Chesney1995Quest cape 01/02/2015 (RSN: Cacus)•

Anyone who doesn't use authenticator turn it on.

It doesn't take a stupid mistake (past not having authenticator) to lose your account. It can happen to anyone, and when your account gets hacked, most likely it will be used for botting, and banned permanently. At that point there's no way in hell JaGex support are going to help you. It happened to my brother who was banned within 1 day of discovering he'd been hacked, and he lost all of his progress in Runescape forever. Activating authenticator takes 1 minute and can save you years of work on your account. You don't need to send JaGex any personal info, simply link a gmail (or other) account and ideally two-step verify that as well, an authenticator app, and your Runescape account and you are protected from most hackers. You only need to enter a 6-digit code once every 30 days, it is no hassle at all.

You can activate it here if you haven't already.

45
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

Thank you! Everything you said I agree with.

What do you think of my suggestions? I feel a lot more can be done to get players to use the authenticator. This can help kill off the hijacking industry and clean up our game.

10
Chesney1995Quest cape 01/02/2015 (RSN: Cacus)•

Anything that gets more people to use the authenticator I support. Personally I think it should be mandatory for all new accounts but then again not everyone has access to a smart-phone or tablet. I like the idea of extra bank-space for having it, or perhaps we could get a small boost to xp for turning it on or something like that.

4
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

Authenticator can actually be used on Windows and Mac osx without a smart phone. I am not sure about Linux, will look into that.

2
Chesney1995Quest cape 01/02/2015 (RSN: Cacus)•

Ah I wasn't aware of that. I've only ever used it on my phone.

2
Piece_Maker•

There's a TOTP plugin (and a regular OTP) for KeePass that works on Linux, though you have to use the Mono version (not the native KeePassX). I've just set it up after reading this thread and going on a quick search!

2
AlmostNPCSlyp •

Don't forget two-step verification for email.

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
MintyFreshnesss2168/2595•

Depends on your account, more than likely they're trying to clean it of any gp you have on it to rwt it.

4
Chesney1995Quest cape 01/02/2015 (RSN: Cacus)•

From what I've seen they do both. RWT off the stuff it already has and then turn it into a gold-farming bot.

4
MintyFreshnesss2168/2595•

I doubt they're gonna turn any high level accounts in to gold farming bots, maybe if you're only playing periodically but your acc can be easily locked if there's suspicious activity happening on it.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
Brook3yBrookay•

I use it on both my RS and my battle.net account and they're so ridiculously effective that I can't think of any valid reason to not use it.

2
iLuxy•

Sorry bro, never been "hacked", never will be "hacked". It's literally impossible to hack someone with common sense. But i'll tell you what, my bank might not be much, but i'm sure a free 430m is a free 430m. Try to "hack" me.

-3
PsionSquared•

Not that I disagree, since I've never been hacked, but the authenticator is handy if your memory of bank pins gets rusty.

7
Puyo1Puyo•

I've never had my account compromised either, but turning down the extra security of the authenticator is downright stupid. Your quote of "literally impossible" just goes to show how uneducated you are about this kind of thing.

3
Fahrowshusyou can't unread this•

well I'll be bold and say it is impossible to hack mine. I just use JAG, which helps make it impossible.

a hacker would need my username (which isn't an email address, and there is no one who remembers my first name in the game). the hacker would also need my email address that is linked to my account, which doesn't exist and cannot be created. they would have to have access to my personal computer and my personal cell-phone for two-step verification through my email.

it's just not possible to hack me. places balls on the table, and hands over a knife

0
t0mfTom F•

Give players 50 extra bank spaces

O dear God please

19
Lurker_242It's not easy being green.•

"20% of oldschool players" != "20% of players"

17
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

True, but I would be willing to bet less took it up on RS3. I'll try find out. I am going to tweet @JagexPorky.

-6
Lurker_242It's not easy being green.•

I would assume the adoption rate on RS3 to be higher, actually. Call me an optimist, but I refuse to believe 80% of the playerbase would be dumb enough to leave their accounts unprotected.

11
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

I speak to players daily in RS3 who don't know what the authenticator is. A lot of returning players have no idea.

Though I like your optimism, I wish I shared it!

3
Lurker_242It's not easy being green.•

Right, returning players would not know about it as it is no longer widely advertised. This is one instance where Jagex' love for popups on login wouldn't hurt; if a player does not have Auth enabled, show them an info window about it (with the option to "never show this again" so it doesn't turn into spam).

