Depafro•

How do you think the unthinkable?

With an itheberg.

I'll see myself out.

14
usedtobias•

I love that, despite what sub this is, this is still the top comment. Not even complaining.

2
Depafro•

I wouldn't be surprised if it gets deleted if this thread becomes more popular. No regrets.

1
n10w4•

And as far as thinking the unthinkable, do many people have a good answer outside of the normal? I too think in this continuation manner: where there seems to be a need for more international bodies that can help us face climate change issues and others.

Of course, with AI, there might, in the future, be room for computers to take over matters like bureaucracy and other matters. That, of course, assumes that AI will get to a point (well, it might be).

1
StWd•

At the end of the 80s, free market thinkers declared "the end of history" and the triumph of capitalism. They were wrong on both counts, says John Gray.

After reading this introduction I decided the rest of the article would be a waste of my time. Anyone still arguing about whether capitalism has won or not needs to go outside more often and read more.

This article just seems like opinionated (which I have no problem with) journalists trying to big up their small ideas as though we're approaching some new social Enlightenment era. The only big changes happening within our lifetime are space colonisation, technological singularity and possibly (hopefully not) the third world war.

0
NotSafeForEarthOP•

Your first problem is that you use a different definition of winning than the author. One definition of winning is being successful (which generally at least requires solving assigned problems and working as advertised). Another definition of winning is besting competitors.

Your second problem is that even whether capitalism has actually bested its historical competitor is open to interpretation and debate. Is economic warfare an essential feature of capitalism? And if not, what part of what capitalism did played any part in the rather unexpected collapse of the system on the Iron Curtain's other side?

Your third problem is that you've made up your mind and don't tolerate and ridicule anything failing to "think the unthinkable".

1
StWd•

Is economic warfare an essential feature of capitalism?

... It is the exact nature of capitalism...

Also, how can you argue your third point at all? Ad hominem much mr mind reader?

edit: Just so you don't waste your time anymore if you were planning on making a better argument, this is reddit not a real debate in which I'd actually like to spend more than a few minutes coming up with a proper argument- I have books to write, people to see, the world at my feet and a song in my heart- I ain't gonna waste too much time on this democratised pile of crap. Reddit is a constant reminder of why democracy is failing- it lets idiots start to believe that the whole "every opinion is valid" has any semblance of truth.

1
n10w4•

Wait, your stance is that democracy is bad, but capitalism is good? Just checking in here, though I think you mean otherwise (a republic argument, I assume?). Nevertheless, wouldn't something like reddit represent a 'market' of ideas? Or would you want more money instead of upvotes to truly make the good ideas rise (this seems like an interesting tangent that I would love to follow)?

As for the previous comment. I don't think many people are arguing that capitalism won (though the degree or the specific type could definitely be debated), rather that it wasn't a specific type that won (again, we should settle on definitions first, otherwise this gets pointless; for example, many communists/Trotskyists and so forth think that the USSR was not communism but State Capitalism), or not the type that people tend to think on.

I assume you have nothing for the end of history argument. If so, I would like to hear it. It does seem like a mistake many in the past have made: that their way was the only and final way. Better, I think, to keep looking for methods to improve oneself.

1
StWd•

I'm reading a lot of Zizek and ecology as culture which is why I tend towards the opinion that democracy is "bad"- by bad, I mean it doesn't really work.

As for capitalism winning, I meant that it is inevitable due to human nature (unless we reach some sort of stable global currency system a la RBE/TZM idealist utopian technocracy).

Don't lecture me on communism is state capitalism because that shit is probably taught in secondary education nowadays (I'm from the UK and, from what I've read so far, I think you'd use my age against me in ad hominem... nevertheless, I'm 22).

As for the end of history- it depends on what you mean by "history" of course. I think it's something post-modernists want to happen because it will sort of affirm their beliefs in the meaningless of "everything"- very nihilistic, depressing sentimentality IMO and makes it no wonder to me why Nietzsche lost the "plot". I think if we were to argue about the end of history today, we'd have to say which history. Hopefully we're getting towards the end of national conflict but, idiographically speaking, it seems, here in the UK at least, as local solidarity goes up, international insecurity and stigmatisation increases. The current 5 tier class system in the UK is missing the supercedent ruling classes that invented our 5 tier system that has defined this "Age of Facts" we live in yet, although we've made massive gains in the average standard of living, the same struggles between classes already exists. To me, to argue that history will ever end, is to argue it never existed in the first place. It's all a bit pseudo-Christian apocalyptic-rapturist. We have "pre-historic times" therefore we will have "post-historic times"

Sorry gotta cut it short and it's really poorly written and probably looks poorly conceived but I have no time to go back and edit for now but I hope there's enough for you to infer some meaning out of what I was trying to express :)

I like your personal philosophy :)

Mine is very similar in that I want to better myself constantly- I see life as the struggle similarly to Buddhists but in terms of positivity and applying Hegelianism, mixed with personally insightful thoughts I've had during a couple of psychedelic trips and a couple of sessions of transcendental meditation in which I was able to "break through", try to make yourself this (poorly written because i've never had to put it into words):

Each day we all wake up and there is no real way to differentiate whether each daily lifeworld isn't some bizarre dream. Assume not that it's your dream, but someone else's. Behave in a manner that makes the lives' of others seem "dream-like" and allow yourself to believe in things that cannot be proved empirically- such as karma- because belief is sometimes half the daily battle. What will I do today? Who should I be? Be someone who is so good that other people can't believe you're real.

Sorry if this again is all scrambly and not pleasant to read, I've been focusing on writing an essay answering "is the distinction between the private and public sociologically meaningful", also writing an Orwellian Sci-Fi novel and have somehow ended up having to read about controlled information destruction in computer security atm so my mind isn't clear for arguing properly on reddit but I would like to finally add (if you haven't gotten bored already) thanks for reading my comments, I have enjoyed reading yours and I hope you feel complimented when I tell you that they made me think!

1