r/motorcycles•
Psada

Kawasaki Ninja 250 vs Hyosung GT 250 naked - Stark price different - Resell value / maintenance costs?

(Stark price difference*) Hello there,

I am looking for my first 250cc motorcycle and I would like your experienced opinions about resell value and maintenance costs.

I have fallen a bit in love with the Kawasaki Ninja 250r and the Hyosung GT 250 naked. If I were to ask you which one to chose you would all say "baby ninja" and "Superior Japanese quality versus inferior korean quality". And that is completely fair.

However I am in a situation where the Hyosung seems to have taken a duck in the price and are therefore vastly cheaper. And therefore I am in doubt.

The three bikes I can chose from are:

Kawasaki Ninja 250r

  • Used, 2008 edition
  • 10.500 km / 6.500 miles
  • 4.000 USD

Kawasaki Ninja 250r

  • Used, 2011 edition
  • 6.000 km / 3.700 miles
  • 5.000 USD

Hyosung GT 250 naked

  • New, 2014 edition
  • 0 km / 0 miles
  • 3800 USD

My questions to you guys are:

  1. In your opinion, how far would the Hyosung have to go down in price to be viewed as a favorable bike compared to the Kawasaki?

  2. What would you estimate the resell values for these bikes are?(New price for the Kawasaki is 7.500 USD)

  3. Are there a difference in maintenance costs for a new bike vs old bike? Any hidden costs?

I am currently leaning on the Hyosung as I prefer the naked look. I am also 6.2" tall and I understand that the Hyosung has a larger and better suited frame for me. Also I am a new rider and I doubt that I would feel all the technical details in the riding experience to justify the price difference for the expensive Kawasaki.

Thanks for reading.

Posted Feb 6, 2015, 7:50 PM UTC

112
elkster88FJR, 2*KLR, EX250, Vespa Ciao•

I'd take the used 2008 EX250 for $4k over a brand new Hyosung 250 for $3.8k any day of the week.

No idea what the resale value is of the Hyosung but the used prices of the EX250 tell vs. the new price of the Hyosung should tell you it's not going to go up and they're (meaning the EX250s) not going to go down very much.

6
PsadaOP•

I'd take the used 2008 EX250 for $4k over a brand new Hyosung 250 for $3.8k any day of the week.

Interesting, why is that?

Is it based on a previous personal experience with Hyosung or other peoples impressions/experiences?

And would you ever even consider a Hyosung over a Kawasaki?

1
elkster88FJR, 2*KLR, EX250, Vespa Ciao•

I have owned two EX250s, a '99 and an '09. I've looked closely at the Hyosung 250 at bike shows. I was not impressed. I've been riding and working on all sorts of bikes for close to 40 years.

The Hyosung dealer network is far smaller, so parts availability might be problematic. The Kawasaki is a known quantity, has a very large dealer network worldwide and a great reputation for quality. To be honest, the Hyosung would have to be much cheaper to even merit consideration.

The used values already tell the story. A 7 year old used EX250 is worth almost as much as a brand new Hyosung. Ask yourself why that is. 10k km is really not that much, if the bike's been taken care of. If it's had regular oil changes and its first valve clearance check/adjustment, the engine will be practically like new.

4
PsadaOP•

Thanks for the elaboration and explanation.

You're definitely right that the price tells a story but I guess I am doubting its accuracy.

A price may be set higher to impose quality in markets where the price is viewed as a quality indicator. I am wondering how much of that price is merely "percieved" value and not real, tangible value.

It is not a secret that Korean quality has been frowned upon but I have also read that Hyosung has worked on the quality since 2007. It may take a while form to change the view and the percieved value won't change untill then.

1
elkster88FJR, 2*KLR, EX250, Vespa Ciao•

Perception is reality, when it comes to resale value. It really has little to do with the objective measurable qualities of the bikes.

