Please make a dua for the 13 people taken hostage in Martin Place cafe

There has been 2 unconfirmed terrorists who have taken 13 people hostage with at least one person armed.

This make me extremely sad for the Islamic community as these people are not showing an Islamic act but an act of terror.

I will be making a dua for the hostages as well as the Islamic community. Please make a dua that this event passes soon and safely.

I will link an article when I get on my laptop as I'm writing this on my phone.

Edit: Here's an article

Posted Dec 15, 2014, 12:37 AM UTC · edited

5563
zeeginganinja•

So awful. I'm so sick of this crap. These idiots need to STOP hijacking OUR religion. Honestly, every time I see something like this on the news, I have to say, "please don't be Muslim please don't be Muslim." It sucks.

I hope that this ends well, but I suspect it wont. Everyone needs to make dua and those of us on this sub need to prepare for backlash and remember to respond to any hatred with love and compassion. Prove that we are NOT like the idiots who do this stuff.

37
FunkyHairBalls•

It's sad how these alleged muslims are the ones making the world unsafe for fellow muslims.

8
UndecidedUserOP•

Yes, I couldn't agree more.

I didn't hear about it until my non-Muslim friend texted me to turn on the news. I was disgusted and devastated at what I was hearing. The first thing I thought was the unfortunate hostages and how the Islamic community was going receive some severe backlash.

It makes me sick seeing people who abuse a peaceful religion by portraying it in a way to benefit their own ideology.

6
EJonsson•

I am from Sydney and live near where this is going down. Let's be honest guys. I'm not much of a fan of any religion, but why do you say things like "peaceful religion" and "benefit their own ideology" when the Quran clearly asks Muslims to kill non-believers and other things of the sort (9:73 etc) ?

I'm not trying to start a flame war or anything of the sort, but I really find it hard to understand. Naturally I understand why personally, any Muslim is against any form of violence. I have many, many Muslim friends, devout and less so, but still, the holy book commands murder in certain circumstances...

Doesn't it make more sense to come out and say that that kind of thing is wrong instead of just sitting back and saying "peaceful religion"? I understand saying that something in the Quran is wrong is considered blasphemy, but where should the line be drawn?

-1
Logical1ty•

Why not read those verses in the context of the verses before and after?

2:190:

Fight in the way of Allah against those who fight against you, but begin not hostilities. Lo! Allah loveth not aggressors.

Even 2:193 says:

And fight them until persecution is no more, and religion is for Allah. But if they desist, then let there be no hostility except against wrong-doers.

Every verse of war is qualified by verses enjoining not transgressing limits, not beginning hostilities, and suing for peace wherever possible.

If you don't understand it's because you're not reading what you're talking about. Cutting out bits and pieces of a few verses and ignoring the rest of the entire book is the modus operandi of terrorists. Are you a terrorist? Because your logic is mirroring theirs whenever you do that.

Even Tony Abbott has so far called this "politically motivated violence", not religiously motivated. And that guy's generally an idiot about such things.

14
MillatIbrahim•

not beginning hostilities

Are you sure? So every Mujahid in the past who participated in offensive jihad is not actually a mujahid but a murderer?

1
theonlywayoutis•

That portion of the Quran is not understood that way. It served as rules of engagement for a community at war during the time of the prophet (saw). Terrorists don't use those verses as much but rather paint themselves as victims and their acts justified because of supposed Western crimes (see Robert Pape's analysis of suicide bombings for more.)

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
justskatedude•

So if the West stops interfering with Arab conflicts we will stop seeing attacks on us? What about the people who live in those areas? From what I can gather you are proposing we just stand back and let those countries sort matters out themselves? Interesting.

0
zeeginganinja•

You only find it hard to understand because you haven't taken the effort to understand the religion and the context/interpretation of those verses.

5
Braindeathx•

hen the Quran clearly asks Muslims to kill non-believers

except it doesn't

4
Drudeboy•

I understand saying that something in the Quran is wrong is considered blasphemy, but where should the line be drawn?

I hope we can let you know when we figure that out.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ThedamnSON•

Why is it always Islamic... :(

12
Drudeboy•

Because of political instability and our (Muslims) leaders' willingness to promote politically convenient victimization narratives and a confrontational attitude towards other cultures and faiths.

7
tallcircuit•

I think it's because the muslim world doesnt have much of leadership. With the western world, the US/UK serves that role. It scary to realize that the insurgent leaders are the closest thing to an influential personality in the muslim world. We have scholars but not anyone with the ability to bring change. Muslims leaders are joke. The vacuum is being filled with all the wrong kinds of people. May Allah help us all. We need a true imam.

8
Drudeboy•

I think it's the Middle East and parts of Central Asia that need leadership. Southeast and South Asian Muslims have their problems, but I think their extremist problems come from the Saudi government poking its collective ass into other peoples' affairs.

