In recent years the Taliban and in current news ISIS have been destroying historical artefacts and libraries which don't fit into their world view; did the Christian world embark in similar activities during the "dark ages" or any other period?

I remember reading about the systemic destruction of Mayan artefacts by the Catholic church including their codices*, but was this a generalised practice carried out in Europe, or just the new world? If so what were some of the most important artefacts to have been lost in this way?

*edit: codices is the plural of codex apparently...

Posted Feb 23, 2015, 12:10 AM UTC · edited

329
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
jschooltigerShipbuilding and Logistics | British Navy 1770-1830•

Do you have a non-Wikipedia source for your contention about Beowulf?

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
jschooltigerShipbuilding and Logistics | British Navy 1770-1830•

First off, that resource is from 1897 and has no bearing on later scholarship of the period (I was lucky enough to study for a period with John Miles Foley, one of the foremost researchers on oral tradition). Second, the Wiki link doesn't even say what you're attempting to say:

It is generally believed that Beowulf is the result of a Christian transcriber... "reworking" the narrative to fit better with Christian Orthodoxy.

No. One school of thought about Beowulf is that it may have been written by a scribe who was Christian and threw in pagan references. What you're asserting, based apparently on some quick and incomplete Googling, is that there was a deliberate effort by Christian scribes to alter a work to fit into a new tradition, which completely misses the point of how oral tradition works and in any case is a discredited view.

2
madjic•

The felling of the Donareiche (Thor's oak) in Germany by St Bonifatius comes to mind.

Follow up: Wikipedia says, many churches in Germany (Europe?) were simply built in place of older holy places (groves, Menhirs). How would this 'usually' happen during the christianization period? Were the people (forcefully?) converted and a church built there to prevent them from going back to their old gods? Or driven out and replaced with faithful christians? Or would a tribe leader express his submission under Frankish rule by building a church?

1
grantimatter•

This isn't exactly the same, but there was the business with the Iconoclasts, who went around within the Eastern Church destroying anything that could be construed as a "graven image" - including likenesses and relics of the saints - partially as a response to Islamic bans on images, but also as a way to potentially gain Jewish and Muslim converts... or at least to bring the empire into accordance with the rules laid out in Exodus.

Byzantine Emperor Leo III was responsible for the peak of iconoclasm. Here, as described in the Catholic Encyclopedia:

In 726 Leo III published an edict declaring images to be idols, forbidden by Exodus 20:4-5, and commanding all such images in churches to be destroyed. At once the soldiers began to carry out his orders, whereby disturbances were provoked throughout the empire. There was a famous picture of Christ, called Christos antiphonetes, over the gate of the palace at Constantinople. The destruction of this picture provoked a serious riot among the people. Germanus, the patriarch, protested against the edict and appealed to the pope (729). But the emperor deposed him as a traitor (730) and had Anastasius (730-54), formerly syncellus of the patriarchal Court, and a willing instrument of the Government, appointed in his place. The most steadfast opponents of the Iconoclasts throughout this story were the monks. It is true that there were some who took the side of the emperor but as a body Eastern monasticism was steadfastly loyal to the old custom of the Church. Leo therefore joined with his Iconoclasm a fierce persecution of monasteries and eventually tried to suppress monasticism altogether.

A similar wave of iconoclasm followed during the Protestant Reformation around 700 years later.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1