Why do people on this subreddit get so defensive when people dare "judge" control decks?

Hey, the question stems from the fact every time I see someone judging control decks "in a bad way", like saying they are no more skilled than zoo for example, they get downvoted into oblivion whilst people shitting on zoo or hunter get upvoted and circlejerked around instead.

Why is this? What makes a deck like [this] (https://i.imgur.com/0vd4kYE.jpg) with 7 legendaries more skillful than a rush/aggro/board control deck?

Do people not understand that F2P players do not enjoy playing zoo decks? Do they not understand it is only cancer because of the current F2P system in place? The great majority of people are forced to play zoo/hunter because they're cheap! And even in those cases they require some cash to be thrown in, for example Naxxramas is essential for Hunter face/deathrattle deck.

I was very saddened to see these two guys get downvoted to oblivion in this this merely for stating their opinions on the matter, I want once and for all understand why do people here think Control Warrior (in particular) is less cancerous, more healthy and skilled than a zoo deck. Thanks.

Posted Dec 18, 2014, 10:44 PM UTC

09
flyingjam•

Control decks require more skill because their games last longer and they have more situational cards in hand. With Zoo or other midrange decks, you're playing on curve for most of the game. Watch Kolento vs Strifecro to see just how ridiculous Control vs Control matches can get; the casters, including 2 pro's, were completely befuddled on what the best play was throughout the game. That doesn't happen with Zoo.

2
PsYcHoSeAn•

The great majority of people are forced to play zoo/hunter because they're cheap!

That's bullshit. Look at Trump. He made f2p decks with almost every class and he hit Legend with multiple of them.

They're (Hunter+Zoo that is) popular cause they take absolutely no skill. Throw your entire hand on the board and attack face. That's all there is. And that's why people hate them.

On the other hand people hate Control Warrior cause it's really a good allrounddeck that's insanely good in making games last forever. When you just want a quick game you better concede against Warrior cause that's not going to happen.

And those guys got downvoted cause of the way they stated their opinion. They come across like douchebags. Not because of the content of their posts.

2
TrannyToothOP•

That's bullshit. Look at Trump. He made f2p decks with almost every class and he hit Legend with multiple of them.

They're popular cause they take absolutely no skill. Throw your entire hand on the board and attack face. That's all there is. That's why people hate them.

They might not take skill but the only reason I personally play zoo or hunter is because I CANNOT AFFORD to spend twenty minutes playing my Control paladin deck when I'm grinding quests/gold to get the cards I need.

I think they are played because they are fast, and people who cannot afford to pay for packs need to win fast to get the gold needed for Arena/packs.

Let's not forget that despite what people might say about Arena being the best way to grind for gold, new players and F2P players might not be experts on it so they won't get more than 3 wins. To get good in Arena you need to play Arena, and at the current rate you can play once every three days from quests.

Also, let's just go ahead and be honest here. Trump made those f2p decks before Naxxramas came out, nowadays F2P decks stand no chance against your various Sludge Belchers, Loathebs and [insert widely used GVG card here]. They just won't cut it.

0
Omenofdeath•

I'd answer but this will go down to a point of opinion:

" Control has more skill required because they have to plan ahead and work out what cards they should keep and what to expect, while most rush can work with whats in their hand."

1
OllieShadbolt•

I'm a F2P player, and run a Paladin deck hovering at Rank 5. I personally hate the excuse of people saying they can't make a good deck due to lack of Dust, so just play Zoo. I've never played any kind of Aggro simply because myself and others find it easy. You play down minions, attack face, occasionally trade, and that's that. For a strategy card game, that's extremely boring for both parties. However, Control is all about tactics and actually thinking about what you need to do next. Is it best to use AOE now, or wait another turn? Heal or Taunt? Is this the correct target for this spell, or should I wait?

A huge range of decks can be made with a small amount of dust after playing the game for a while at higher ranks, so high tier decks can easily be created that don't have to be Aggro, hence why I hate that reasoning of no control decks are cheap.

1
Se7enDwarves•

I think there's a certain respect that comes from people towards a warrior control deck, as you do have to earn or buy your way into such an expensive deck. I do not subscribe to this myself as I too see it as cancerous.

0
TrannyToothOP•

I think this is another one of the reasons. A lot of people on this subreddit are "hardcore" Hearthstone players who have spent money or a lot of time to complete their control decks so seeing folks and their zoo decks being successful is annoying to them.

4
[deleted]•

Miracle, mill rogue, math warrior - those are the only three "hard" decks in all of Hearthstone. If you think responding to threats with executes/shield slams/weapons then playing big minions, or tapping til you can drop giants is hard then you're retarded and probably wind up at rank 5 every season because you can't rank up without streaking.

0
TrannyToothOP•

This is what baffles me. I understand in a Control vs. Control matchup how it could come down to skill but against zoo? Drop a taunt turn 4, drop a taunt turn 5, whirlwind, shield slam, absorb absorb absorb.

Get down to 1hp, Alextrasza (tons of skill right there, gr8 card), back to 15hp, zoo can no longer deal with your high health legendaries. Boom, game over, beaten with skill, totally not due to the fact legendaries were indeed legendaries.

-1