My girlfriend cuts, I don't understand, I want her to be happy. What should I do?

My girlfriend cuts occasionally. Its not bad; you wouldn't notice if you didn't touch her wrist which would hurt her or the fact she comments on it occasionally.

We can't really talk about it because it is a really touchy subject for her and also I cannot empathize at all. She says she has no choice and that her mind hates her and stuff, but I just can't see how it isn't a choice, seeing as she has to actually do it...but I'm not here to discuss that.

The issue I have is I don't know what to say or what she wants me to do. Should I ignore it? Do I talk to her about it? How do I talk with her about it if she does? I don't want to offend her or anything, but I don't want her to think she's alone. I want her to be happy and stuff.

Can anyone give me advice about what to do or say? I don't care if the answer is nothing or everything. How do you hope other people act towards you when they know?

Context: Both in college, been together for > 2 years

Posted Jan 1, 2015, 9:49 PM UTC

99
cut_paste_throwaway•

Hi there!

First of all, you seem like a very empathetic person who sincerely cares for your girlfriend. That's great, that's probably exactly what she needs right now :)

However, you cannot expect to fix her. It sounds like she has some sort of mental illness, by what she's told you about her mind hating her, and mental illnesses are often a lifelong struggle. You can't fix them just by knowing what to say in specific instances. You "want her to be happy and stuff", but that simply might not be an option right now. All you can do is to support her in her own journey: encourage her to get professional help, make sure she knows that you're there for her if she needs to talk or cry or anything else.

It sounds like you really genuinely don't understand her urge to self harm, which would be a big stumbling block for me in a relationship. Maybe consider doing some research on self harm and mental illness, or go to therapy with her (with a therapist who understands self harm).

What you can do in the meantime is just to make sure she knows that you support her, even if you don't understand her. Telling (or worse, guilting ) her to stop cutting will likely breed resentment, but not talking about it at all will make her feel unloved. She's cutting because she's in a lot of pain. You need to recognize that and be there when she needs you. Certainly don't encourage the behaviour, let her know that it hurts you, but don't be an asshole about it either ;)

TL;DR: Encourage her to go to therapy. Consider going with her to develop understanding. Support her and allow her to move forward. Be patient.

5
answerquestionguyOP•

We're both in college and living with our respective parents, so the therapy is kind of a thing I (personally) can't see being a real possibility at the moment, mostly for the cost/fact I'm not with her often enough to actually suggest it.

However, looking to the future of us out of college and living together (aka going on with life lol), how would one go about mentioning professional help in a way that wouldn't hurt her or make her think I don't like her as the person she is? Because I love her for who she is, I just hate seeing her in pain and hurting herself, but I feel like I might mess up and say the wrong thing, making her think I want to actively change her and who she is...

1
cut_paste_throwaway•

College is actually the perfect opportunity! Most campuses have free mental health resources. You should check them out :)

You could always tell her that it hurts you to see her in pain, but that you don't know if you're capable of giving her the support she needs without help. You can tell her that you just want her to have every resource she needs to feel better. That you don't want her to change her personality, but that you want to help her move toward happiness.

1
Toadxx•

Cutting is addictive. Best advice I could give is to try and spend time with her, the more you do so the less time she has to cut. Try to keep her mind off of it unless her cuts become more serious. At least that's what I'd do.

1
answerquestionguyOP•

Best advice I could give is to try and spend time with her

Yeah, I figured that would help a lot. It just sucks because I live at college during the semester and can't be at home all that much, only like every other weekend or so :/

1
dunraim22M•

I think it is best that you just show that you are there for her, and that if she wants to talk about anything that she can and shouldn't be afraid or feel judged. I wouldn't specifically bring up the cutting, I know personally if I want to talk to someone about it I will, but if someone brings it to me I am most likely going to get angry and shut down completely. If she does bring it up just offer support and reassurance that she is not alone and that it will get better, don't stay stuff like promise me you won't cut for anything like that because it is really hard to keep a promise like that, and then when you don't you feel like more of a failure than you did before. I can only talk from personal experience.

1
reck121•

I can also only talk from my experiences.

To try and give an example of how someone could justify it, for me, the reasons are mostly simple but mine may not match someone else's. I put quite a lot of significance into my school work and when it goes wrong I just don't know where to place myself. For someone else, it can be something else. I find myself tossing and turning not being able to calm down. Some people will talk to a friend or draw or play football to get rid of that feeling. For me, I cope with this and it does calm me down and gives me something physical instead of mental. The problem with Sh is that is does calm you down so it's not so black and white when you're feeling high strung. It is a vice of sorts much like going for a drink after a bad exam to me at least.

I did have a relationship once with someone who shed (before I did) and at times it was difficult and it did have its downs and ups. Sometimes it may seem like she hates you but it's not actually true (in my experience) and at those times she may just want to sit silently for a while and that's okay. You can't put pressure on yourself to fix it because you can't and it isn't fair on yourself to burden yourself. You can just be there for her, no advice or suggestions (she may have heard it all already) just adoration, and though it may not seem like she appreciates it, she will.

One final point I'd like to make is that I tend to think in my old relationship was that sh wasn't the main problem, it was the extremely visible consequence of a more subtle problem. It may not be the same in yours but for mine her thoughts about herself were the problem which caused Sh. I would advise you not to loose hope when she does slip up.

Sorry if I'm awful at advice. Please don't forget to take care of yourself; that isn't just an empty gesture, it's important you do, you owe yourself that for being so genuinely caring. Feel free to pm me if you wanna talk (about you or her).

1
burninglikeabridge•

She's not going to stop cutting and asking her to will not make your relationship last long. You can try to focus on harm reduction rather than eliminating the harmful action. For example helping her bandage/clean cuts, advising to get medical attention if necessary and just give her a nice hug from time to time.

1
dance211•

All the other answers address your question well, so I'll focus on the empathy part.

Have you ever gotten angry, stressed, frustrated, etc. and banged your hands on the desk? Hit your head in frustration? Chewed on hangnails? Bit your lip out of stress? Cutting for a lot of people similar to that, except to an unhealthy extreme. Your body gets a flood of adrenaline which makes it easier to focus, calms you, etc. It's getting those feelings out.

1