No Excuse [Commentary of Tafseer]
Bismillah
And they said, "If we follow the guidance with you (0 Muhammad), we will be driven out of our land!' Is it not that We have established them in the peaceful Haram (sanctuary) to which the fruits of everything are drawn as a provision from Us? But most of them do not know. [57] And how many a town have We destroyed that were over-proud of their means of living. So, those are their habitations which were never inhabited after them except a few, and We alone were the inheritors. [58] And your Lord is not to destroy the towns unless he sends to their central place a messenger who recites to them Our verses. And We are not to destroy the towns except when their people are wrongdoers. [59] And whatever of anything you are given is (no more than) an enjoyment of the worldly life and its decoration, and that which is with Allah is much better and far more lasting. So do you not understand? [60]
And they said, "If we follow the guidance with you (0 Muhammad), we will be driven out of our land." [28:57].
Harith Ibn 'Uthman and other infidels of Makkah put forward one of the reasons for their non-acceptance of faith that although they believed that his teachings were based on truth, but they feared that if they followed him, the entire people of Arabia would turn against them, and as a consequence they will be driven out of their land. (Nasai'i etc.). The Holy Qur'an has given three answers to their lame excuse. One,
Is it not that We have established them in the peaceful haram (sanctuary) to which the fruits of everything are drawn as a provision from Us [ 28:57]
that is this excuse of theirs is false, because Allah Ta'ala had already made special arrangements for the safety of the people of Makkah by making its land haram. All the tribes of Arabia, despite their mutual feuds and infidelity, were unanimous on the point that killing and feuds were strictly prohibited on the land of Makkah. If a killer of father met the son in the haram, despite extremely strong feelings of revenge, he could not raise his hand against him. It was just not possible for any one to kill or harm his enemy on the ground of haram. Therefore, it was not at all a convincing excuse for not converting to faith. How was it possible that the Creator of everything would let them die as a believer, when He had made arrangement for their safety in haram even as infidels? Yahya Ibn Sallam has explained this verse as: 'You were safe and secure because of haram, and were enjoying the sustenance provided by Me in plenty, still you used to worship others instead of Me. You did not get worried over this situation of yours, and on the contrary got worried over conversion to faith in Me' (Qurtubi). In this verse two qualities of haram are described. One, that it is a place of peace, and the other that fruits from different parts of the world were brought there.
Availability of all types of produce in Haram of Makkah is a special Divine gift
Allah Ta'ala chose Makkah Mukkarramah, out of the whole world, to establish the Ka'ba and Haram. In terms of its environment and geography it is a region where, under the normal circumstances, hardly any economic or commercial goods and activity should have existed. Even the basic staple agricultural products like wheat, rice, gram and sundry cereals were not cultivated before on a significant scale, let alone fruits and variety of vegetables. Though, in recent years there has been some emphasis from the Saudi Government toward their cultivation. Yet, everything is available there in such an abundance that one gets amazed. During the period of hajj some two million people are drawn from all over the world and stay there for an average of one month. It has never been heard that any scarcity of food items was ever experienced there. On the contrary, everyone can witness that cooked and prepared food to cater for all types of races and people is readily available all the time. If we ponder over Qur'anic words, which say fruits of everything, a question arises that fruits are the product of trees, so it would have been fruits of every tree rather than fruits of every thing. Therefore, it is quite likely that the word 'every thing' used here, encompasses the produce and products of all kind, including agricultural produce. For instance, the produce of industrial factories is also their fruit. Hence, the gist of the discussion is that not only food items but also all sorts of things of human need would be made available in Makkah. Any one visiting Makkah, either for hajj or 'umrah, can confirm that everything produced anywhere in the world is readily available there. This was one reply to the excuse put forward by the infidels of Makkah, and the gist of the reply was that the Lord who had been so kind to them that He had made available all the bounties of the world in their city, despite the fact that they are not produced there, and who had made the city completely free of risk and danger, it is the worst kind of ignorance to presume about Him that He would deprive them of these benefits if they would believe in Him.
The second reply to their excuse is given in the next verse And how many a town have We destroyed that were over-proud of their means of living. [28:58]. In this reply it is stressed that they should recall the plight [dangerous situation] of other infidel people of the world, how their habitations, strong forts, and all means of their protection were destroyed, because of their infidelity and rejection of the truth. What they should actually fear is their infidelity and associating others with Allah, which is the real cause of destruction. How foolish and ill informed they were that they feared faith and not the denial of truth and infidelity.
The third reply was given in the following verse: And whatever thing you are given is the enjoyment of the worldly life [28:60]. Here it is explained that just in case they did get involved in some sort of trouble as a result of accepting faith, it would last only for a few days. Just as mundane wealth and comfort is temporary and would last for a short time only, worldly troubles are also transient and short-lived. Therefore, the wisdom lies in that one should seek and care for the comfort and happiness that is lasting. If one has to suffer trouble for a short time for the sake of permanent and ever lasting wealth and comfort, it is well worth it. Which were never inhabited after them except a few [28:56]. The habitations of the earlier people, which were destroyed by the Divine torment, still lie uninhabited, with the exception of a few. If the exemption 'except a few' is taken for those living there and the places destroyed, as Zajjaj has construed it, then the meaning would be that those places could never get inhabited, except a few that are inhabited. But Sayyidna Ibn 'Abbas [ra] has given another explanation of the verse. According to his interpretation, the exemption is not for the place and houses, but for the time. Thus the meaning would be that even if someone lives there, it is for a short time, like travelers, who cannot be regarded as permanent residents.
Unless he sends to their central place a messenger [28:59]. Popular meaning of the word 'Umm is mother, and since mother is the very basis of human creation, hence the word 'Umm is also used extensively for origin, base, and foundation. The pronoun ha (translated above as 'their') refers back to the towns, and 'mother of the towns' means the central town. The meaning of the verse is that Allah Ta'ala does not destroy a people unless He had sent His message through His messengers in their main cities. When the invitation to truth had reached, and yet people did not accept it, only then the torment is sent on those cities. This verse has pointed out that Allah's messengers and prophets are generally sent in big cities, and not in smaller towns, because such towns are normally under the influence of big cities, both for their economic and educational needs. If something is known in a big city, it becomes known automatically in the smaller towns around it. Hence, when a prophet is sent in a big city and he starts his call to the truth, the message is spread out in the surrounding towns in no time. This way Allah Ta'ala's message reaches to all and sundry, and if they reject the message of truth, the torment is sent to all of them.
Read also: People of the Book & the word 'Muslim'
NOTE: I am not the one writing all of this. I am quoting interesting parts from a Tafseer called Maariful Qur'an. I am very far from having so much knowledge. The credit goes to Mufti Muhammad Shafi Uthmani [RA], his son Mufti Taqi Uthmani & the translators. I am no one compared to these men.
Posted Feb 2, 2015, 11:28 PM UTC · edited