Are there any good resources on design for manufacturability of both electronics and enclosures for them?
I've been noodling around with an idea for a gadget for awhile, writing software, laying out circuits, scribbling out drawings on graph paper, etc. and I'm increasingly thinking I'd like to put it on Kickstarter and turn into a product. Without getting into the details too much, it's an electronic good that you connect to your computer, the size of pretty much every other random electronic gadget you might expect to find on a desktop (router, modem, desktop amps, audio interfaces, etc.). Bigger than a smartphone, smaller than an oscilloscope.
I'd like it to have a more premium feel, and therefore likely a metal (probably aluminum), non-sheetmetal (or at least not thin sheet metal that's folded together...like you might find in a typical ATX power supply) enclosure and I'd like to attempt to do everything myself as much as is reasonably possible both as a learning experience and as a cost saving measure (ignoring the cost of my time unless it's absolutely ridiculously inefficient compared to paying someone). There are some pre-made enclosures that seem vaguely viable, but I think a custom one is preferable for my uses so long as it is not absurdly impractical. Plus, even if it is absurdly impractical, I'd like to learn at what point it isn't. (How many Mac Minis does Apple have to make before it becomes profitable for them to use a housing like that?, etc.)
I have an...I suppose reasonable hobbiest understanding of all/most of the fields involved, and I think have a technical mind with a willingness to learn, but I come from a software background, not a physical one, so I'm trying to find information on how these things are done at scale, and the considerations and costs involved in bringing a product to market. I'm having issues finding that sort of information online compared to information on how to make something functional on an individual prototype level.
It's also frustratingly difficult to find ballpark estimates for costs for the manufacturing of a simple mechanical component. Most of the companies advertising their services want you to request a quote, which I suppose makes sense for them to do, but I'm not at that point yet, and I don't want to ask a business to hand hold me through the design process. What I have found so far is that people will discuss relative costs, IE "die casting is quite expensive for low volume sand casting has a lower tooling cost, but a higher per part cost at volume", but I'd love for an actual example rundown of a couple different items comparing the same basic shape/purpose with different methods.
Obviously exact numbers will vary by the manufacturer themselves, the exact specifics of the object and the time that the resource was written, but something as general as "An aluminum 10cm hollow cube with 3mm thick walls that you can screw the bottom onto will cost more than $5 and less than $15 if you make a thousand of them by die casting." or "You can reasonable expect a trained worker in China to put on 100 panel mount switches in an hour for $3 an hour, or $10 an hour in America, or a rate of X for $Y an hour if you have someone set up a machine to do it, but that will have a fixed setup cost of $Z" would be extremely helpful. (All of those numbers are numbers I don't really know, but last example has variables because I couldn't even hazard a non-embarrassing guess. Though that doesn't mean my existing guesses might not be embarrassing too.)
Are there any good books or videos or resources of some sort for general best practices and general expectations in this regard? For electronics or the mechanical aspects? My Google Fu has been failing me for the most part. I've found this video series and it's very helpful, I'd love to find other things like it as it applies both to that field in other ways, and as it applies to the manufacturing of enclosures and the like. Or hell, I find the whole thing very interesting; if you know of an exceptional resource about the manufacturing of anything, I'd love to take a look.
Another question I have is if I were to learn all I need to learn and do all that needs to be done, in my position as still a relative layman (IE I didn't go to school for it and don't have any experience with it), would you hire a consultant for any of the relevant disciplines? If so, how much would you expect to pay/would you charge to look it over and say "Yeah, you're not going to find out in 6 months that 80% of them will break because you designed this like a moron." or "Yeah, you designed that like a moron. You should do this instead."?
All of that said and asked, if you have any suggestions or advice about any of the endeavors mentioned in general, I'd love the input.
Posted Jan 9, 2015, 7:20 AM UTC
Your gadget will succeed based on how well it solves a problem. I wouldn't worry about concealing your idea too much. 100 other people have your idea too.
Tooling costs for mechanical enclosures are expensive. Unfortunately for you, people in the mechanical field will be more inclined to give better rates if you seem serious about volume production and capable of getting to production. Everyone in this industry deals with hobbyists/wannabee inventors/crackpots, and most of the time these people are a waste of time and money, so prices rise accordingly. If you show them a mechanical design that screams "I don't know what I'm doing" then expect further price adjustments.
On an electronics project I worked on, mechanical tooling for custom metal and plastic parts cost about $35,000, although our client saw quotes as high as $250,000 before we got involved and cleaned up the design. If you want professional quality tooling, you'll need to sell thousands to justify the cost.
On the electronic side, a good PCB should have a JTAG test chain so that all of the chips can be tested, a number of test points in key areas with clearance for "pogo" pins, a test jig you design and document to provide external test circuits, and a thorough built in self test mode. (Normally, setting a pull up/down resistor external to your PCB should tell your software "we're in a test jig" and automatically run tests instead.) All of this gets harder if you're trying to develop a secure platform (that is, if you want to prevent people from using the test interface to hack your device) - then you're looking at things like preprogramming your ICs with private keys before soldering.
If you have multiple PCBs, test them all independently and then as a unit.
