Flowah•

The whole "we have virtually the same roster as last year" doesn't work for this situation.

The first half of last season's roster was much different than this season.

No Sheahan, Jurco, Nyquist, and even Tatar sat the first few games. Meanwhile Bert, Sammy, Cleary were mainstays. Also we had no Weiss at all last season, and I'm pretty sure Helm was injured at the start. Helm has been in every game so far this year.

So rosters are very different at this point. And it does show. Not only has the forward group been much improved with skill and speed, as even Babcock noted, but Quincey improved, Howard rebounded, and Smith played better.

So yeah, we look like a way better team.

9
elzeardclym•

I think he meant that at this time last year the rosters were similar. But I'm too lazy to look it up right now. Seems plausible, the notable exceptions being Dats/Z might have been out.

1
Flowah•

At this very point, yes, the rosters were pretty similar.

But within the context of what he was saying he was trying to say "we're basically the same roster but we're doing so much better!"

That just doesn't make sense since Nyquist missed 24 or so games, Sheahan and Jurco only played the latter ~45 games, and Tatar missed the first 8 of 42. Team was pretty damn different for the first half overall.

1
elzeardclym•

That's true. I guess I didn't completely understand what you were getting at.

1
FrogTrainer•

I agree, Helm is one of those players that doesn't appear to have a huge impact on paper, but really shakes things up when he is on the ice.

1
Decaf_EngineerOP•

I never understood the doubters about this season. We made the playoffs with kids who were still wet behind the ears, but somehow we'd miss it after they matured a year? Pffft...

1
GardinerExpressway•

I think its strange that Tatar and Nyquist have the same grades, I thought Tatar has been performing above expectations and Nyquist not so much.

I would give Tatar A and Nyquist B+

7
Datsyukia•

I definitely agree. Nyquist has a tendency to go invisible for 1-3 games at a time but Tatar seems to get chances most nights.

6
BenAdaephonDelat•

Not sure if leafs fan or redwings fan who lost a bet...

2
GardinerExpressway•

I'm a Leaf fan but I watch quite a few other games as well. The Red Wings are good to watch since they have some exciting players and most of their games end up with a close score.

5
BenAdaephonDelat•

So.. what you're saying is.. You're some kind of spy!!! Get your pitchforks boys!

6
Syuk_Dat_Deke•

I felt the same way.

1
elzeardclym•

Random: The other night I heard Ken and Mick say that Mike Babcock said Darren Helm is a better winger than a center.

And we all know he's said more than once that he's the best third line center in the league.

... I don't know the point of that, but there it is. I've liked the Helm-as-wing experiment, personally. Off to a slow start, but he's played well this season. He'll likely have career bests this year.

3
how_it_goes•

All I know is Helm carrying the puck through neutral ice is terrifying. I'd rather just let him go fast and get the puck from somebody else.

7
elzeardclym•

All I know is Helm carrying the puck through neutral ice is terrifying.

Why do you say that?

1
how_it_goes•

He usually has bad hands. The kind of hands that turn a neutral zone push into an odd-man rush the other way.

1
elzeardclym•

I don't know. I tend to think his puck possession is pretty good.... I think his reputation as "Stone Hands" is exaggerated anyways, but it mostly applies to his shooting or when he tries to make fancy moves.

As if this really needs to be posted.

I'm not saying it's never happened, but I can't think of a time when I've ever seen him make a terrible neutral ice turnover.

2
Kanz101•

Funny that this was posted the day after Anderson scores...

2
Decaf_EngineerOP•

The article was posted 3 days ago, but still, I don't think one goal will earn much of a grade improvement.

1
Decaf_EngineerOP•

Something I didn't know. Tony Granato isn't just our PK coach, but coaches the defense as well. I wonder what he's said to Quincey...

1
big_phat_gator•

It was probably the money pile Holland gave him that got him going.

1
JOHNxJOHN•

I'd give Glenny and Sheahan A's but other than that i pretty much agree with his grades.

1
big_phat_gator•

Still only 7 points more then last season, i think thats a bit disappointing...

0
Ducey89•

That's 14 points over the entire season if we keep it up, turning our 8 spot last year into 4-5.

4
big_phat_gator•

Well yeah, but the way people are talking and hyping one could think we are top 3.

2