3
Letumstrike•

It's not just "dumb" people. Can't fuckin do it without a smartphone and I'm not willing to pay for a data plan.

also definitely not willing to buy a usb.

-1
Lurker_242It's not easy being green.•

Can't fuckin do it without a smartphone

Uuuhhhm...

also definitely not willing to buy a usb

A small USB stick costs less than one month of membership.

1
Llaver•

Maybe if they would fix it so it actually takes 30 days for it to reset more people would want it/not turn it off.

11
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

That's a fair concern. I will add it to my thread soon.

4
braidsfoxRSN: Tecca N9na•

It takes about 10 seconds to open the app and type in the 6 digit code. Is 10 seconds worth the risk of losing years of work? Not a big issue whatsoever.

3
Llaver•

While this is true, it's still a nuisance. I typed in my code yesterday. I know that no one will be using my computer. My ip hasn't changed. The files haven't been deleted off of my computer. Why am I typing it in again?

4
EpicBot•

It probebly has something to do with background processes. You might be running a program that keeps deleting the auth key.

For example: On my clean OS Win 8.1 Noting installed except java, chrome, 1 school program(Stupid thing didn't run on main OS). The auth key lasts 30 days the way it's supposed to work.

On my normal OS win 8.1 I have a shitload of background processes running like: Anti-Malware, Anti-Virus, Pc Optimiser, ect...

On there the auth keys lasts till I reboot.

So probably it's your computer that is at fault here not jagex.

3
killer4u77Give me the budder•

Except no matter what happens, I'm pretty sure it has a cap at two weeks.

2
Llaver•

That was my thought at first too, but I actually reinstalled windows the other day for a different reason. Not a whole lot installed yet and it still removes it occasionally.

1
Roger_Fcog•

JAG takes 0 seconds, and as long as you aren't retarded it is more than enough protection

0
EpicBot•

I can answer most of the JAG questions my friends had. It only makes it a bit harder, and offers a fake feeling of extra security.

1
Roger_Fcog•

Most doesn't get them into the account, and this is after they got your password. Like I said, you have to not be retarded. It would be just as easy for one of your friends to snatch your phone, if not easier.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
SysyphusX99•

You own a computer though, right? You can download the authenticator on your PC and it's just as secure. Sorry but your comment reeks of ignorance.

Edit: LOL he deleted his comment. It said "I don't have a smartphone. Get off my dick."

7
VULGAR_ACT_IN_CAPS•

Don't you have to scan a QR code to get Authenticator to work though? Meaning a PC client won't work?

-3
GodelRSTetsu•

I just went ahead and disabled JAG (on my main) and enabled Authenticator on my main + Ironman after reading through some concerns highlighted in this thread. Not that I'm paranoid or anything; I'm a graduate in IT with Systems and Security concentration. I know a good amount of security paradigms and recognize token authentication as one of the stronger ones.

I thought it was about time I upgraded...I also happen to know Jagex keeps the answers for JAG answers saved in the clear (non-encrypted) so if their security would be comprimised, there's no guarentee my JAG answers would remain safe. Now that is kind of what scared me about JAG.

One major reason for not doing so before was due to the lack of an app compatible phone. The reason I didn't use the desktop version is because if a backdoor manages to get deep enough into your computer to keylog you, they can just take the information which makes that authenticator work straight from your harddrive. A phone is a lot more secure for me as I do much less on it.

I don't think a lot of people realise you can do the authenticator without having a smartphone. You might want to highlight that.

6
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

Thanks, I will add it to my list for when I update the thread. I agree, most people don't realise authenticator can be setup without a smart phone.

You've probably already done it, but secure your registered email with two-step authentication. :)

2
The_Old_Nite•

That shouldn't scare you at all because a person needs to get past your 2 step gmail to get to your JAG answers lol... If they get past your 2 step they can simply disable Authenticator and gg, it's the same shit except JAG is easier to use, 2 step is the only thing you need.

-5
GodelRSTetsu•

Any (professional) company will absolutely never store something like your passwords. They almost always store the cypher of your password + a salt that was generated before it was sent. The fact that your JAG answers were almost more powerful than your password alone and the fact they were not being stored as a salted, encrypted hash key but rather an unencrypted plain text file really, really worried me.

And if you ask how I knew this, a friend had trouble with his JAG answers because he slightly forgot some of the answers and they needed to confirm his identity by him providing answers that were close to his actual JAG answers. They should not have had access to such data. And if anyone thinks you can compare the similarity between something like "may2007" and "may 2007" while they're encrypted, you will be unhappy to learn you have a lot to learn about cryptology and it would be impossible to make any rational corelation between them.

tl;dr: JAG is NOT secure going by the standards of what is considered secure in the professional Information Technology industry.