3
ThedamnSON•

... or, maybe because THEY ARE Islamic? Geez, calm down.

-1
Drudeboy•

By "our leaders" I mean "our Muslim leaders."

I believe our Muslim leaders aren't doing enough to confront extremism and stop fanning the flames.

1
ThedamnSON•

Ahh, my bad, sorry I interpreted your original comment wrong :/

2
justskatedude•

What else could be done? I came to a conclusion that the Muslim community doesn't do enough to fan extremism but also I found that the West can be intolerable of groups that do not integrate well. And historically Muslims do not integrate well into western culture. Even today, look at what's happening in Denmark.

2
MillatIbrahim•

Or because they are dropping rather big bombs on us everyday and it is inevitable that some of a community of 1.5 billion will react this way.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
adorkable95•

Let me guess, Daesh fan boys who think they're "souljahs of Islam" or something ughh. We don't need this crap in Australia or anywhere in the world.

7
[deleted]•

Nah looks like an older dude. I'm guessing he's just a bit of a nutcase.

1
Raven_25•

Id like to impart some advice for those of you who will listen. I am not Muslim but rather, an Australian Jew. I know what it means to be marginalised because of who I am and be discriminated against for things i've never done. Unfortunately for the Muslim community, as has been mentioned, a group of mentally unstable a**holes have hijacked your religion.

I would like to suggest a practical solution to your problem given that, as many of ou have noted, the global Islamic community lacks strong leadership:

Become involved in the broader Australian community - join the military, the police, volunteer in a soup kitchen, help the homeless people, make a big public protest against ISIS' actions etc.

Once people see that you are defending and helping THEM, they will no doubt be suspicious at first, some will let you help them, others won't. But eventually, people will see that the muslim community is not a separate thing from the Australian community, people will see the difference between muslims and extremist nutjobs. The distinction they will make is not which interpretation of the Qur'an a person believes in, rather, the difference will be that one group of muslims is there to help and support and grow the Australian community and the other seeks to destroy it.

I have heard other solutions, but I have not seen any really work.

You can claim that you are entitled as Australian citizens to the same respect as everyone else - and you may be right, but unfortunately, that doesn't stop people being suspicious of you. To them, you are either a terrorist or a potential terrorist. And even if you're not, you don't belong here, citizen or not. If they see you fighting against the terrorists, that belief is much harder to hold.

You can claim that the muslim community is already doing alot - various Imams are issuing rulings, some muslims do speak out and some muslim community leaders do condemn this extremism publicly. All this is true - my point is not that you are not doing anything, it is that if you want to be treated as equals and without suspicion in Australian society, you need to do more.

Is it fair? Absolutely not. Is it right? No. But is IS a solution to your problem. Making a dua is a nice gesture and perhaps your prayers will be answered, but the average Australian will never notice it.

I leave you with this article: http://www.sbs.com.au/news/article/2014/08/18/meet-young-muslims-getting-ready-fight-australia

Nobody can say that women who are prepared to fight and die for Australia do not belong here. But at the same time, nobody can say that 98 people represent an entire community. The more Muslims that do the kind of thing that these women are doing, the closer you are to earning your place in Australia.

5
MillatIbrahim•

Oh God that article. I wish you hadn't linked that.

2
Raven_25•

Why not?

1
MillatIbrahim•

It's prohibited to join the armies of the disbelievers. We have our own army, they are the Mujahideen.

2
Raven_25•

Its not necessarily the army, I gave other examples of things you could do. I respect that peoples religious beliefs may prevent them from serving, but that doesnt excuse not participating in Australian society in other ways.

1
aafa•

It's sick that they have sympathizers outside of that Syrian/Iraqi war zone. Sickening.

edit: he was a crazy refugee who was known the the police...mainly for being involved in his wife's death.

4
Logical1ty•

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jihobbyist

So far all the ones in the news have had either mental and/or drug problems. We'll see what's the motivation for this guy after this is over.

1
autowikibot•

#####

######

#### Jihobbyist:


A “jihobbyist” is a term coined by Jarret Brachman to characterise a person who is not an active member of a violent jihadist organization such as Al-Qaeda or the Somali [Al Shabaab](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Al-Shabaab_(militant_group\)), but who has a fascination with and enthusiasm for jihad and radical Islam.


^Interesting: ^Jarret ^Brachman ^| ^Revolution ^Muslim ^| ^Zachary ^Adam ^Chesser ^| ^Humam ^Khalil ^Abu-Mulal ^al-Balawi

^Parent ^commenter ^can [^toggle ^NSFW](/message/compose?to=autowikibot&subject=AutoWikibot NSFW toggle&message=%2Btoggle-nsfw+cmv41h5) ^or [^delete](/message/compose?to=autowikibot&subject=AutoWikibot Deletion&message=%2Bdelete+cmv41h5)^. ^Will ^also ^delete ^on ^comment ^score ^of ^-1 ^or ^less. ^| ^(FAQs) ^| ^Mods ^| ^Magic ^Words

1
Zaidfa83•

I would gladly take any of there spots if I lived there. How can someone completely translate the quran into the opposite of the meaning or what the prophet Mohammed ( pbuh ) taught us. Inshallah they all will be reunited with there families.

