an alternative to 24 word phrases
edit(looks like fake words are already implemented. letter only might still be a nice enhancement)
Regarding TREZOR's recovery mode, in which the user's PC is assumed to be hostile, and attempting to glean the user's wallet mnemonic during trezor setup.
Using random ordering of the mnem phrase words, with only 12 words, there are 479 million possible wallets, which is a very searcheable space. with 24 words, the space is 620 sextillion, which is arguably harder to search (for 100k guesses per second the former takes an hour, the latter 2billion centuries)
So it's clear that 24 words is superior for this use case. However, for another use case it is detrimental: The problem is the 24 words is significantly harder to memorize as a mnemonic, significantly increasing the risk of forgetting.
There may be an alternative that works for both use cases: during recovery the trezor firmware could randomly mix in 6-12 arbitrary words, in addition to the random ordering. Each recovery phrase is padded up to at least 24 words length, and the trezor itself uses its yes/no buttons to let the user set the length expected, so the hostile computer has no idea.
I think this would provide security equivalent to a 24 word phrase, but put less strain on user's ability to memorize the phrase.
(Of course, allowing direct input without being connected to a computer would be best. micro-keyboard & stylus)
Posted Feb 7, 2015, 7:11 PM UTC · edited