[Elementary Statistics ] Residuals: did the professor make an error or am I just incorrect?

This is a question on a practice exam.

I was pretty sure with my answer but I guess I got it wrong. According to StatTreck, a residual is:

the difference between the observed value of the dependent variable (y) and the predicted value (ŷ)

Shouldn't my response be correct if this is what a residual is defined as? Thanks in advance for your help!

Posted Feb 22, 2015, 11:41 PM UTC · edited

25
PetPiggie•

Hmm, I'm not completely sure if I'm correct, but if you draw the line of best fit, the predicted value for the second graph would be a line sloping upwards toward point B, while the line of best fit for the first graph would not be near point A.

1
CagedZebraOP•

Exactly, thus the difference between the observed value and the predicted value would be greater than that of point a. So point b would produce the largest residual, correct?

1
PetPiggie•

Hmm, just so you know, I'm just giving my thoughts on this, I'm also a student and I didn't see any replies so I though maybe I would try to help out. I kind of explained by thoughts in this picture: http://imgur.com/MD7r2oO

i'm assuming the predicted value (ŷ), is the lines i drew.

so if my understanding is correct, I think you could argue that your answer is correct. (but im no expert, it would probably be better to wait for someone else to share their thoughts).

edit: now that i think about it, you are probably correct, who even labels

a) point b

b) point a

probably a typo

1
nkbxwb•

Look up leverage point and outlier. Those terms might help you better understand why the answer they have is correct.

1
CagedZebraOP•

Can you help me out a bit more? I saw a nearly identical problem in a study packet and it stated my answer was correct.

1