5
The_Old_Nite•

Neither is Authenticator since it can be removed just by having your email hacked L. They're exactly the same, both JAG and authenticator are remove via gmail so neither is more secure than the other... Also, you can't recover an account with just JAG questions, you need to login to your email and click on the mail Jagex sent you that will bring you to the JAG questions page.

-3
Theta_ZeroRunefest 2014•

I understand the security benefits of authenticators but I hate hate hate having to rely on outside expectations (like smartphone ownership) and conditions (like my phone not being dead) to play a video game. I've had to wait 15-20 minutes for my phone to charge just to log in after work before. It's infuriating. There's a reason why passwords are the most common method for security: All they require is you.

You know what's just as effective as an Autheticator? A strong, unique password you don't use everywhere else on the internet. Authenticators shouldn't be a crutch for people to not understand basic security. It should be a tool for those to enhance security for critical things that require the extra layer, like government information.

It's cool that they offer the option, and I myself use it. But fuck making it mandatory.

5
favpenguin•

Charge your phone at work?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
hylebus•

Any password is keyloggable, or can be intercepted by several methods like Man-in-the-middle attack on the way to Jagex servers unless the password is already crypted, which is just delaying the decryption. No single step authentication is as strong as two step authentication. You have no idea what you're talking about.
And if it's a problem for you to enter PIN once in 30 days, you're a lazy ass.

2
Theta_ZeroRunefest 2014•

I am a FULL SUPPORTER of multi-step authentication, but I've been doing two-step since the day bank pins were added, and then I added a third step with JAG. For me, I don't see the need four-step authentication, and I certainly don't want it to be made mandatory as was suggested.

If players would rather use autheticator pins than in-game pins or JAG, please let them. I'm not against it as a security method, just in making it a mandatory method. But praising it as the "best security method" tends to make people think that basic account security or additional authentication steps aren't necessary. The best account security isn't a cell phone app or biometrics. The best account security is you and common sense.

EDIT: For work (government related) I've used key fobs, credential cards, hard drive encription, secure VPNs, biometrics, 30/60/90-day rotating passwords and pins. Most of them are more annoying then they are practical. Secure, sure. Efficient, not in the least.

-1
hylebus•

Common sense won't help you against any competent hacker.
And nobody said two-step auth with generated PIN is best security method. But it is best for removing 99% threats without being too much hassle. Much better than using extreme passwords, which are easily forgotten.
Related

3
NickVascuas•

Stronghold of security revamp?

3
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

Yep, that was amongst my initial thoughts. Though for the authenticator I would want players to get immediate benefits after enabling it. I think that would promote the app more than anything.

2
Gunnuy•

Still don't like having to login with email

3
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

I wish they could change it too.

Fun fact, when a player gets phished the hijacker gets both their email and password. If they haven't changed their registered email, the hijacker will know what it is. If the email password is the same as the RS password, then the hijacker has access to the email... This means the hijacker can disable authenticator (which is why 2-step on email is important).

So from a security perspective, login names should not be emails.

6
killer4u77Give me the budder•

...is that a thing...?

None of my accounts need that...

2
Theta_ZeroRunefest 2014•

Any new account does. Legacy accounts before...What was it, 2010?....use usernames.

6
killer4u77Give me the budder•

oh god, email logins sound like a terrible idea

4
Theta_ZeroRunefest 2014•

They're not a big deal, except that one email account can have one runescape account tied to it. Which means making a new email (which you won't remember in 3 weeks) to make a new account. Also they're lengthy for mobile logins like the official Runescape app.

2
switchn•

Cringed pretty hard at "Legacy accounts".

-5
Theta_ZeroRunefest 2014•

Legacy just means something that's been replaced. Like in this case, accounts with account name logins instead of email logins.

Fun fact, Windows 7 becomes legacy software (end of Mainstreem support) on January 13th. "Obsolescence" is a much faster paced thing in software than in other fields.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Maxilicious_RSUnited we stand•

Thanks for making this, Eu.

3
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

No problem :)

The past few days I've seen so many of those phishing spammers... Couldn't just do nothing.

2
WillAteUrFaceIf you're reading this, get a beer. - Wacky Willie•

The only qualm about using Authenticator is that with the Android app it immediately begins downloading several other apps. In fact, it does it without the user really knowing. Unless you catch it in the act and force stop the several processes it will continue to download other apps.

