r/Christianity•
Deien

Do people who go to hell realize the error of their ways?

While in Hell, do people form a higher understanding of what they did in their lives to deserve this judgement? Or do they continue to believe they are being unjustly punished? Or does it vary? Because what is the point of punishment if the recipient doesn't understand why he's being punished?

Posted Mar 1, 2015, 1:16 AM UTC

37
WiseChoicesChristian (Cross)•

In the parable, the rich man desperately wanted someone to go warn his family not to follow him to Hell. So he seems to have full memory of his life and realize his mistake. And he knew Lazarus from their time shared in life.

4
PrettyPoltergeistEvangelical•

Most likely. But it's not really a punishment. It's a consequence, in the same way getting burned is a consequence of touching the stove. You can regret it, but you can't unburn yourself. In the same way, once Judgement Day comes and goes those people will not have another chance.

1
MrsChimpGod•

They probably just try to make the best of it.

1
adecentchristianChristian (Cross)•

Universalists believe that all people will eventually repent and accept Jesus and go to heaven.

0
FlareCorranChristian (Chi Rho)•

Not all punishment is restorative. Even in Scripture, God punishes the Israelites by killing some of them on numerous occasions. He strikes Ananias and Saphira dead and causes Herod to be eaten by worms. None of these things were for the benefit of those punished, they were done because they were the just consequences of sin. The Biblical view of justice is retributive. Love is what brings restoration, not justice.

So it is unnecessary to their punishment for them to know why they are being punished. And, in fact, it's likely that they persist throughout time believing that they are being punished unjustly, refusing to admit that it is their own rebellion against God that caused their condition. Some, in fact, argue that when given the choice between Heaven and Hell, the damned voluntarily choose Hell, because God is the sole and singular focus of Heaven. You cannot have Heaven without Him, so those who have rebelled and rejected salvation prefer Hell to Heaven.

0
DeienOP•

For none of us liveth to himself, and no man dieth to himself. 8For whether we live, we live unto the Lord; and whether we die, we die unto the Lord: whether we live therefore, or die, we are the Lord's. 9For to this end Christ both died, and rose, and revived, that he might be Lord both of the dead and living.

But what about that verse in Romans 14? Do correct me if I'm wrong but what i interpret from that is that sinners will come to know the Lord in the end. And what man, in the face of that which is pure and good can examine his own life and not see the sin in which he is steeped? And those verses are followed by this well-known one: For it is written, As I live, saith the Lord, every knee shall bow to me, and every tongue shall confess to God.

From which I infer that every man must know and confess his sins. But what I don't know is whether a full understanding of that sin comes to those who have not repented. And how sincere that confession is? For why would God want to hear an insincere confession, because he would know the true nature of that man's heart.

And if God is Love, why doesn't he lead all men to salvation? If he loves all men, why would he allow them to suffer in hell forever? Why wouldn't He show them the love in life which would allow them to be restored to Him?

1
Raptor-LlamaOrthodox Inquirer•

They aren't being punished by God, they are experiencing God's love as fire because they hate him. Their sins consume them, especially pride, so the more one stays in hell the less aware they become of their sin (and the more it consumes them).

If they became aware of their sin and repented, they would be forgiven of course. Is that possible? I don't know. They could also know they did wrong and not repent though, by either blaming God for how they ended up or convincing themselves they can't be forgiven.

0