There is no way this was premeditated.

After reading Susan's break down I am convinced the premeditation was an invention of the police. If Adnan did it, he snapped. Jay's earlier versions point to this pretty clearly. I am personally done speculating that it might have been premeditated and therefore Adnan did things like lend his car, buy a phone, ask for a ride for the purpose of murdering Hae.

Which leads me to, man, Jay really is a masterful liar. Not because he's good at telling coherent lies. He obviously isn't. But like SK says, his testimony is poetic. I wonder if he's tried his hand at creative fiction. He has a talent for it.

It doesn't mean Adnan is innocent. But it does cast Jay's statements in a different light.