Am I missing something about external HDDs? They're often much cheaper than internal ones.

For example:

Cheapest 4TB Seagate internal HDD

Vs.

Cheapest 4TB Seagate external HDD

Is there a quality issue I don't know about with the external ones?

Posted Dec 9, 2014, 4:35 PM UTC

716
from_the_sidelines•

Usually it's a matter of warranty - cracking the case voids the warranty of the drive. There also a grab bag aspect to it, there's no guarantee what drive you'll actually get inside the enclosure. I've personally harvested a few Seagate Backup HDs for my Drobo and not has an issue.

5
Decaf_EngineerOP•

Okay, thanks for the info!

1
sbddude•

This. I use Seagate external HDDs removed from their cases in my Synology NAS. It was much cheaper than WD Red drives and so far I've had no problems. I've gone through three batches of drives so far (2, 3 and 4 TB).

1
davdev•

Is there a quality issue I don't know about with the external ones?

It may just be my luck, but I have found failure rates far higher on external drives than internals. I have been running HTPC's for over a decade and gone through dozens of drives and I would say the my externals fail at a rate approaching 5-1 over my internals. In fact, I have gotten to the point where I wont even buy external drives anymore, unless for some reason I really need something that is portable.

2
Decaf_EngineerOP•

That's a little scary. I want to extract the HDDs and run them in raid 5, so maybe that'll buy me the protection I need.

2
majesticjg•

I believe it would. They aren't junk drives, they just may not be the very best.

1
davdev•

I wouldnt do that. At the very least you would void the warranties. Worse case, I think some drives are designed such that they will only work in the external enclosure.

1
veruus•

To what degree would you attribute the failures to being moved around?

1
davdev•

None. I very rarely moved the drives, and I don't recall any failures occuring after a recent move.

1
durkadurka9001•

WD externals have a hardware encryptor on some drives rendering them useless if you remove it from the enclosure.

2
THECOACH0742•

This is a little misleading. It wont render them useless.

If you have data on the drive when you remove it, that data can not be recovered without the enclosure.

However, once the drive is formatted outside of the enclosure, you can use it anywhere.

9
Decaf_EngineerOP•

That's not an enabled security feature? Just flat out won't work if used as an internal HDD?

1
durkadurka9001•

its on the PCB which connects the sata/power and converts it to a USB connector.

2
majesticjg•

In addition to what other people have said, they can often use last-year's internal drives or a previous model of internal drive in their external, since the externals are not expected to be the latest, greatest and fastest.

1
SirMaster•

It's really a matter of supply and demand.

Higher demand for externals so lower margins on them to sell even more.

0
General_Hide•

That's the exact opposite of real economics. Supply and demand both drive price and usually when the demand is high, the price is higher too (though supply had a say in it as well)

2