ELI5: Why is it 'bad' for my heart to consume drugs (in moderate doses) that speed it up a little, but 'good' for my heart to speed it up by exercise? Other obvious complications aside, aren't they both doing the same thing?

Posted Jan 7, 2015, 12:02 AM UTC · edited

279
abelcc•

I literally never saw someone saying drugs are bad for your heart. What is "drugs" anyways, specify which ones. The bad consequences use to be addiction, mental damage, organ damage etc. but it depends on the drug.

1
oopsleonOP•

Really? I suppose some relevant examples for me are Marijuana and Adderall. Both noticeably increase my heart rate after consumption.

edit: Added an edit in the orginal post. Thanks for your feedback.

3
floydpambrose•

He's talking about medications that play with your heart rhythm and rate.

2
Hottstud•

I assuming when you workout the veins dilate allowing more blood to rush to the muscle/muscle group. When your heart races with a cold body the blood pressure rises with non dilated veins causing high blood pressure. disclaimer, I have no creditable sources

1
oopsleonOP•

Interesting idea. Can anyone add support/criticism to this?

3
DrImmergeil•

Everything in moderate doses.

I'm no major in the subject, but the way I see it, drug users are probably likely to keep taking a drug over and over, thus keeping their heart rate high for a prolonged timespan.
Working out only spikes your heartrate for a couple of hours usually, which is good for burning calories, while keeping a constant high heartbeat will eventually wear down your heart.

The way I see it, the slower your heart goes, the longer it takes to wear it down, it just so happens that a high heartrate is required to burn calories, kind of like a side effect of training muscles.

1
oopsleonOP•

Sure, this makes sense. However, does this somehow imply that the increased heart rate from a moderate drug dose is good for your heart? From my understanding, the increased BPM that a jog gives you is beneficial to your heart. Why not the same for increased BPM from a moderate drug dose?

2
DrImmergeil•

Nah, what I meant is that a high BPM is bad, but a nessecary evil in order to work off the calorie intake during your ordinary day.

I don't know jackshit about bodily functions, but from a cellular point of view you can either store the excess energy from calories by converting it into fat or, like during excercise, turn it into energy for the muscles to use.

AFAIK the only reason your heart rate spikes during excercise is because you need that extra oxygen being pumped to your muscles to maximise ATP(energy) production, and limit lactic acid buildup due to lack of ATP. Since ATP production needs oxygen to work, the increased heart rate is neccesary to keep going, even though a higher BPM is bad for you over time.

Hope this help, otherwise feel free to ask. I'm not sure, but I'm pretty certain this is the case.

1
TheSixPartsSeven•

I would assume that mixing different types of drugs would be bad for your heart, by telling it to speed up or slow down at the same time.

Ironically, you could liken it to doing running that require a lot of stopping and starting. (sort of like suicides on a basketball or tennis court). Where the movement of your body is your upper/downer, and the general feeling of anguish and sense of death is what your heart experiences.

This is in no way scientific, but you're only 5.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1