[GoT] Why didn't Sam Tarly's dad force him to become a Maester instead of taking the black?

I know that Lord Randyll Tarly hated that Sam wasn't 'manly,' and he probably liked the Knight's Watch, but Randyll had to know that he would have to survive basic combat to make it in the watch, and that Sam was unlikely to be able to.

Maester's also renounce their inheritance, and Sam loved books, why wasn't this the option that he chose?

In fact, he sort of gives Sam a choice, and Sam has to volunteer, why didn't Sam come up with this option on his own? Sam would have to know about the Maesters, their vows, and he had a few days to think of a solution.

BTW I've loved this subreddit for a while and I think it's the only place to post an 'in-universe' Game of Thrones question. LMK if you think not and I'll re-post it somewhere appropriate.

Posted Dec 16, 2014, 9:48 PM UTC

1020
Loading comments…