Can Mishra, Artificer Prodigy be competitive?

I'm interested in running a Mishra deck. I'd probably go with some sort of stax deck using Nether Void and similar "everyone has to pay more except Mishra" effects. I've done a bit of research, but I haven't seen too much in the way of actual win conditions besides the Darksteel Forge/Nevi Disk/Mycosynth Lattice which seems sketchy given it's a 3 card combo without much in the way of tutoring like Arcum Daggson decks. Any idea on a possible win condition? Can Mishra stax be viable in a competitive environment?

Posted Dec 22, 2014, 8:12 PM UTC

710
mpaw975French 1v1 - Rafiq Infect / Anafenza Goodstuff•

Here's the Mishra Primer. It talks about Stax and Storm builds (what value!).

Edit. I can only comment on the Storm build. Besides what the author comments on, here's my take:

The deck, as stated, is not French legal. Grim Monolith and Mana Vault are not French legal. Timetwister is in fact French legal, so if you've got one, play it. It will make the deck much better.

The following cards can probably be cut, I'm not impressed by them.

  • Cruel tutor, Mystical Tutor. These are only good when you've already got your engine humming.
  • Diabolic Tutor. 4 mana is a lot.
  • Exsanguinate. This is a sort of all-in win condition with Krak-clan Ironworks. If it fails, then you are dead.
  • Snapcaster Mage. Only really included for storm kill reasons.
  • Dark Ritual, Cabal Ritual, Desperate Ritual. These are only temporary measures and don't help build or maintain the engine.
  • Coalition Relic, Basalt Monolith, Izzet Keyrune, Rakdos Keyrune, Chromatic Latern. 3 CMC mana rocks are mana-neutral when Semblance Anvil is online. (The 2 CMC ones are actually +1 mana, which is a big deal.)
  • Voltaic Key. It is only really helping out Basalt Monolith, which I also don't like.
  • Relic of Progenitus. You are going to really need your graveyard.
  • Blood Funnel. This card needs to be used with extreme caution. If they kill your Mishra, then your entire deck is offline.

Cards I've found work well:

  • Phyrexian Metamorph. This can copy any of your engine pieces, or your opponents creatures to stall out.
  • Treasure Cruise / Dig through Time.
  • More lands/fetchlands. The current deck is 25 lands. I think you want closer to 30. You basically want to always make your third/fourth land drop, then never draw another land again.
  • Windfall. This card on turn 3 often acts as another Wheel of Fortune.
  • Thoughtcast. Regassing is good.
  • Meekstone. It can help buy you some turns.
  • Howling Mine. Probably not good enough, but worth testing out. You don't really have the time to take advantage of it, which makes it less good.

Cards that are better than they seem:

  • Time Spiral, Wheel of Fortune, Timetwister. The gas these cards provide is essential.
  • Ornithopter and the other 0 mana artifact creatures. These do double duty when under the Semblance anvil as they lower the cost of artifacts and creatures.
  • Ichor Wellspring, Tsabo's Web and other 2 CMC + draw a card. These cards are the ones you really want to see when you get your engine started.
  • 2 CMC mana rocks. These guys are gas while your engine is online. They provide +1 mana while Semblance Anvil is online.
  • Chain of Vapor. Most often this will act like a poor man's Hurkyl's Recall which is used to reset your mana rocks/draw some cards.
6
tremilos•

I've been playing Mishra competively as a storm/combo deck for the past 6 months to great success. Here's my list. http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/mishras-durdle-house-v20/

2
mtgspotter•

Great list and deck name! Thanks for the share.

1
cromonolithFrench 1v1 Maelstrom Wanderer / Varolz•

Sure. A friend of mine has a pretty strong Mishra storm deck. It killed two people with Tendrils on turn 4 or 5 last night.

Mishra almost never gets used though. Blood Funnel is in there for shenanigans, but it's just an artifact-based storm deck.

1
mtgspotter•

I'd love to see a list if easy for you to provide.

1
cromonolithFrench 1v1 Maelstrom Wanderer / Varolz•

I don't think I have access to an up to date list. Paging u/mpaw975!

The idea is to play stuff like Vedalken Archmage and Riddlesmith to cantrip you when you cast artifacts. Then stuff like Semblance Anvil, Cloud Key and Helm of Awakening to make your artifacts essentially free to cast. Add in some artifacts that cantrip you (Chromatic Star, Conjurer's Bauble, Spellbombs, etc.) and once you get online you very quickly go through most of the deck. Along the way you find Tendrils or Grapeshot, probably Yawg Will, Time Spiral and the like, and winning becomes easy from that point.

The deck plays very few lands, less than 30, and around 50 artifacts.

Mishra doesn't need to be involved, frankly.

2
ReactorOperatorKaalia•

Just curious, how does Mishra's ability work if you can only have one of each type of card in the deck?

1
mpaw975French 1v1 - Rafiq Infect / Anafenza Goodstuff•

The two common uses of it are Nether Void and Blood Funnel.

In both cases, once Mishra is out, and the enchantment is out, you cast an artifact [say Howling Mine], then you can let the enchantment counter it, and then Mishra's ability resolves and you can Howling Mine in your graveyard.

If you are playing cut throat, you can also use Mishra to protect a key artifact from being countered. Example:

Let's say Mishra is out, and you want to resolve Darksteel Forge. You cast it, and they Cancel it (without saying anything about Mishra's ability). After the Cancel resolves, you announce that Mishra's ability resolves, then you find your Forge in your graveyard.

This will only work once, as after this, your opponent will wait for Mishra's ability to resolve, before countering your artifacts.

1
KingoOfChaos•

Planar Chaos and Possibility Storm are two other cards that work great with Mishra!

1
Deeviant•

Misha is a gimmic, but that doesn't mean he can't be used for style and profit.

There will always be more solid choice, power-level-wise than Mishra, but you can always make a solid Mishra deck.

It just comes down to what you're setting out to do.

1