noob question:why is my tank commander not gaining skill?

so I have an elite status on my T-28, I checked the "accelerate Crew training" box, and the tank commander is the one with the lowest skill, but he's not increasing:

http://i.imgur.com/2c6amjf.png

also, just to be sure, if my crew reach 100% on this elite tank, will they stay at 100% when I move them to the KV-1?

Posted Dec 24, 2014, 7:53 PM UTC

416
wot-mothmoth•

The 27% fire fighting gets in the way. It goes to the crew member with the lowest total experience.

25
mercurycc[RDDTX]•

I have no idea why this comment is at the bottom. This is the correct answer.

2
BR-700•

Your comment settings may be set like mine, where the Newest comment is on top and the oldest is on bottom?

1
UkTapesRDDT9 [DC] •

I think OP is wondering why his commander is at 88% and his radioman is at 97%, and yet the radioman has the bonus weighting for skill... This is likely because to the radioman also has an actual skill of 88%... The 97% includes a 9% bonus from the commander...

In terms of perks, op would be better in future training repairs or camo (repairs on this line) and dropping for 6th sense once he reaches 100%

0
arktoid[RDDT7 EU]•
  1. Your crew gets 10% of the commander's skill as a bonus. The commander himself does not get this bonus.

  2. You will need to retrain your crew if you move them up, which is 100% if you pay with gold (generally not worth it), 90% if you pay with credits (a small amount though) or 80% for free IIRC. If there are any mistakes please do correct me.

7
ExplosiveMachineAlex_Sonny [22ACU] Recruiter•

People explained it already, but I noticed another noob thing: take off the fire fighting and for god's sake put on sixth sense.

I can't believe how late I got sixth senses on my tanks because my former noob self didn't select it as first skill. It is useful on every tank.

7
Mac_redbaron•

It's best to level a skill, then when it gets to 100% drop it for SS

5
YT4LYFEREALLY LIKES TIER 9•

Yea but still... firefighting for the commander of a T28?

6
Mac_redbaron•

Yes, I agree this is... Odd.

1
ExplosiveMachineAlex_Sonny [22ACU] Recruiter•

But doesn't that cost gold?

1
GrassWaterDirtHorseDarthpepper22 63%Derp•

No. You can drop it for a nominal fee. As long as get the second skill to about 20-30%, you can drop skills for 20k credits and get one 100% first skill

2
nolo_mewoe2you [22ACU] XO•

Preferably Mentor, if you're only credit training the rest of the crew.

1
PhanthomPhreak•

at this point even fire fighting is better than 6th ... since he'll have to retrain the commander anyways and 6th only becomes active at 100% ...

With your advice OP would have to retrain twice, it's better to keep fire fighting (or ideally camouflage/repair) till he get's the skill to 100% so he can retrain it to 6th which will then be active.

Also if he retrains his skills without the main skill being at 100% he'll lose the crew skill and the exp will go to improve the commanders main skill.

2
boucem•

Since the OP is not spending gold, it's best to reset skills early on, because you lose less total XP. 27% on the first skill takes very little XP, so I would just drop it for free. The primary crew skill is much more important.

-2
NotAvn1r•

This is kinda confusing. The crew displayed training level and the actual training level are two different things. the percentage you see is the displayed training level, witch takes into account additional bonuses such as Ventilation, Brothers in Arms, and the Commander skill bonus.

"Every 10% of Commander’s combat skills give a bonus 1% to all crew! Thus, if your Commander is 50% trained, then the crew will be 55% trained. If the Commander is 100% trained, then the crew will be 110% trained."

So in your case, your commander is at 88%, that gives the crew an additional 8.8% (~9%) bonus to their main skill. So your crew is actually trained to about 88% (97% - 9%), its just the game displays other bonuses too. If you hover your mouse over the crewman in question it will also display all the bonuses affecting said crewman, including commander bonus.

Breakdown of your crew:

  • Commander............... 88%
  • Gunner..................... (88% + 9%) = 97%
  • Driver...................... (88% + 9%) = 97%
  • Radio Operator.......... (89% +9%) = 98%
  • Radio Operator 2....... (88% + 9%) = 97%
  • Loader..................... (88% + 9%) = 97%

So as you can see your commander is actually on par with the rest of your crew, he just doesn't get his own Commander skill bonus.

you can read more here: http://worldoftanks.asia/en/content/guide/general/tank-crew-training-and-qualifications/

7
fastbeemer•

Please read this tutorial, it will really help you, and shorten your learning curve: http://forum.wotlabs.net/index.php?/topic/166-how-to-crew-yer-tank-right/

1