You don't need consultants, but you do need engineers or technologists with domain knowledge. These projects are almost always a team effort. There are issues you haven't even considered (I imagine) like ESD protection and RF emissions - and mechanical issues can play a large role in mitigating or aggravating both. If you can't pass an FCC/UL/EU test, you can't sell.
I'm not too concerned, it just takes a little more explanation than I thought would be useful. My post already seems pretty long. Plus there's "not too concerned about it" and "willing to post it on a public forum on the internet that specifically is aimed at people who are capable of executing the process faster than me". Though I realize there's a combination of ego and irrational neuroticism involved in thinking that way. I'd still rather not get too into the nitty gritty details, but it's an audio interface, and does audio-interface-y things. It'd be USB powered, and all of the 'complicated' stuff would be done by some off-the-shelf ICs.
Sure, makes total sense, which is why I want to learn before I bother them. Before talking to a manufacturer I want to have a design that I'm reasonably confident doesn't require much input from them. IE that they can just take a CAD file, format it for their equipment and press the "Go" button for (..I know I'm oversimplifying even the minimum input they could have, but my general goal is to learn as much as possible, and I'd rather do most of the intellectual heavy lifting to myself). That's why I'm looking for resources.
I've found some stuff, as for design considerations and considerations for communication with the manufacturer to limit the amount of work they'd need to do and therefore the cost, but I haven't found something that was fairly comprehensive that made it all "click"; that gave nice examples of ways you should do it and ways you shouldn't do it and the costs involved for both. Ultimately I'm sure that a lot of it is experience, but there must be something out there that outlines some of the specifics.
How did you or whomever was involved in cleaning up the design learn to do this? Was it in school, or was it experience working with manufacturers in the past? That might aid in my search for resources. Am I looking for lectures in a Mech. E course or to be a fly on the wall in an industrial machine shop?
Also, sort of generally, can you say what they did wrong that lead to a $250,000 quote? Was it just an overly complicated design with too many features that required too much intervention or precision? Too many parts? Too many processes?
Can you give me some (vague) idea what that project was or how complicated it was on the grand scale of electronic products at that $35,000 final price? I have to imagine that the difference in tooling costs between, for instance, the HTC One M8 vs your average USB Thumbdrive (even an aluminum housed one) would be pretty substantial. Like..a few orders of magnitudes substantial.
I'm more or less familiar with this and have given it consideration. I don't know the specifics of how to implement that sort of thing, but I am reasonably confident I know how to learn them when the time comes.
My understanding is that certification/compliance for an unintentional transmitter (which my device would be) is relatively easy to achieve. I don't believe the requirements for ESD protection to be particularly difficult to meet either, though I'll need to research the standards more carefully. Maybe this is a poor assumption on my part, but I believe the electronics involved to be relatively well trodden as classification of product that is not too difficult to certify. Products that do things that are similar enough have both plastic (without any shielding on the PCB) and very uncomplicated aluminum enclosures. I think my requirements are simply "a box that looks and feels nice and a PCB can be mounted in that doesn't make electrical contact with the components/is otherwise obviously terrible". It's hard to know what I don't know, though, so maybe I'm missing an aspect of it.
Also, thank you very much for your input so far and any you can give in the future.
The project was probably a 20 person-year effort, and would have had over in $1m R&D costs. I do not know if the investors will break even, but I would guess no. It's a specialty product for a certain type of professional that sells for over $1000 and probably only a few thousand units will ever be made. It did have a novel industrial design that made it more mechanically complex than most devices – maybe two orders of arbitrary magnitude above a USB drive, but three orders below a modern mobile phone.
I suspect that practical experience in the machine shop would make a difference. Technical or engineering seminars on the subject might help as well.
It's not hard. The trouble is – overall – you're in an area that isn't conceptually hard to figure out, but is also an area where it's hard to substitute for practical experience and the experience-improvement feedback loop is long and expensive. If you happen to be a programmer, consider running the equivalent of "make all" on a PCB costs a couple of thousand dollars and several days of preparation, and there's no guarantee your build will succeed.
It's certainly not impossible for a single person to pull it off, it's just not an easy road.
If you have a device that has very few external connections and go in a metal box, it's somewhat easier. The more interfaces (I/O, screen, sensor), the more opportunities for RF and ESD issues. The industrial design has a large impact on these issues. Faster processors, more issues. More signal clocks, more issues. Bigger PCB, more issues.
If you're not worry about the unit cost of the design, you have more options in terms of using a high layer count PCB (letting you hide the "noisy" layers inside the board), adding metal cans around your transmitters, ESD snubbers, transient voltage suppressors, etc. Part of the trick is trying to achieve compliance on a really tight budget where adding a $.04 part is a big deal.
See http://www.celectronics.com/seminar/sample/IEEE11-9-05.pdf
RF and ESD labs cost about $200-400/hour for their time. Usually you do a prescan to check if it will likely pass (might take a few hours) and then a full scan (maybe a day). If it does not work, you try again.
Thank you very much for this comment, it's very helpful in giving me a sanity check of what my expectations should be! The whole thing does seem quite daunting, and I must say that after going over some particularly complicated technical document, I've thought: "How the hell am I ever going to do all of this", but I'm determined to learn everything I can.
I really appreciate the time you've taken to answer my questions.