r/runescape•
Enofel

Over a thousand songs, but 12 spots on the playlist?

We now have well over 1000 songs, some I like listening to, some indistinguishable from another, but I would love to be able to choose my favorites to listen to over the course of the hours of playing RS, however with only 12 spots, the songs repeat wayyy to fast.

I would love if the list size were increased to 100 or at the very least 50 slots to add songs to.

Posted Dec 19, 2014, 4:32 PM UTC

7415
Primal_Demon•

...Can they please fix all the music player glitches too?

14
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Phone8675309•

I agree. I'm not sure how hard it would be to implement an infinite list. They could even store it locally if they were worried about memory usage (though I dunno why they would be)

9
Two1012595•

It could theoretically be implemented with just one bit per song with that bit corresponding to whether that song is in your playlist or not. At the moment, this would be about 21 bank spaces worth of data per person (Jagex previously stated that each bank space is 4 bytes; 2 for item ID and 4 for quantity).

However, I really do agree with storing non-sensitive information locally such as action bars.

EDIT: I wrote this post with the assumption that everyone would listen to their playlist on shuffle (like I do) so the order wouldn't matter. Storing an array of song IDs would make your playlist at least 2 bytes per song contained in it. which is potentially a lot more than my initial estimate.

3
Mrerf•

I also wish they added a "I hate this song" button so a particular song doesn't play anymore

5
zenylHere to help :)•

Jagex are in general not too happy about expanding things like this, since it requires a ton of space on their servers to store all the lists, but I certainly agree it should be longer, possibly also split into several lists.

1
Fauxbliss•

Inb4 you can buy playlist expansions for 2 weeks for 200 runecoins.

6
F3AR3DLEGENDGrandmaster•

It doesn't take up a significant amount of space. Let's assume there are 10 million players who want to use the feature. With a limit of 50 songs per playlist, at 2 bytes per song (as the ID), each player requires an additional 101 bytes (50 songs * 2 bytes per song + 1 null ending byte). 10 million * 101 = 1,010 million bytes which is approximately 1 GB of space. That's very small for modern hard drives (even solid state drives, too).

If they're using a NoSQL, document-centric database (such as MongoDB), this requires even less space because if a user does not fill up all 50 slots, the database "field" does not have to take up 101 bytes.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
zenylHere to help :)•

I fully understand that storing a few numbers per-player doesn't add up to a lot, but Jagex think different; they weren't all in for adding max/comp presets, as it would take up space.

1
F3AR3DLEGENDGrandmaster•

You don't know that the reason behind not having presets for max/comps is the space required. It could be any number of reasons that weren't disclosed to the public.

2
zenylHere to help :)•

I suggested here on the sub, and a JMod said space was an issue. Nevertheless, this has been added (sounds like you don't know).

1
ReahuHail Hydra•

While we're on the topic of music playlists, can the ninja team add a little add to playlist button next to the song currently playing? It's just a small thing to make creating playlists easier, because whenever I hear a song I like I have to search through the entire song library to add it to my playlist.

1
EnofelOPRun...Escape!•

I understand what your saying, but they did add a search feature in case you didn't know :)

2
ReahuHail Hydra•

Ah, I didn't notice. Thanks for the tip! :)

1