r/Jazz•
UncleMeat

Best mistakes on record

I'm always fascinated by how even the best musicians can still totally botch things just for a brief moment. Its not to infrequent to see it live and sometimes you get verification by looking at the reaction somebody in the band makes but I wonder how often these errors make it to record.

Does anybody know any real stinkers that made it onto well known records?

Posted Dec 7, 2014, 6:07 PM UTC

7863
CmdrChesticle•

Kurt Rosenwinkel's tune "Minor Blues" is in Ebm. The guitar solo is 2 choruses, and in the middle, Kurt accidentally hits a big honkin' open D string. He then promptly works it into the rest of the solo. As the take continues, the track unfolds into one of the most perfect story arcs I've ever heard on record. The way the saxophone solo picks up from the guitar and just soars...unbelievable.

29
UncleMeatOP•

This one is great. I've always loved this tune and never really thought of the D as a "save mistake" because he repeats it so soon after he plays it but that makes a ton of sense.

8
kid_on_summer_break•

it happens at 2:20 for those just looking for the mistake

8
UbiquitousCheeseM.M. Jazz Drums•

This is indeed a glorious "happy accident" and a fine example of risk taking in jazz yielding great rewards!

5
angryofmayfair•

Not exactly a brief moment, but Tommy Flanagan's solo on Coltrane's Giant Steps is pretty wayward and he's sort of forced to bail out by just playing the changes towards the end. In fairness the poor guy was probably confronted with the (at the time) revolutionary harmony on the same day as the recording, no time to woodshed...

28
jazzcigarettesbopbe•

He got the music prior to the session but was under the impression it would be a ballad.

40
savemejebus0•

Yup. Also heard McCoy wanted to be on the album and knew the song very well. Can't remember why they didn't use him. Age maybe?

7
Telenovelarocks•

I heard that Trane needed a ride to the session and Flanigan had a car.

3
savemejebus0•

That is perfect!

3
skunk_funk•

Nothing like subbing in a group and being thrown on the fire. "oh my god I have never played anything like this. I swear I don't suck."

19
ThreeHourRiverMan•

It's almost funny how jarring it is when Coltrane comes back in at full blast. You can tell everyone is just counting down for Tommy's solo to end (no doubt himself the most) then Trane comes in balls to the wall.

5
comeatmebreau•

I came here to say this. It's actually really exciting to hear what it sounds like when a musician of that caliber is in over his head.

12
Telenovelarocks•

Totally! Especially interesting because it's undoubtably the most famous recording flanigan played on, and truly one of the most classic jazz recordings of all time.

To be fair, there's later examples of him ripping Trane changes to make up for it!

10
AveyReynolds•

I have read that Flanagan was actually reading those chord changes for the first time during that recording.

5
NRMusicProject•

This has to be the most famous example. Because of that, the recording of your work that most people become familiar with is the one where you got lost. How much does that suck?

3
OceanicMeerkat•

At the end of the drum solo in Bird Calls (on Mingus Ah Um) John Handy comes in 2 measures early. I'm sure Mingus was pissed.

25
rebop•

honk

ಠ_ಠ

16
rusemaen•

I came here to post this. That botch gave me hope when I was younger. It's not just amateurs that get a little fucked up during drum solos. Well maybe it is, but at the least the pros can step down to my level on a bad day.

6
ThreeHourRiverMan•

Try being a jazz drummer. When I was younger and just learning to phrase solos properly I would get lost during my own solo, and come out of it in the wrong place constantly. Nothing can screw up a group more than the drummer losing his own place in a solo.

7
ComoBluff•

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cWGvsyeayFk&list=PLdhGk7gKuZxazMSoUjp1SDa9kbtS_ZTJ7&spfreload=10

(Not sure if cheating because this is a live recording.)

You'll hear it when the A section kicks off after the intro.

17
mwengerd•

What in the world?!

8
qmanoulton•

That's insane!

5
tjcooks•

Hahaha wow. I feel much less awful about any clumsy entrance I've ever participated in. . My guess is that folks couldn't hear each other, probably including a conductor, and maybe the tempo wasn't expected to be quite that fast. You'd have to be really tuned into that bass part to infer the tempo from it in that short a time before the first brass hits.

4
ComoBluff•

Yeah, it's reassuring to hear that mistakes happen to the best of them, so no biggie.

A friend of mine, who is a distinguished student of jazz, also speculated that perhaps the conductor didn't hear the bass well enough and hence the entrance was all over the place.

What makes this even more reassuring is that the conductor is Gil Evans of all people!

2
Staying_Anon•

As someone who isn't so knowledgeable about the theory, what am I listening for?

2
terrapin1203•

The album version of So What starts with the bass and the horns do the "do-dot" little lick. Here it was orchestrated for the brass, but whoever was conducting the group didn't pick up on the tempo the bassist started at, thus making the entrance way out of time.

3
bradgrammar•

It's not a theory thing really. Well sort of. The horns come in on the offbeat when they are supposed to be on the downbeat (I think that's what went wrong at least.)

That aside, it sounds really jarring compared to the original recording.

1
kungfu_jesus•

Sam, you would love this one.

1
NickyDeuce•

I dont know if its technically a mistake, but on the Dial sessions of Lover Man, Bird is so wasted one of his bandmates yells at him "Blow Man!". Its kind of hard to hear on the the youtube version, but its pretty well documented. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oNJpes0XFGU

14
imtrew•

It's not that song. It's here.

15
NickyDeuce•

You're correct, my mistake. I knew it was one of the two. In my defense, he did forget to come in on Lover Man...

2
zegogobass•

Yeah, Bebop is what you are talking about.

