r/keto•
glintsCollide

Gene test shows high fat may not be the ideal diet for me

I did a quick test where you swab the inside of your cheek and send it in for DNA analysis. They test four different genes called FTO, PPARG, APOA5 and FABP2. I would like some input from anyone who's got a bit of knowledge on the science and research behind this stuff.

First off I learned that I have a gene combination that promotes over weight, which means I need to take some steps to counteract that in order to lose weight or keep my weight. Second I learned that I have a good allele that promotes low LDL cholesterol which is good. Another gene suggest that exercise will have a big effect on my weight, my body responds well to it, so that's all fine.

The more interesting result is that one gene combination suggests that eating mono-saturated fat would promote a lower BMI for me, but that a high-fat diet would promote a higher BMI, my sweet spot would be that fat is 30% of my energy intake. They suggest food like avocado, nuts, chicken, olives and olive oil. They also mention the Mediterranean diet.

Let's assume I take this at face value and try to implement the optimal diet and exercise plan for myself based on this, am I to believe that poly-saturated and saturated fat is counter-productive for me? Or is it just that I should have some mono-saturated fat in there for good measure? I can't just skip the omega-3's, and what about saturated fat?

Does this seem compatible with LCHF/Keto in my case?

Posted Jan 11, 2015, 8:00 PM UTC

222
mrdumbphone•

Referencing Phinney and Volek, genetic testing with respect to dietary guidelines is in its infancy. The complexity of the phenotype/dietary interactions are assumed to be extraordinarily complex to the point that there is little active research pursuing them at this point.

What is well understood is the Carbohydrate => Insulin => Body Fat relationship, and it has been understood for hundreds if not thousands of years that feeding grain to an animal makes it fat.

The Phinney and Volek interpretation of various studies on weight loss and low carb vs low fat dieting is that there is universal positive response to a LCHF diet but that response to low fat carb restricted diets is much more varied.

Individuals who are "insulin sensitive," i.e. not apt to develop diabetes, will respond to a "low fat calorie restricted diet" nearly as well as they do to a low carb diet (but the LCHF diet is better still). However, those who have reduced insulin sensitivity, pre-diabetes, metabolic syndrome, syndrome X, whatever will respond very poorly to a low fat calorie restricted diet but just as well to a LCHF diet as those with proper insulin sensitivity.

In short, LCHF works for everyone and LFCR works for some (maybe 33% of the population).

EDIT: You're almost universally better off consuming animal fats than oils. Lard, tallow, and any other animal fat should be preferred followed by tropical oils like palm and coconut. Olive oils, avocado oil etc are acceptable for medium heat cooking but they don't have mythical health benefits as you might have been lead to believe by mainstream media and weren't considered fit for eating until 100 years ago. All polyunsaturates should be avoided especially "vegetable," "canola," cotton seed, soybean...

3
glintsCollideOP•

When trying to interpret the result I brushed up a little on mono-unsaturated fats, and it seems I can only find it in very few foods, and the Swedish equivalent of the FDA keeps going on about rapeseed oil and margarine spreads being so good for the cardiovascular system - which I'm not buying at all, and also that only 30% of the energy should come from fat which seems plain difficult when you cut out the carbs. Also, saturated fat seems all but banned still.

I could imagine that there is statistics that links these alleles to the effects they're describing, I'm just not very sure about the resulting action suggested in the conclusion. I get the feeling that the conclusions drawn from the test I did is completely based on those old archaic guide rules.

Is there anything that I can keep in mind from this test? I assume it's scientifically accurate, even though the conclusions may be a bit off.

About the polyunsaturated fats, omega 3 is part of that group, isn't that supposed to be vital to this type of diet?

1
mrdumbphone•

Ignore mainstream nutrition. If you're interested some books are The Big Fat Surprise, The Art and Science of Low Carbohydrate Living, either of Taubes' books, or you can watch Youtube lectures by Phinney, Volek, Taubes etc. This page is also fairly good on fats.

Fats are extraordinarily complicated in structure, oil composition, metabolism, etc. The best bet is to eat older fats and not newer processed oils because we quite literally evolved eating animal fats exclusively, not shortening hydrogenated from the refined oil extracted from the unused excess seeds that fell out of cotton plants.

Omega 3:

  • Omega 3 and Omega 6 are both required to be ingested by the body as we have no metabolic way of creating them (whereas Omega 9 can be created from Saturated Fat).
  • They should be consumed in a one to one ratio, which is the ratio found in grass fed animal fats, eggs, milk, butter.
  • It is important to note that the need for these essential fatty acids is relatively small, so in the case that you're consuming 80% of your calories from fat you should primarily worry about the ratio of the fatty acids in your food (IE eat animal fats). You can overdo Omega 3 consumption if you consume an excess of fish oil supplements in addition to fortified foods etc.
  • The so-called "polyunsaturated oils" like soybean, cottonseed (commonly called "Vegetable"), rapeseed (commonly called "Canola) etc are very high in Omega 6 while being low in Omega 3. The result is that most people in the US consume vastly more Omega 6 than Omega 3, and studies have shown that many inflamation markers and chronic diseases are improved as that dietary ratio moves closer to 1:1.
  • Grain fed livestock is much higher in Omega 6 than Omega 3, just like the so-called polyunsaturated oils.
  • Lard is fairly high in Oleic Acid, the monounsatured fatty acid that Olive Oil gets all the praise for.
2
glintsCollideOP•

