Kil'Sorrow Cultist: A detailed look at a card Hearthstone needs.

Card

Kil'Sorrow Cultist

  • Neutral Commmon Minion
  • 3 Mana, 2 Attack, 3 Health
  • Battlecry: Silence a minion.

INTRODUCTION

Kil’Sorrow Cultist is 3 mana 2/3 minion which silences a minion. Compared to other neutral Silence minions it shares a similar statline: 2 stats off vanilla test while its attack and health are 1 stat apart. It is, in theory balanced, and it fits a niche other silence minions can't handle well. Here's why:

TRADE POWER

Consider a battlecry silence to be worth a mana of a minion’s cost, that the minions themselves are worth 1 less than they cost. Playing a Silence, leaving a weaker creature on the board is bad for your tempo. To counter this, Ironbeak owl and Spellbreaker are attack focused minions, which will trade well with the aggressive minions with an equal mana cost, despite being less valuable.

Kil’Sorrow makes no attempt to trade well with 3 drops, in most cases a 3 drop will kill it and survive, even when aggressively inclined. However it gets to trade with (nearly) all 2 drops, and can (nearly always) knock out multiple 1 drops. While it does get taken by your opponent’s 3 drop, you get to retaliate on turn 4, arguably the most valuable turn. Water elementals, Void Callers, Kor’krons, Truesilvers and Consecrations, Defender of Argus etcetera etcetera…

STRATEGIES

  • Kil’sorrow silences and trades with Undertaker and Mad Scientist.

  • It’s a powerful tempo play with Ancient Watcher.

  • Silences Mechwarper and trades with lesser mechs.

  • Is a powerful counter to Nerubian Egg

A LESS VOLATILE EARLY GAME

Failing to mulligan solid 1-2 cost card in the beginning of a hearthstone match can be devastating. Tempo built in those first few turns can take until turn 4 to die down. It’s why rush is so prevalent in HS. Games can be won before mid-range decks reach a bulk of their strong cards. A calm start leads to deeper commitment to a match and a slower game. A Slower game lets players play with and against a larger variety of cards, creating more interesting matches.

As a common Kil’Sorrow Cultist is open to all players, and it creates a slower game without eliminating the importance of a board. It’s not the go to 3 drop, it has puny stats. It’s not the got to silence, it costs more than ironbeak, being worse for late game tempo. Its niche is strictly to stop a rush meta from getting out of hand.

TL;DR

A downwards trading 3 drop with a silence attached is a simple soft-solution to upsetting early games. I think Hearthstone needs something like it.

Posted Jan 26, 2015, 5:17 AM UTC

92
OptimismBeast•

Although there's no real way to know if this card will affect the meta as you intend it to, this is still a perfectly balanced card in a vacuum.

2
sumsum98•

Interesting enough, I like it. Well done on the thought process.

1