Lover Man is famous for Bird coming in late for the head and scrambling a little at the beginning. He also hated this solo and didn't want it released, but Dial did anyways. It is one of Bird's most iconic moments, and the solo has so much pain and tension that it's legendary. I can recall the first time I heard it, I was shocked by it's stark beauty.

1
verwondering•

Joe Morello, Dave Brubeck's drummer, loses one of his drum sticks during a solo.

http://youtu.be/6kc97rN4Af0

(I can't make nice links on my mobile, sorry.)

13
PlaidDragon•

He handled that pretty well - If you aren't watching, you can't really tell he messed up.

It was pretty funny how he kept grabbing the wrong sticks and he and the bassist were laughing about it mid-solo.

6
verwondering•

The look on his face when he grabs the wrong stick is quite funny yes.

He's one of the best drummers I know. On Unsquare Dance he only uses his sticks, no drums whats so ever. So I'm not that suprised that he sounds good when he loses a stick.

6
mrpotatoman14•

In Coltrane and Monk's recording of "Well You Needn't," Coltrane actually fell asleep during the piano solo.

13
frankafruAll My Favorite Sentimental Blues•

I heard he was just called over to solo not that he was asleep since the Monk song was off a mainly solo album. Got it from my jazz history teacher, so I'm going off his word.

2
gargle_ground_glasstenorman•

According to the Robin Kelley biography of Monk, it was trumpeter Ray Copeland who said that Coltrane had been nodding off but that really Monk was just calling out the solo order because it hadn't been worked out before. Either way, it's always a moment I've loved on that recording, the way Coltrane hits the ground running. I'd could listen to a whole album full of Coltrane entrances!

2
mrpotatoman14•

Interesting, I'll have to read that!

1
moethehobo•

So, I learned that I pretty much have no idea what's actually going on in jazz, but I still like it!

10
ohirony•

I know nothing about music theory. So, I'm reading top comments like a monkey.

2
3rdAnnual•

There are two examples I know of of great Sun Ra recordings that have a phone ringing in the background.

7
jazzbass92•

McCoy Tyner hits a single wrong note on My Favorite Things around 5:03 that I've always noticed. Still an amazing tune and solo...

7
gargle_ground_glasstenorman•

On Andrew Hill's tune "Refuge" (Point of Departure, 1964) Eric Dolphy breaks into Richard Davis's bass solo too early with the first notes of the little kick chorus that introduces Joe Henderson's solo later.

5
g-rob2Drums•

Two come to mind that are pretty amusing:

  1. Frank Sinatra accidentally lets his New Jersey accent slip on the word "hurt", then seems to sort of panic and say the word again without the accent. The rest of the track is great so I guess they just decided to keep the take.

  2. Louis Hayes, who was only in his early 20's at the time of this recording with Cannonball Adderley, totally beefs the entrance to the last head of this tune. I can laugh at it because I've done the exact same thing so many times before... The mistake is at the end of the vamp - it's hard to miss.

5
tiphphin•

Fairport Convention (not jazz, I'll grant you) were using a row of milk bottles as percussion on a song on their Unhalfbricking album. At some point during the recording, the bottles all fell down with a crash. The band were going to stop, but the engineer kept them going, and the crash ended up on the record.

Edit: here is the song. The crash is at 1:57.

4
rebop•

Not what you meant but these outtakes are great!

4
imtrew•

Miles Davis on Prince of Darkness starts the melody chorus on the wrong place. It's supposed to be a pickup line starting on beat 3, but he starts at the beginning of the bar, which can easily screw everything up for the rest of the band, but they pick it up and fixes it like it was nothing.

4
lindymad•

Neither of these are quite what you asked for, but I think they will both be enjoyed :)

  1. Cab Calloway performing with the muppets! - at 1:55 he can't find the notes and you can see the look of terror in his face, but the show must go on!
  2. Ella Fitzgerald singing Mack the Knife - at 1:46, she forgets the words and does some meta improvisation
4
gustywindsmayexist•

I've never been sure if this was accidental or not but in Freedom Jazz Dance on Miles Smiles it sounds to me like Miles came in with the melody too early or Wayne Shorter didn't come in. Or it could've been planned that way, but this always felt accidental to me.

3
CmdrChesticle•

Supposedly Herbie was kind of "picked on" by other members of the group. Tony was younger, but was really "in" with Miles. Herbie, at this point, was the bookish soft-spoken young guy. Essentially, Miles used to cut off his solos to fuck with him -- basically give him blueballs instead of letting him get his "nut".

7
gustywindsmayexist•

Interesting. I should have been more specific, I was talking at the very beginning when Miles plays about 5 notes of the head by himself two bars before they all start playing. But you're right the entrance after the solos is also kind of staggered, which I hadn't noticed before.

1
english_major•

On Charlie Haden's The Montreal Tapes with Paul Bley and Paul Motian, someone's watch starts beeping right into the mic. I guess that there was no way to delete if from the recording. Otherwise, it is a great concert recording.

3
veecter•

Not exactly a mistake, but Miles Davis has multiple instances of forgetting to empty his spit out of his trumpet during solos. The best example is during his solo on "All Blues" on the Kind of Blue record.

3
rusemaen•

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0_WN90dWcBM

It's not technically a mistake, but the tenor solo of this live version of Boogie Stop Shuffle starts off off-kilter and sounds like it's going to go pretty badly as he meanders his way through a few choruses.

Somehow, though, he manages to pull it together and by the end of the solo I was cheering for him like I would an underdog sports team or something. It's the real essence of improv, the way he managed to tie it all together.

3
UncleMeatOP•

Just a heads up, this isn't Mingus. This is the Mingus Big Band. Amazing stuff but people often misattribute their music like the uploader did in this case.

4