2

And also for any women/children/mosques/bookstores that may come under fire in the inevitable backlash. May Allah make it easy for the Muslims.

1
Drudeboy•

May Allah make it easy for the Muslims.

I'd prefer God make it easy for everybody.

11
arabista3•

I bet none of them will be held at gunpoint and paraded near windows.

4

You can make dua for two...even three things!

Sometimes four things! Wow!

6
arabista3•

darling, my point is not about prayer, but about the victim card that you're pre-emptively playing here.

3
reeblebeeble•

Ordinary muslims in Australia are already victims of political scapegoating and careless fear incitement. This will make it worse. There is nothing pre-emptive about it - communities need to mentally prepare themselves.

5
h4qq•

pre-emptively

Because there is absolutely no reason to do that...

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-3
muhamispedo•

thank you for this. An important reminder that we can do just as much good as they can do bad.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Kharos•

I don't understand your mindset with this dua. Let me just run a few scenarios by you:

Scenario 1: All of the hostage are kaffirs. All of them survived this hostage situation and live on and die years or decades from now. Since they are in Australia, chances are they will remain kaffirs until the times of their deaths. According to Islam, wouldn't they be in the eternal fire of hell exactly like how they would have been had they died as hostages? In the cosmological scheme of things, do those extra years or decades of life before the eternal torture of hell make a difference? If anything, their deaths prevented them from making more kaffir babies. I doubt that Muslims in Australia have a shortage of kaffir to be converted to Islam anyway. Apart from the fact you would have slightly fewer kaffirs to be converted to Islam, no value is lost one way or another. So, then what are you praying for?

Scenario 2: Some, a few, or even one of the hostages are/is Muslim(s). Nothing really changed from scenario 1 for the kaffirs in this scenario. If s/he had been a good Muslim, and s/he died as a hostage s/he would be in heaven. If s/he had not been a good Muslim, and s/he died as a hostage s/he might still be in heaven if s/he asked for Allah's forgiveness and grace before his/her death; nothing really different from a Muslim who died for any other innocuous reason. If they all survived, then they live on and they will be judged when they die in the future. Apart from the fact you would have slightly fewer Muslims to be spreading Islam, no value is lost one way or another. So, what are you praying for?

1
paracompact•

Sorry, but your dua aren't really doing anything for the people trapped inside that building.

-1
h4qq•

That is your baseless opinion.

1
paracompact•

I can't provide tangible evidence that your dua makes no difference in the outcome of this situation, but it just seems sort of egotistical to assume that your prayer/plea to a higher power might sway the end result. In my view it's disrespectful to the hostages and to the team that is negotiating and actually working directly with those involved.

Of course I also acknowledge that people giving duas / prayers in this situation are probably doing so out of some kind of goodwill, so my apologies if you were offended by my statement.

1
h4qq•

so my apologies if you were offended by my statement.

Appreciate it, as long as we are respectful, that's all that matters.

but it just seems sort of egotistical to assume that your prayer/plea to a higher power might sway the end result.

I've honestly never heard an argument that a prayer for someone else can be egotistical...logically it just doesn't make sense to me lol And nowhere is it said that only our prayer is accepted - could you cite that please?

In my view it's disrespectful to the hostages and to the team that is negotiating and actually working directly with those involved.

Well, this is a theological difference we have then. I believe that the team that is negotiating and all of the emergency responders there (I am a Firefighter/EMT, so I can speak on this) are doing so with all of the abilities that they have been blessed with, the ones that they practiced at and developed over time. Although the person who posted this made a prayer specifically for the hostages, it is more than appropriate to make a prayer for the one's working the scene as well, for God to grant them ease and the strength to do their job.

If you disagree with that, then that's just a fundamental difference we have in understanding our Creator, nothing more really.

2
paracompact•

Egotistical in the sense that someone making a dua might believe that they are somehow helping to make a difference, when in reality it's those professionals who are directly involved in helping to stabilize the situation.

And yeah, the fundamental difference is that I don't believe in the existence of a creator or higher power (although I did at one time). In my view these people were born and (along with a combination of the characteristics they had as per their genetic makeup) went through a series of situations (nurture from parents, friends and teachers; being in the right place at the right time) that allowed them to become experts in diffusing hostage situations and so forth. You don't have to insert a higher power / creator for it to make sense.

0
Jemzzz•

You can't make dua for non-believers

-3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-8
MegatronRx•

I know you feel bitter because the Ayatollah kicked you out of your home. But there's no need for that.

Go put your gold chain on your copious amounts of cologne and be a douche bag somewhere else.

4