Rockwool as a wick?

On the face of it, this is a very stupid question. I know it, you know it, but hear me out anyway. I was researching ekowool on Amazon and ran across a description that said Ekowool can be used to replacement materials such as Rockwool (among other things). I know Ekowool is silica and Rockwool is made from a type of rock (maybe).

All I really know about Rockwool is that it's used a lot in horticulture to germinate seeds and cuttings for plants (or "clones" for you pot heads out there). It's basically a sterilized growing medium that replaces dirt and peat and it's made from molton rock. Lava is basically spun like cotton candy at 1600*C and cut into cubes.

So my question, specially for you pot heads out there that also vape. Is there anyone here who has tried Rockwool as a wick? Heck, has anyone tried burning rockwool with a butate lighter to see if it burns or releases any weird odors.

*** DISCLAIMER *** I don't advocate anyone using this stuff for vaping. I'm simply asking questions and hoping to start a civil discussion. Until proven otherwise, assume one puff of this stuff will cause your d*ck to fall off, your first born will die, and your dog will get cancer. So don't do it.

Posted Dec 4, 2014, 2:37 AM UTC

714
danthevapingman•

amorphous silica is what we use for wick. its made in a similar way like a cotton candy machine on steroids. its a relatively simple compound consisting of silicon and oxygen and can you can find it with ease at a purity of 99.9%... it even occurs naturally in a few stones including opal.

the chemical composition of rockwool can vary greatly depending manufacturer and intended use. its designed for industrial applications for insulation mostly. its also a good growing medium. but its not designed to be a highly pure product, even if it didn't already pose inhalation hazards you would not want to vape it.

3
ShigfuApril 2011•

This line from the Wikipedia article makes it sound iffy to me: "Precautions need to be taken when handling a fiber product, as it can irritate the eyes, skin, and respiratory tract" http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mineral_wool

But from the description it sounds similar to the stuff they use in the Aspire BVC heads, so it may be okay but I would do tons more research before even trying it. I'll stick with cotton myself.

2
danthevapingman•

i Think the wick they use in the BVC heads is cellulose materials converted into nanostructured ceramics, based on what the report said from the "independent lab" Aspire hired to evaluate the safety of the new wick and heads.

3
MonkeeSage•

The only lab report I'm familiar with is this one, which only indicates the material as "Fiberglass paper". The Aspire support rep "Tina" called it ceramic in her forum post linking to that report. (The same Tina who apparently said the Nautilus chimney was SS and then later admitted it is chromed brass[1]. Her initial replies to elrin on the thread seem to have been deleted.) As far as I know ceramic is completely non-organic, and is made up of various metals (silicon, aluminum, etc). If you have other sources on the material, I'd like to hear them though! I'm pretty sketched out by it to be honest.

1
clinodevSigelei 100W+/Subtank Mini, iStick/Derringer•

You can make porous ceramics by mixing the ceramic material ("clay") with cellulose (paper fibers, etc.,) and then firing it. The paper burns out, leaving the ceramic material behind. I don't know if this is what they're doing, but it's how I interpreted the comment you're replying to. This is how some ceramic water filters are made.

2
MonkeeSage•

Nobody knows what they're doing! Converted nanostructured ceramics sound cool though.

1
danthevapingman•

yep Aspire has been been calling it "fiberglass paper" and or "ceramic fiber" since the beginning. ill cut them some sack because of the language barrier but i think i get the point. not sure what you mean by "non-organic", do you mean carbon free? because ceramics can most definitely contain carbon.

1
GobbleThisObeliskJuiceDB.com•

The same or worse can be said for silica.

inhaling finely divided crystalline silica dust can lead to silicosis, bronchitis, or cancer, as the dust becomes lodged in the lungs and continuously irritates them, reducing lung capacities.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Silicosis

Silicosis... is a form of occupational lung disease caused by inhalation of crystalline silica dust, and is marked by inflammation and scarring in the form of nodular lesions in the upper lobes of the lungs. It is a type of pneumoconiosis.

Silicosis... is characterized by shortness of breath, cough, fever, and cyanosis (bluish skin).

And just to avoid any angry rebuttals, I'm by no means saying silica rope isn't perfectly safe to use as wicking material. I'm just pointing out that many things aren't considered safe for inhalation... including cotton. Hell, even the MSDS for vegetable glycerin warns of irritation.

I say we just skip to the end and start wicking with asbestos.

1
danthevapingman•

yeah we use amorphous silica, chemically its like the exact opposite of crystalline silica. it does not pose the same risks as crystalline silica.

2
GobbleThisObeliskJuiceDB.com•

Good info, thanks for the education.

Animal inhalation studies with intentionally manufactured synthetic amorphous silica showed at least partially reversible inflammation, granuloma formation and emphysema, but no progressive fibrosis of the lungs. Epidemiological studies do not support the hypothesis that amorphous silicas have any relevant potential to induce fibrosis in workers with high occupational exposure to these substances...

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/11876495

I haven't used silica since my protank days, but it's definitely good to know.

2
bt112506•

Rockwool is insulation.

1
Stephen_Kizzipv3, darkhorse rda, olympian•

Oh god I had to fuck with that shit when I worked construction. Worse than any of the pink shit.

1
sfflyfishJuly 31, 2012•

When I was a kid many of my friend's houses in my neighborhood had rockwool insulation in the attic. Back then it was made out of ASBESTOS.

1