and America. You're indoctrinating yourself. Last point, if you see small children and war orphans as INVADERS when your basic founding charter states that any and all are welcome, you're genuinely ignorant of your own country's purpose.

1
lava9611•

Who are you are anyone else to say what is real and what is false? Would you be ok with some authority deciding? What if the authority decided that Christianity was false and could not longer be broadcast... Would you still be ok with that?

This is the very principal on which the US was founded. Each individual gets to hear all sides and then decide what is right. It is not up to you or anyone else to decide this for me! While we may have warped this fundamental right at times, it is still important that we all defend this right so that it is not taken away in the name of stupidity. While you may not agree with what is being said, it is your duty to defend their right to say it if you want to maintain the freedom you enjoy.

That is all...

8
Shunshundy•

Speaking of Christianity the next ancient aliens episode is about Jesus. Yea people would probably be pissed if they had to scientifically prove prayer cloths worked before they could sell them to the public.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
FakeAudioOP•

Have you not watched the history channel in the past few years? They don't air actual history. Ever heard of ancient aliens, or any of their other rediculous programs?

-6
pewpewlasors•

Americans are idiots, its legal to lie on the news here.

3
klug3•

Yeah, American Movie Classics doesn't air movies all the time either, what's your point ?

1
pewpewlasors•

Simple. That shouldn't be allowed.

0
Fripples•

If you don't like it, don't watch it. They're not breaking any laws. Get over it.

-1
pewpewlasors•

There should be a law.

0
FakeAudioOP•

Are you trolling, or are you really that apathetic and stupid?

-7
GasOnADugong•

He's saying that just because it's stupid, doesn't mean it should be illegal.

The US (and many countries) have freedom of speech and freedom of the press, and that's generally a good thing - even if it does mean that people are free to go on tv and say they think we're descended from aliens.

5
Fripples•

I just don't watch it because it's not worth watching. There's no legal obligation for what is ultimately just entertainment to be scientifically accurate.

1
Robotguy27•

Name calling won't get you anywhere.

1
Shunshundy•

TV is just for entertainment they would have to have some kind of regulatory committee that would approve what comes on, if they do that for the history channel they would have to do it for the rest.

6
strikefire83•

We do have some sort of "regulatory committee" it is called the Federal Communications Commission ant it is the TV gatekeeper. The FCC is really only empowered to handle administrative issues such as payment for and licensing of the public airwaves. The First Amendment only allows the FCC to regulate "obscene" content, and they haven't exercised this power much in the past 40 years. The Janet Jackson boob incident is the only thing that comes to mind.

4
smokeyjoey8•

FCC can only regulate over-the-air television, like CBS, NBC, FOX, CW, ABC, because they are broadcast on the public spectrum. They have no control over cable. You won't be seeing "fuck" or anything equally obscene on cable networks as long as they're supported by advertisers, and you won't see nudity for the same reason (though cable networks are getting more risque). But if AMC decided one day to air a full frontal nude scene on one of their shows, they could, so long as it's in good taste (not porn).

4
number90901•

They say "fuck" in Mad Men a few times. (Oddly enough, there's one time when it's muted but the others are out loud)

2
CharlesNapalm•

The History Channel is about history as much as MTV is about music.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ohsureyoudo•

What could be more educational than a pawn shop? Just ask Chumlee.

4
Noy2222•

I don't know much about education, let me call a buddy of mine.

2
Salvyana420tr•

Any good examples? Now i haven't watched History Channel in the past 3-4 years, but back when i did it was only well documented history documentaries.

3
Shunshundy•

History channel and Natgeo are all about aliens, religion, monsters, ghost, the Vikings landed in Texas, David Crocket escape the Alamo to live in Alabama, big foot lives in Tennessee . Other non sense.

4
FakeAudioOP•

Ancient aliens is just one of many rediculous programs.

2
sobok•

But there's no proof they didn't happen!

4
deviationer•

Ever notice how many times ancient aliens uses may, could, might, etc. The only people who say something definitive are those true believer's/"experts". The show is just for entertainment and to question how stuff thousands of years ago could have happened.

Its still better than what history use to be known for. The Hitler channel.

1
moon_at_the_wayside•

Ancient Aliens have a disclaimer. In the beginning of the show, the narrator says something like " Many people believe aliens helped our ancestors in the past. What if it was true?" The whole show is speculation about aliens on Earth. You can learn some history from it, just ignore all the alien stuff.

1
VaguerCrusader•

I seem to remember they ran a a disclaimer before a documentary distancing themselves from the beliefs of what was to follow .. I was all "oh shit this must be some heavy shit" and the documentary was...

FDR KNEW ABOUT PEARL HARBOR BEFORE IT HAPPENED!!!!

2
smokeyjoey8•

History Channel never claims their programming is factual. It's up to the viewer to decide if what they are watching is factual, educational material, not the History Channel. They are breaking no laws. There is a law that requires over-the-air networks to broadcast a certain number of hours of educational entertainment, but History and all other cable networks aren't bound by it.

If you don't like what History airs, don't watch it. That's all you can do. Unfortunately, millions of people do enjoy their programming, so it's not likely to change for awhile.

1
illpoet•

I used to watch the history channel religiously. now it just pisses me off, and i pretty much stick to watching the internet.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
con77•

They are making shows that are politically correct depicting times that were anything but. I turn them off.

0