Thanks for the input, I've read a couple of books and a lot of other sources and I'm onboard with all your arguments. I was just mostly interested in whether a test like this could be applied to the way I eat, LCHF doesn't seem to work that well for me, except that cutting carbs does wonders over-all. I'm pretty sure I need to keep track of my caloric intake if I'm to lose weight more effectively, which is also what the test suggests. I just don't think 30% fat is workable, and I didn't quite get why mono-unsaturated fats were touted specifically. I guess I'll ignore that bit either way.

1
mrdumbphone•

What do you mean it doesn't work that well for you?

Remember, there's a 1-3 week adaptation phase and you need electrolytes.

1
DownhillYardSaleSD: 9/1/13 | 33/M/5'7" | SW 183 | CW 151.2 | GW 150•

First off I learned that I have a gene combination that promotes over weight, which means I need to take some steps to counteract that in order to lose weight or keep my weight.

What is the specific gene combination? I would like to do further analysis please.

Second I learned that I have a good allele that promotes low LDL cholesterol which is good.

Which allele, please?

Another gene suggest that exercise will have a big effect on my weight, my body responds well to it, so that's all fine.

Same here, please.

The more interesting result is that one gene combination suggests that eating mono-saturated fat would promote a lower BMI for me, but that a high-fat diet would promote a higher BMI, my sweet spot would be that fat is 30% of my energy intake. They suggest food like avocado, nuts, chicken, olives and olive oil. They also mention the Mediterranean diet.

Data, please.

Let's assume I take this at face value and try to implement the optimal diet and exercise plan for myself based on this, am I to believe that poly-saturated and saturated fat is counter-productive for me? Or is it just that I should have some mono-saturated fat in there for good measure? I can't just skip the omega-3's, and what about saturated fat?

Let's not take it at face value so we can give you actual advice, not hypothetical. :)

2
glintsCollideOP•

Absolutely!

FTO is supposed to show whether I have an increased risk of obesity or being over-weight. It shows genotype A/T, which is a positive, ie. I have the increased risk.

PPARG is supposed to show BMI tendency in relation digesting various fats. I have genotype C/G which points to mono-unsaturated fats being related to a lower BMI for me according to the test.

APOA5 is supposed to show how my body deals with fat in the diet. I have genotype T/T which points to a higher BMI when high fat intake according to the test.

FABP2 is supposed to be involved in how the body transports, binds and breaks down fats. I have genotype G/G which is supposed to show that I do not have a tendency for high blood fats.

Here's some translated text from the test information:

BMI and exercise, the FTO gene

A well described gene can be linked to overweight and obesity is on chromosome 16 and is called FTO (fat mass and obesity Associated ( Gene) ). The FTO gene is expressed primarily in the brain and is believed to have been linked to appetite and food intake. In this test we are looking at a specific position in the gene, where a change results in different gene variants (alleles), one A allele and one T allele. The A allele of the gene associates with an increased risk of overweight and obesity. Carriers of the A allele respond better in the exercise to help weight loss than those who do not carry this gene . FTO gene detects if you are at risk for overweight or obesity depending on your genotype. People with AA genotype are at a 40-60% higher risk of overweight and obesity and people with AT genotypes have a 20-30 % higher risk of overweight and obesity. Individuals with the TT genotype have no increased risk of obesity. Carriers of the A allele respond better in the exercise to help weight loss than those who do not carry this gene. These people can reduce the risk of overweight and obesity by up to 30 % through physical activity

BMI and fat types , PPARG gene

There are also several different genes that affect how we handle different types of fat in the food and how the body reacts to this. PPARG affect the metabolism of fats and is expressed in adipose tissue. People with a certain gene variant (G allele) of PPARG tend to have a lower BMI at diet containing a higher proportion of monounsaturated fat.

BMI and the amount of fat in the diet, APOA5 gene

The APOA5 gene is also linked to the regulation of fats and storage of fat in fat cells and thus has a role in the development of obesity. Studies show that people who are carriers of the C allele of the APOA5 gene does not tend towards a higher BMI even if the diet consists of a lot of fat. These people tend to even get a reduced BMI at a high-fat diet. Individuals who do not have this gene variant have instead tended to increase their body mass index and risk of overweight or obesity at a high-fat diet.

Lipoproteins , FABP2 gene

Blood lipids such as cholesterol are important building blocks of the body but can at high levels be risk factors for heart/vascular disease. FABP2 gene (Fatty Acid Binding Protein) generates an intracellular protein which affects the amount of fat in the blood. Individuals who carry the A allele of FABP2 gene may cause an increased amount of triglycerides and LDL (bad cholesterol) and a decreased amount of HDL (good cholesterol) in the blood. FABP2 genotype shows if you are at an increased risk of dyslipidemia. Genotype AA and AG gives an increased risk of LDL (bad cholesterol) and lower levels of HDL (good cholesterol). According to the Food Administration, many people would do well to eat more monounsaturated fat and reduce the amount of saturated fat and this could also lead to lower levels of blood fats.

