"I" has as many unique meanings as there are English speakers.

And then some for fiction.

It's weird how natural it is to let everyone use the same pronoun without getting confused about it.

Posted Feb 18, 2015, 4:07 AM UTC

1611
itswestime•

This is really how you understand that? The meaning is not unique for each person, it's the same for each person. Referring to "oneself" as the object of a sentence. Not referring to "bill, bob, jane, jessy, john".

1
animate_objectOP•

When you say I, you are presumably referring to a different real life object than when I say I. That's what I'm talking about. This is a shower thought not a linguistics thesis.

1
itswestime•

sure its not a pot thought?

1
7LBoots•

Pought?

1
animate_objectOP•

Shh.

0
itswestime•

omg i just had a shower thought as well. It's amazing that when I say "you" anybody can understand who i'm talking about at all! Because.. get this.. "you" could be anybody who speaks English.

1

What is "it"? I'm confused. I'm also confused when someone asks for a glass of water.
Everyone wants a different glass and different water.
Life is hard.

1
animate_objectOP•

I specifically want your glass of water, actually. What now?

1

Do you have PayPal?

2
animate_objectOP•

I don't know, do I?

1

Do who?

1