Also, with every new phone I get, I have to redownload it and reset it. If my phone breaks or is stolen, the same thing occurs. (Which happens, but not super frequently) What does happen more frequently is that I sign in from several computers or several locations. I find myself entering the authenticator several times. The worst is when the authenticator prompt engages when I'm logging out of RS and reloading, or hopping to another computer.

A Summary. What I'd like to see changed is that Jagex has their own authentication app. One that doesn't require me to: have a google account to download the app; download various other apps; allows me to choose the frequency that the authenticator engages; allows me to set one or two specific IP address to never request authenticator from; the ability to activate my authenticator app on another phone using only my RS password & linked email as verification.

3
MekiahNaabe Master•

Google Authenticator doesn't force you to download anything else. What in the hell did you try to get?

2
artbot345•

You don't need Google Play to use an authenticator app.

https://f-droid.org/repository/browse/?fdfilter=Auth&fdid=org.fedorahosted.freeotp

2
WillAteUrFaceIf you're reading this, get a beer. - Wacky Willie•

Is that what you use? It still is downloaded through Google Play, and it seems like it's seldom updated. I'd hate to see Android come out with a new system update (which it does so frequently) that causes glitches on various phones.

1
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

I've never heard of this problem, about the app downloading other apps. This has never happened to me! Have you with Authy? It's an alternative app and it's pretty good.

1
xxteargodxx•

Don't care if anyone else uses it as long as I'm using it. If they are too stupid/stubborn/ignorant to use it then tough luck.

2
LogginWaffleDenkar•

I love using the Authenticator for my pin. A lot more convenient than that outdated interface.

2
UsedPotatoRsn: Runic Potato•

I... I don't have a phone...

2
DisheartendCracker full of Crackers•

don't need a phone.

2
Nick12506•

I don't have access to a phone. Why not have use a better authenticator that doesn't require a expensive third party device?

2
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

You can use WinAuth and install the authenticator on either your computer or a USB drive:

http://services.runescape.com/m=rswiki/en/Authenticator_codes_on_a_desktop_or_laptop

2
EpicBot•

90% of the 10$ Nokia's still being sold can run a authenticator on it.

2
TheLuxuriousHam•

People actually get hacked?! I thought it was just what people said to scam!!

Going to turn this on now...

2
UmdlyeTru•

Feel free to post this to r/2007scape as well :)

1
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

Thank you.

Worried about downvotes though, seeing as I've already had a couple here.

I guess the message is more important though.

7
The_original_guyKing Anon of Guthix•

Make a text post if you are worried about the negative karma... they don't affect your overall karma if you get downvoted to hell

8
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

Oooh, I didn't realise that. Thank you :)

4
insayan2595 | Robot Heart•

It says 20% of old school players, how about rs3? I've been using the authenticator since it came out, was already using it for my google account so it wasn't a big adjustment. Better safe than sorry.

1
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

Mat K released that statistic just over a week ago. So far Jagex haven't released any statistics on the RS3 community. Would love to know though.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
zuuzuuMs ZuZu•

I started using Authenticator as soon as it was released. Then one day it wouldn't accept my code. I had to disable it. About once a month I try to set it up again, but it never accepts the code, so I'm screwed. I made sure the clocks on both computer and phone matched, but still no go. I've given up.

1
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

What phone operating system are you using?

1
zuuzuuMs ZuZu•

Android 4.4.2, but it started happening on my old phone which was a much older version of Android, so the problem doesn't seem to be specific to the version. It worked fine for the first two or three months, and there had been no changes to either my computer or phone between the last known time it worked and the first time it didn't. Since then I've tried it with a new phone, and two new computers. No change.

I've noticed that even though the computer and phone both show the same time, the computers are 12 seconds faster than the phone (clocks on both phone and both computers are set by network) so I've tried waiting 12 seconds before using the most recent code. Still won't accept it. I'm at a loss.

1
AwesomicOPRSN: Eu•

Ok, so with the android app, it runs off an internal clock. It doesn't seem to have anything to do with the actual system clock. Navigate to this part of google support and see if that helps:

https://support.google.com/accounts/answer/185834?hl=en#sync

There's an alternative app called Authy, which I can recommend. Some players in the past have had issues with the google one which were resolved by switching to authy.

Let me know how you go, if you do try to set it up again. Happy to help with any further issues.

1
zuuzuuMs ZuZu•

I'll try that. Thanks for the tip.

Edit: It worked! Hot diggity!

2