Matt_MG•
7
efranorTalhoffer•

My statement exactly.

1
Silver_AgocchieBolognese Sidesword•

"“For us it’s about honoring, preserving, and reigniting interest in weapons-based martial arts — arts that have sort of slowly drifted off of people’s radar since the invention of gunpowder and projectile weapons,” explains UWM co-founder and CEO David Pysden. “Since then, there’s been no forum in which to see weapons-based marital arts practiced, and we want to change that.”

Says the man who had never looked into HEMA before marketing this project. It's almost insulting.

5
LordAcorn•

on the other hand i bet hema folks will be doing a lot of winning if this ever actually takes off

6
Hussard•

Says the man who had never looked into HEMA before marketing this project. It's almost insulting.

That being said, HEMA has had no PR in Australia. Most people don't even think of it as a martial art, let alone search the terms 'historical+european'. Unless you are connected to the online community in a big way, you won't hear of it - or if you do, its in relation to LARP or the SCA.

2
Silver_AgocchieBolognese Sidesword•

Yes, but I would think that someone how is specifically looking to "resurrect" and "preserve" weapon based martial arts would have spent ten minutes on google to find organizations already doing so. This give me the feeling he's doing it for nothing other than the spectacle, and care very little about the martial arts.

He says "But more importantly, when the knights were fighting back in the medieval days, they weren’t throwing kicks to the head. They were generally on horses or on foot, and typically weren’t using marital arts as part of their combat."

This is ignorance and insulting.

9
boredidiotMelbourne, AU / Fiore / 18C Backsword•

On the very day they announced it I spoke to them, I offered them resources and gave them a list of all the SME in their home town (Sydney) and all the groups in Australia.

There attitude was "oh yeah that is nice, lets talk about it in a few months"

Next contact was asking me to advertise their fundraising efforts and said they had all the experts in HEMA that they needed (but could not tell me who they were other than they worked on LotR).

Since then everything they post is a perfect example of ignorant people claiming expertise.

5
Hussard•

I would argue that Stoccata might not have looked 'professional' enough for their boardroom.

3
Hussard•

To us, yes. But if you weren't at all scholarly you shouldn't even know about fechtbuchs and would have only Hollywood as your medieval fighting background.

Look at all the people that lost their shit at how awesome we looked in that NYTimes article. People have no idea about us. Our PR sucks.

4
Silver_AgocchieBolognese Sidesword•

A fair point. I suppose it is just frustrating that we have all the art and know how but none of the marketing, while he has all the marketing but none of the art.

My main point of concern is this: along with all the people who thought the NYT article/video was really interesting and exciting, there were still many people who reacted along the lines of "that's not real sword fighting..." then spout one of the many popular misconceptions of HEMA. For them and the population at large, this UWM stuff will legitimize their false notion of european martial arts, which is a discredit to their culture and history (assuming they are Western). If this gets big, it will make all our efforts at PR so much harder because we "don't do real sword fightin', likes what's I saw on the TV"

4
boredidiotMelbourne, AU / Fiore / 18C Backsword•

Not surprising, we have no professional body with no dedicated marketing resources and low or no budget to work with one.

When people market, most just market their own school and there are few are are willing to market HEMA.

4
FuriousJester•

The original two fighters haven't even based their martial arts on European Martial Arts. It's all focused on McDojo Western Martial Arts.

2
electricsoma•

The UWM team did accept an invite to Swordplay in Brisbane last year. This article was posted a few months before that event so any thoughts toward HEMA may have changed. My impression was they were keen to interact with HEMA and were interested in making sure their system could cover our style of combat. Perhaps because of that I'm positive about the project. UWM is not HEMA but it is something HEMA could easily interact with as a way to showcase our top competitors.

I also suspect if their plans for the armour work out it could provide HEMA a way to safely fight with polearms/halberds. Time will tell with that one.

2
Hussard•

I do seem to recall something about on the WMAA FB page but nothing else was heard since. But yeah, if the kit's good enough, it might be one way of dealing with the whole polearms issue.

2
angrystuff•

The have been approached by both hema and botn

1
zn95•

Got excited when I read the title and then saw the thumbnail was the stupid fantasy suits from the thing reposted every month :v

5
LangSawrd•

They mention piezoelectric sensors, to determine intensity of hit. Sounds like it'll be about percussive force doing hit point damage, and an insufficient consideration for lethal or debilitating slices.

4
angrystuff•

This is exactly right. It's just as artifical as any other system . Frankly speaking we could just wire up fighters like Olympic fence and we would get something largely the same

6
TanithArmoured•

I was really excited about this, but this thread has killed my interest :'(

1
VennificusNewfoundland, Canada•

The r/martialarts thread is worse and a few of the ones on the HEMAA fb page are worse still

1