2
DownhillYardSaleSD: 9/1/13 | 33/M/5'7" | SW 183 | CW 151.2 | GW 150•

FTO is supposed to show whether I have an increased risk of obesity or being over-weight. It shows genotype A/T, which is a positive, ie. I have the increased risk.

The studies apparently show a difference of a few kg. I'm not sure, even if I had this, why I would be concerned. It may explain why I can lose weight more easily if I exercised but we know exercise helps improve weight loss, A/T allele or no. What does this change in your behavior knowing this?

Regardless of why your body is the way it is your mind needs to decide what it will do with itself.

The information is interesting but beyond that...

If you haven't had detailed lipid profiles accomplished how do you know what this diet is doing to your body?

You say it doesn't seem to work.

How so?

Need data.

When did you start? What is your macro target? How much weight have you lost? Have you gotten any smaller?

1
glintsCollideOP•

It's absolutely a mind game. I feel that if I somehow knew the optimal path it would be easier to follow through. I've been at it before, lost some but fell off the wagon eventually. I'm very motivated now, this was just a way to see if I could find some science to back up my decisions with.

The test result is pretty vague and the conclusions are drawn from some mainstream statistics, and the advice is straight out of the Food Administration's text books which wants you to eat heaps of fruit and say no to most fat, so I'm taking that part with a healthy grain of salt.

Good to hear that the studies are that vague, I wont linger too much on that. I initially dropped 50+ kg during 3-4 years from calorie restriction, lowcarb food and exercise, my current status is that I've gained about half of it back over three years since then because life changed a bit at that point. I've hovered around a 10-15KG regain for most of that time but now I'm up to 25+ backlash so here's where I draw the line. I'm down ~2KG from my new starting point, counting since around new year, but I've beep stepping up and getting back to proper LCHF just now this last week.

Macros are about 10/15/75%, carbs/protein/fat, but it varies between days. I juice vegetables such as broccoli, kale, zuccini and eat a lot of eggs, cheese, avocado, olives, and various meat and fish. My daily calorie intake have been between 1500-2000.

1
DownhillYardSaleSD: 9/1/13 | 33/M/5'7" | SW 183 | CW 151.2 | GW 150•

It's absolutely a mind game. I feel that if I somehow knew the optimal path it would be easier to follow through. I've been at it before, lost some but fell off the wagon eventually. I'm very motivated now, this was just a way to see if I could find some science to back up my decisions with.

You don't though, that's the rub.

Macros are about 10/15/75%, carbs/protein/fat, but it varies between days. I juice vegetables such as broccoli, kale, zuccini and eat a lot of eggs, cheese, avocado, olives, and various meat and fish. My daily calorie intake have been between 1500-2000.

Focus on net grams, not ratios. They don't assist you any.

Be careful with kale as it has sugar in it.

1500-2000 is a wide variance with weight loss.

Did you use the macro calculator?

1
anbeav•

It's a nice marketing product to make money but four genes are unlikely to be most predictive of what diet is best for individuals.

This is the typical let's use allelic variation to make correlations and get a big pay check.

You could go through the genome and do this for years...find all sorts of correlations, are they clinically relevant, most are not.

I would do nothing based on these results.

1
glintsCollideOP•

I hear ya. I don't think it's exactly wrong though, but the correlations may not be very strong, and the recommendations they come up with seems to be taken directly from the mainstream nutrition ideas. I would be interested in an interpretation of this with a more modern keto-friendly mindset. There may yet be something to learn here, I hope.

1
mrdumbphone•

Just remember, keto is the opposite of "mainstream nutrition" at the moment.

1
glintsCollideOP•

I'm well aware, that's the reason I'm here in the first place.

1
anbeav•

I'm interpreting it with a keto-friendly mindset. I currently spend much of my day analyzing genomic data, you can find anything you want and few if any of it has bench to bedside applications.

1
bidnowM/6'0"/59|SW 352|CW 207|GW 167|SD 11/1/12•

I firmly believe that different people thrive on different types of diets, and I also agree that genes/heredity play the biggest part. I also believe that the science is not really developed yet, and you may come across some shysters. This was the only such reference that I recall:

http://rockstarresearch.com/these-5-genes-predict-what-kind-of-diet-and-exercise-is-best-for-your-body-2/

And no, if you limit your fat calorie intake to 30% of your total, that cannot be a keto diet. About the minimum fat content for a hypocaloric ketogenic diet would be 50%.

1
glintsCollideOP•

That's pretty similar to the test I took actually. Allegedly, I'm in the category that shouldn't eat lowcarb, (i.e. high fat I assume). But I couldn't imagine switching to carbs just because of this test, I know my body just swells when I do. So maybe I'm left with LCLF/LCRC, or just ignoring that part of the result all together.

I also think certain diets are more efficient for different people even though most diets work to some degree on everyone. I was interested in optimizing my diet if I could, but I'm not really seeing a conclusive interpretation of the result.

1