[B4E10] Thoughts on the most recent Spirit World visit
Apologies in advance if this is incoherent, I had a lot of thoughts about this scene.
I know everyone is pretty nonplussed that the cool bird-eel spirit rejected Korra's request for aid in her fight against Kuvira. However, I think it makes perfect sense. Spirits seem timeless (as evidenced by the return of our friend carrot spirit), as in they literally exist outside of time. For them, this war is not the end or the beginning of anything, it's simply one force in the eternal quest for balance. Remember that, in the The Swamp from ATLA, Huu says that time is an illusion. Spirits are not beholden to this illusion (which is how Aang could see Toph before he meets her).
The reason they are leaving Republic City (and, presumably, the swamp) is because that's the only true way to preserve balance in that eternal, not temporal, quest for balance. Yes, Kuvira already has harnessed some spirit energy, but now that the spirits are abandoning the physical world there is no more for her to harness. If Kuvira attempts to go into the spirit world to harness spirit energy, then the spirits will be able to prevent that through the normal spirit-world hostility toward meddlesome humans.
In the short term, their abandonment means that Republic City will likely be destroyed and perhaps people will die, but Korra can stop that. Her power is limitless (c.f. Zaheer Laghimason). And it is the Avatar's job to maintain balance, not regular spirits'. So, if the spirits stayed, they would be exposing the world to Kuvira having an unlimited supply of spirit vine energy. Remember, they did try to fight back in the swamp before the city spirits started fleeing; it didn't work.
In the long term, the only time scale that matters to spirits, even if Republic City is completely destroyed, the spirits fleeing is better for the balance of the world because Kuvira will never be able to use her tank again once the initial harvest runs out. So they made the right decision for balance by leaving, even if it means the humans are in tremendous danger.
That means that only the Avatar, the master of all four elements, can stop this. And this time, when the world needs her most, she's right there prepared to face it. Truly a fitting ending to the series.
Posted Dec 9, 2014, 10:12 PM UTC
The issue is that the spirits are timeless, and that has caused them to lose perspective. They see this as just another human war - but if Kuvira wins, then the world will be changed forever, and not just for humanity. The spirits will be out of the human world by force; and with the portals open, there is every chance that an expansionist society like the Earth Empire will seek to claim all that unclaimed territory.
But Tenzin has taught Korra that change can be good or bad, depending on your point of view. That's a belief I'm sure the spirits hold as well, so the potential for a changed world is not necessarily a problem. Again, if Kuvira takes the fight to the spirit world then something will have to change. But I don't think she would be victorious in the spirit world.
Your point is that the spirits have "lost" perspective, but I say they have a perfectly well-defined perspective, it's just one you don't share.
Except the spirits have spent the past ten thousand years locked in the Spirit World, and thousands of years before that having control of the material world, and prior to that, were locked in the spirit world even more securely.
This is the first time they have ever had anything close to resembling true balance between spirits and humanity, and if Kuvira wins it can never happen again.
I think there's a philosophical difference here. You're thinking of balance as the end state, a static equilibrium that can be arrived at. Thus, you suggest achieving balance by destroying a threat. But the point of view of nearly every spiritual being (human or otherwise) perceives balance differently. It's a constant process, a dynamic equilibrium that is maintained through the smallest possible level of intervention. In this perspective, large disruptive actions like a human attack are not best countered by an equally powerful (or overpowered) human defense.
I'm not saying I agree with this or anything - as a human with temporal concerns I certainly couldn't imagine taking such a detached perspective - but that's just my earthly tether holding me down. Seriously, Guru Laghima's poem and Zaheer's interpretation is a pretty apt description of the spirits' perspective: Korra's instinct is to defend with force because, ultimately, she's afraid for the ones who will perish in Kuvira's attack. It's no wonder Zaheer was able to commune with spirits so much before he got out of prison: he thinks a lot like them.
Oh, I agree. I definitely understand that this is the Spirit's perspective, I simply think that they are failing to see the big picture. And I'm not advocating for the Spirits wiping out Kuvira, simply defending their shared society alongside humankind. Your point about the smallest possible level of intervention is a good one, but the issue is that at the moment the spirits aren't going to be making any form of intervention at all. Considering how hostile Hei Bei was when his forest was destroyed, I'd hope more Spirits would be willing to defend their home in the Material World.
Taking a detached perspective is not the only path to wisdom, as Iroh proved when speaking with Aang in the tunnels under Ba Sing Se. In this case, I feel the spirits detached view is contributing to Kuvira's cause, and making the 'dynamic equilibrium' impossible to maintain. Sometimes, to maintain Balance, we need our earthly tether.
I think you may be having trouble with the idea that they're in a place where time doesn't exist. Literally. Time is a concept humans developed so its possible there literally is no time in the spirit world (for example, Iroh never died, he just went to the spirit world)
In-show evidence suggests otherwise. Whenever someone is in the Spirit World, an equal amount of time passes in the real world as well.
Iroh didn't physically go to the Spirit World and become immortal he meditated into the Spirit World, same as every other time people have gone in without the portals. The difference is, his physical body died while he was in there.
(EDIT: Plus, Vaatu frequently boasts about how long he has existed)