I am assuming that since you supplied the prices, and you know your local market conditions, that those prices are close to what you would actually have to pay. If you believe you could buy any of the bikes for less than the quoted prices, by all means do so.

Asking prices are not in lockstep with actual sale prices but they generally do track each other.

1
CrayolaS7CBR600RR•

Unfortunately perception matters more for resale value than actual quality, while the newer Hyosung will be built just as well as the 2008 Ninja 250 (which is when they had just updated it...) it won't matter. That's not to say the Hyosung is a better bike, it's underpowered and doesn't have the suspension to match it's weight and size, apparently, but the frame is bigger than the Ninja so may be more comfortable to you as a bigger rider.

1
HayaBrosa•

Hey Bro

I feel you trying to save money and all. If you buy the Ninja and keep it for a couple years, you'll be able to sell it for close to what you bought it for.

If you buy the Hyo and keep it for a couple years, you'll lose half the value at least.

Korea is okay and all but Hyo isn't man. All the Hyos that I've seen age like a crack whore in a time machine.

l8r Bro!

1
pudjamsAprilia RS250, Hornet 600•

I used to own a GT250 (2008, so the newer one may be better), and I can tell you the ninja is a much better bike. The weak points of the Hyo are:

  1. Poor suspension. The front is way too soft and underdamped, meaning it loves to bottom out. I can't comment on the back because the shock on mine was knackered and I couldn't be bothered fixing it.

  2. The frame is weak. They are known to have moderate frame flex that gets worse as they get older. Mine would wobble in any hard corner, or pretty much any corner over 90 kph.

  3. The brakes are really bad, especially the single disk on the naked. Wooden, feel-less, spongy and weak.

  4. They are heavy for a 250, almost 20 kg heavier than the Ninja.

  5. The factory Shinko tires suck in the rain.

Good points:

  1. Good fuel economy. I never saw worse than 3.8 l/100km and I thrashed the piss out of mine.

  2. Reliable (mine at least). They were pretty bad when they were introduced, but they have improved a lot. Mine was almost faultlessly reliable with me thrashing the piss out of it.

  3. Simple to maintain.

  4. Bigger than the Ninja, good if you are a bigger person.

You have to keep in mind that this won't be your last bike, when it comes time to sell you will get more money for the Ninja than the Hyo, which may offset the difference in purchase price. I would buy a ninja personally, but it's up to you.

EDIT: didn't see the prices and that the Hyo is new. Get the Ninja, new Hyosungs hemorage resale value.

3
wakamonkaKawasaki ER6F, Hyosung GT250Ri•

The build quality of the Hyosung is cheaper indeed. It fares ok and is very fun to ride, but some stuff breaks now and then. I put 56000km on it and the clutch basket was worn down enough that the clutch plates wiggled back and forth. I don't think that should happen on a 250cc bike, someone correct me.

The resale value at that point was close to zero, but I think it's true for most 250cc bikes with that mileage.

I'd say financially the Hyosung doesn't make sense. If that's not a problem then go for it.

Personally, if I had to do it all over again I'd probably get a used restricted Kawasaki ER-6N.

2
PsadaOP•

Oh, and I come from Denmark so the prices are translated and obviously not comparable to the american prices. There is a lot of taxes going on, so it might be best to ignore it :)

1
muchADEWCB300F•

Might I suggest the Honda CB300F? It looks similar to the Hyosung GT250 (naked), but I think it's much better build quality. CB300F's MSRP is $3,999, but I got mine for $3,709 ($3826 OTD).

1
CrayolaS7CBR600RR•

The build quality on a 2014 Hyosung will be pretty good, if not better than the Honda. The CB300Fs is cheap as hell for a Japanese bike and that's because it's made with relatively cheaper parts in a low cost country (Thailand), you can't expect it to have the same quality as a CBR1000RR costing 4 times as much.

1
muchADEWCB300F•

Well, Honda's CBs were made in China for decades, and they developed a reputation for reliability, so I'll take my chances.

1